Bioethicist opinion: Science proves kids are bad for earth; morality suggests we stop having them

Bioethicist opinion: Science proves kids are bad for earth; morality suggests we stop having them

travis rieder

Travis and his child in his Twitter profile picture

The author of this opinion piece, Travis Rieder, PhD, is the Assistant Director for Education Initiatives, Director of the Master of Bioethics degree program and Research Scholar at the Berman Institute of Bioethics. He is also a Faculty Affiliate at the Center for Public Health Advocacy within the Johns Hopkins School of Public Health.

From NBC News: A startling and honestly distressing view is beginning to receive serious consideration in both academic and popular discussions of climate change ethics. According to this view, having a child is a major contributor to climate change. The logical takeaway here is that everyone on Earth ought to consider having fewer children.

Although culturally controversial, the scientific half of this position is fairly well-established. Several years ago, scientists showed that having a child, especially for the world’s wealthy, is one of the worst things you can do for the environment. That data was recycled this past summer in a paper showing that none of the activities most likely to reduce individuals’ carbon footprints are widely discussed.

The second, moral aspect of the view — that perhaps we ought to have fewer children — is also being taken seriously in many circles. Indeed, I have written widely on the topic myself.

But scientific evidence and moral theorizing aside, this is a complicated question with plenty of opponents. In what follows, I will address some of the challenges to this idea. Because while I recognize that this is an uncomfortable discussion, I believe that the seriousness of climate change justifies uncomfortable conversations. In this case, that means that we need to stop pretending the decision to have children doesn’t have environmental and ethical consequences.

The argument that having a child adds to one’s carbon footprint depends on the view that each of us has a personal carbon ledger for which we are responsible. Furthermore, some amount of an offspring’s emissions count towards the parents’ ledger.

Most environmentalists accept this sort of ledger view when it comes to recycling, driving, and flying, but support begins to decrease when applied to family planning. The opposition is typified by Vox writer David Roberts, who argues that “such an accounting scheme is utterly impractical” because it seems to entail that one is never responsible for one’s own emissions. Because “we don’t want to double-count,” as Roberts says, this means parents are really only responsible for their kids’ emissions.

The flaw in this objection is the plausible-sounding caveat: “we don’t want to double-count.” Because why wouldn’t we want to double-count? If moral responsibility added up mathematically, then double-counting would be a serious problem. But I think it’s clear that we should not accept a mathematical model of responsibility.

Consider a different case: If I release a murderer from prison, knowing full well that he intends to kill innocent people, then I bear some responsibility for those deaths — even though the killer is also fully responsible. My having released him doesn’t make him less responsible (he did it!). But his doing it doesn’t eliminate my responsibility either.

Something similar is true, I think, when it comes to having children: Once my daughter is an autonomous agent, she will be responsible for her emissions. But that doesn’t negate my responsibility. Moral responsibility simply isn’t mathematical.

If you buy this view of responsibility, you might eventually admit that having many children is wrong, or at least morally suspect, for standard environmental reasons: Having a child imposes high emissions on the world, while the parents get the benefit. So like with any high-cost luxury, we should limit our indulgence.

Read the rest of this opinion here.

DCG

Views: 86

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by DTOM on November 20, 2017 at 8:08am

@Diana

On one hand the PTB demand population reduction, while on the other hand they tell us the West needs cultural enrichment from open borders immigration to compensate for low birth levels - it's not hard to work out the real agenda.

“In searching for a common enemy against whom we can unite, we came up with the idea that pollution, the threat of global warming, water shortages, famine and the like would fit the bill…. All these dangers are caused by human intervention… The real enemy, then, is humanity itself,”

https://12160.info/profiles/blogs/club-of-rome-group-that-admitted-...

https://12160.info/forum/topics/royal-society-enviro-eugenicists-ca...

Comment by Diana on November 18, 2017 at 1:33pm

Why does he have a kid?  What about his moral responsibility to climate change carbon footprints?  Just like Al Gore's home consuming 34X more energy than an average home, while everyone else should feel guilty.  These people are such hypocrites.

Comment by DTOM on November 18, 2017 at 5:53am
Comment by DTOM on November 18, 2017 at 5:26am

More 'carbon' lies...as Fukushima continues to kill the Pacific...and nothing is said or done.

If Rieder and others that spout this crap, believe in it so much, they should set an example, and dispatch themselves and their families immediately.

Latest Activity

Gralton favorited Raz Putin's blog post The Bill Maher NPC Meme "The whole narrative and nothing but"
3 minutes ago
Gralton commented on Raz Putin's blog post The Bill Maher NPC Meme "The whole narrative and nothing but"
"feckin brilliant! he most likely paid someone to do it because his show is in the toilet."
3 minutes ago
Boris favorited Central Scrutinizer's photo
10 minutes ago
Boris commented on Raz Putin's blog post The Bill Maher NPC Meme "The whole narrative and nothing but"
"Bill Maher Blasts ‘Incels’ Who Defaced ‘Real Time’ Billboard with NPC Meme Comedian Bill Maher mocked the “incels” who defaced a promotional billboard for his HBO show Real Time with the “NPC”…"
13 minutes ago
Boris commented on Diana's photo
16 minutes ago
Profile Icon via Twitter
"“We’re at War!” — And We Have Been Since 1776: https://t.co/vl0akAlfrt
Twitter25 minutes ago · Reply · Retweet
Chris of the family Masters commented on Central Scrutinizer's photo
Thumbnail

Only a Bill

"And applies only to legal fiction characters...."
28 minutes ago
cheeki kea replied to Chris of the family Masters's discussion GOP Amnesty Plan Fails After Public Outcry. Trump Pushes Ahead Anyway with Plan to Give 100,000 Foreign Workers ‘Path to Citizenship’ Every Year
"This will drive down wages. They will work for less, and most of them will work over an eight hour day for nothing. Overtime rate will be a thing of the past for sure. (if you let it) Low wages to come."
29 minutes ago
Gralton favorited Burbia's blog post INTENSE VIDEO SHOWS COP SHOOT FLEEING MAN IN THE BACK, THEN GET SWARMED BY ANGRY CITIZENS
30 minutes ago
Gralton favorited Dr. Frederick Meekins's blog post Bill Of Rights Not A Chinese Takeout Menu
33 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer posted photos
34 minutes ago
Gralton favorited Modern Feudal Serf's blog post Yellow Vest || The Law(s) That Broke The Sheeple's Back
34 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on cheeki kea's blog post VAPE LIQUID CAUSED THE LOSS OF MY PENIS, SAYS NEW ZEALAND MAN
"I tried vaping for a short time about a year ago. Didn't like it and stopped. Lucky me...."
35 minutes ago
Profile Icon via Twitter
“We’re at War!” — And We Have Been Since 1776 https://t.co/vl0akAlfrt
Twitter38 minutes ago · Reply · Retweet
Boris commented on DTOM's blog post Native Actors Walk off Set of Adam Sandler Movie After Insults to Women, Elders - Navajo Nation President Condemns Film
"Navajo Code Talker Alfred K. Newman passed away at 94 years old this past Sunday. Newman served with 1st Battalion, 21st Marine Regiment, 3rd Marine Division during WWII, including Iwo Jima, Guam, and other island campaigns. Semper Fi, Marine."
41 minutes ago
cheeki kea posted blog posts
52 minutes ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted