New York’s U.S. Bankruptcy Court Rules MERS’s Business Model Is Illegal



Professor of Economics and Research Director of the Center for Full Employment and Price Stability, University of Missouri–Kansas City


Posted: February 16, 2011 03:00 PM

United States Bankruptcy Judge Robert Grossman has ruled that MERS’s business practices are unlawful. He explicitly acknowledged that this ruling sets a precedent that has far-reaching implications for half of the mortgages in this country. MERS is dead. The banks are in big trouble. And all foreclosures should be stopped immediately while the legislative branch comes up with a solution.

For some weeks I have been arguing that MERS is perpetrating foreclosure fraud all across the nation. Its business model makes it impossible to legally foreclose on any mortgaged property registered within its system — which includes half of the outstanding mortgages in the US. MERS was a fraud from day one, whose purpose was to evade property recording fees and to subvert five centuries of property law. Its chickens have come home to roost.

Wall Street wanted to transform America’s housing sector into the world’s biggest casino and needed to undermine property rights to make it easier to run the scam. The payoffs were bigger for lenders who could induce homeowners to take mortgages they could not possibly afford. The mortgages were packaged into securities sold-on to patsy investors who were defrauded by the “reps and warranties” falsely certifying the securities as backed by top grade loans. In fact the securities were not backed by mortgages, and in any case the mortgages were sure to go bad. Given that homeowners would default, the Wall Street banks that serviced the mortgages needed a foreclosure steamroller to quickly and cheaply throw families out of the homes so that they could be resold to serve as purported collateral for yet more gambling bets. MERS — the industry’s creation — stepped up to the plate to facilitate the fraud. The judge has ruled that its practices are illegal. MERS and the banks lose; investors and homeowners win.

Here’s MERS’s business model in brief. Real estate property sales and mortgages are supposed to be recorded in local recording offices, with fees paid. With the rise of securitization, each mortgage might be sold a dozen times before it came to rest as the collateral behind a mortgage backed security (MBS), and each of those sales would need to be recorded. MERS was created to bypass public recording; it would be listed in the county records as the “mortgagee of record” and the “nominee” of the holder of mortgage. Members of MERS could then transfer the mortgage from one to another without all the trouble of changing the local records, simply by (voluntarily) recording transactions on MERS’s registry.

A mortgage has two parts, the “note” and the “security” (not to be confused with the MBS) or “deed of trust” that is usually just called the “mortgage”. The idea behind MERS was that the “note” would be transferred from seller to purchaser, but the “mortgage” would be held by MERS. In fact, MERS recommended that the “note” be held by the mortgage servicer to facilitate foreclosures, but in practice it seems that the notes were often lost or destroyed (which is why all those Burger King Kids were hired to Robo-sign “lost note affidavits”).

At each transfer, the note and mortgage are supposed to be “assigned” to the new owner; MERS claimed that because it was the “mortgagee of record” and the “nominee” of both parties to every transaction, there was no need to assign the “mortgage” until foreclosure. And it argued that since the old adage is that the “mortgage follows the note” and that both parties intended to assign the notes (even if they did not get around to doing it), then the Bankruptcy Court should rule that the assignments did take place in some sort of “virtual reality” so that there is a clear chain of title that allows the servicers to foreclose.

The Judge rejected every aspect of MERS’s argument. The Court rejected the claim that MERS could be both holder of the mortgage as well as nominee of the “true” owner. It also found that “mortgagee of record” is a vague term that does not give one legal standing as mortgagee. Hence, at best, MERS is only a nominee. It rejected MERS’s claim that as nominee it can assign notes or mortgages — a nominee has limited rights and those most certainly do not include the right to transfer ownership unless there is specific written instruction to do so. In scarcely veiled anger, the Judge wrote:

“According to MERS, the principal/agent relationship among itself and its members is created by the MERS rules of membership and terms and conditions, as well as the Mortgage itself. However, none of the documents expressly creates an agency relationship or even mentions the word “agency.” MERS would have this Court cobble together the documents and draw inferences from the words contained in those documents.”

Judge Grossman rejected MERS’s arguments, saying that mere membership in MERS does not provide “agency” rights to MERS, and agreeing with the Supreme Court of Kansas that ruled “The parties appear to have defined the word [nominee] in much the same way that the blind men of Indian legend described an elephant — their description depended on which part they were touching at any given time.”

Read the  rest  of  the article  here  :

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/l-randall-wray/new-yorks-us-bankruptc...

Views: 38

Reply to This

Latest Activity

the mighty bull posted videos
5 minutes ago
cheeki kea favorited Chris of the family Masters's video
44 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters posted videos
2 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on Chris of the family Masters's video
2 hours ago
MAC posted a video

Creepy Joe Biden has a Very Serious Privilege Problem on His Hands

Now more then ever we need your help keeping this channel producing REAL content for REAL people https://www.paypal.me/ConservativeResurge Joe Biden's senior...
3 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on James T. Kirk's video
4 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters favorited James T. Kirk's video
4 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters favorited Phyllis Maka's blog post Who Are 'They' really? These Scandalous Troublemakers! Want To Rule & Hog Every Leetle Thing In Sight, Every Where They Go!
4 hours ago
Raz Putin favorited rlionhearted_3's photo
6 hours ago
Raz Putin commented on Phyllis Maka's blog post Who Are 'They' really? These Scandalous Troublemakers! Want To Rule & Hog Every Leetle Thing In Sight, Every Where They Go!
"AshkeNAZIS Khazarian Mafia indeed."
6 hours ago
Raz Putin favorited Phyllis Maka's blog post Who Are 'They' really? These Scandalous Troublemakers! Want To Rule & Hog Every Leetle Thing In Sight, Every Where They Go!
6 hours ago
Diana's 4 photos were featured
6 hours ago
Old Denmark's video was featured
6 hours ago
the mighty bull's video was featured

Wild Horses in New Zealand | DJI MAVIC AIR

Spot these WILD HORSES in the Aupouri Forest - Far North! About 50 years ago, they escaped from farmers paddocks and bred amongst themselves. Subscribe to ou...
6 hours ago
Burbia's video was featured

('79) Timothy Leary, Al Hubbard, Oz Janiger, Humphry Osmond, Sidney Cohen (& more) party

Al Hubbard is the man in the officer's uniform; he's "captain trips," and he's the "johnny appleseed" of hallucinogens. Humphry Osmond is the charming Englis...
6 hours ago
Raz Putin's video was featured
6 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer's video was featured

Why magnesium is so good for you

In this video, i talk about magnesium and why it is so very good for the heart and yet why we take in so little of it. My name is sanjay Gupta and i am a car...
6 hours ago
Raz Putin commented on James T. Kirk's video
Thumbnail

Ukraine: New President Zelensky disbands parliament upon inauguration | DW News

"Curious to see who Zelensky is actually aligned with. "
6 hours ago
Raz Putin favorited James T. Kirk's video
6 hours ago
Raz Putin's discussion was featured

Fluoride Action Network: "LAUNCHES NEW FUNDRAISER AS TSCA FLUORIDE LAWSUIT GAINS STEAM"

Fluoride Action Network: "LAUNCHES NEW FUNDRAISER AS TSCA FLUORIDE LAWSUIT GAINS STEAM""We are now entering the final phase before our historic trial begins. The stakes are high, as this legal challenge could be our best chance to end fluoridation…See More
6 hours ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted