Axel Voss, The man behind the EU’s copyright law is “surprised” by what’s in the proposal

UH OH

The man behind the EU’s copyright law is “surprised” by what’s in the proposal

3 hours ago


h
Rapporteur on copyright MEP Axel Voss celebrates—but perhaps not for long.

The European Union Parliament on Sept. 12 voted to approve new copyright laws that will transform how people in Europe and beyond use and profit from the internet. But even the man behind the legislation, Axel Voss, was apparently unaware of what exactly he voted for.

Emanuel Karisten, a reporter for Sweden’s Breakit news site, spoke with Voss, a Member of the European Parliament (MEP) and the EU’s copyright rapporteur, after the vote. Karisten asked about a last-minute amendment that will bar the filming of sports events. The MEP replied in a recorded conversation, “This was kind of mistake I think by the JURI committee. Someone amended this. No one had been aware of this.”

European Parliament press officer John Schranz at that point broke in to explain that he was aware of the provision in question, calling it “amendment 76.” Schranz said that the amendment doesn’t bar individuals from filming sporting events. Rather, “the main target” is online betting companies enticing viewers to their sites with video that they have no right to film. He objected to the fact that the “Greens and others” interpret the provision as having a much wider application.

But the MEP Voss admitted, “I didn’t know that this was in the proposal so far, so of course I have to deal with it now. I do not consider that the commission and council will have this inside the proposal.” Voss added that “because of the time pressure” and general focus on other, more notable aspects of the law, it’s possible that the measure was insufficiently scrutinized. But he reassured Karisten that MEPs will be meeting again to go over the law in its entirety. “Of course we have to discuss this,” he said of the provision in question.  

Voss isn’t kidding when he says he’s been busy. The controversial Copyright Directive, which aims to compensate content creators and limit intellectual property violators, was rejected in July. Two sections of the legislation in particular have been in dispute—Article 11, which would charge a link tax to news aggregators, and Article 13, which would require platforms to install software that reviews content for copyright violations.

Vocal opponents, including tech giants like Google, Facebook, and Apple as well as internet pioneers like Vint Cerf, argue that the law will stifle the flow of information on the web and turn corporations into intellectual property police, using technology that’s insufficiently nuanced for the task. Meanwhile, supporters—musicians, filmmakers, news publishers—say the law would right an imbalance online and ensure that content creators are compensated for their contributions to culture.

Karisten notes that MEPs complained at a press conference after the vote yesterday that Facebook and Google tried to manipulate their votes with email campaigns, ignoring the fact that messages were also sent by concerned individuals. “They do not believe people in Europe really are worried about what this directive will bring,” the Swedish reporter contends.

He tells Quartz that Voss’s surprise about the sport filming provision is indicative of a much larger problem. “I was actually flabbergasted by my time in the parliament. It exceeded my worst fears about the competence of the MEPs handling of this directive.” With over 250 amendments up for vote, the MEPs were likely overwhelmed. Karisten suggests, “That is a lot more than they are used to. But still: [Schranz] knew about this very amendment, when Voss did not. So this is something that was meant to be there—for some reason, by someone’s concern. It is mind-boggling that Voss voted for it, when he really thought it was a bad idea.”

The reporter believes the copyright rapporteur was either deceived or indifferent. Either way, that’s not a great sign.

Views: 51

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Latest Activity

Marklar's Ghost replied to dogitydog's discussion Why Is This Being Celebrated?
"Apparently old meat is tenderized, young meat is genderized."
13 minutes ago
Diana commented on Old Denmark's video
Thumbnail

YELLOW VESTED AMERICAN TELLS OFF PRO ILLEGAL ALIEN LA COUNTY SHERIFF ALEX VILLANUEVA

"The Supreme Court has said that police have no obligation to protect citizens beyond that which the police themselves decide, either individually or at the departmental level.  So there you have it, the Sheriff has made his decision. "
17 minutes ago
Marklar's Ghost replied to Chris of the family Masters's discussion Alert to all Americans: Prepare for emergency action in the 3D world… the orchestrated assault on your mind, your country and your president is approaching its final chapter
"The request for a link to the 3d world was just a joke Chris."
20 minutes ago
Diana favorited Old Denmark's video
27 minutes ago
Boris posted a video
35 minutes ago
Diana posted photos
38 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on Doc Vega's blog post Income Tax Really? And The Illusion You've Been Fed!
"'Income' Tax- "income is a profit derived from operating business" Wage earners, although the people, have been turned into corporations, e.g JOHN BROWN. It's been diabolical scam, working due to the widespread…"
1 hour ago
Old Denmark posted a video
1 hour ago
Chris of the family Masters favorited Doc Vega's blog post Income Tax Really? And The Illusion You've Been Fed!
1 hour ago
Chris of the family Masters replied to Chris of the family Masters's discussion Alert to all Americans: Prepare for emergency action in the 3D world… the orchestrated assault on your mind, your country and your president is approaching its final chapter
1 hour ago
Diana favorited Doc Vega's blog post Income Tax Really? And The Illusion You've Been Fed!
2 hours ago
Diana posted videos
3 hours ago
Marklar's Ghost replied to Chris of the family Masters's discussion Alert to all Americans: Prepare for emergency action in the 3D world… the orchestrated assault on your mind, your country and your president is approaching its final chapter
"Could you please provide a link to this 3D world of which yo speak?"
3 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer favorited honeygirl's video
3 hours ago
Doc Vega commented on Less Prone's blog post Students threatened to be fined for refusing to watch a homoerotic movie in Kokkola Finland
"Oh My God! Keep the can of Crisco warm Ducky!"
3 hours ago
Doc Vega commented on Doc Vega's blog post Income Tax Really? And The Illusion You've Been Fed!
"Raz Putin Thanks man!"
3 hours ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted