French Thought Police and the Creeping Dictatorship of Virtue By Jean Bricmont

French Thought Police and the Creeping Dictatorship of Virtue

https://www.lewrockwell.com/2018/06/no_author/french-thought-police...

The French government of Emmanuel Macron has introduced a new law to protect the French from “fake news” during election periods. This vaguely drafted amendment to existing press law seems to have been inspired by Macron’s resentment at rumors circulated against him during last year’s presidential election – which didn’t prevent him from winning. Widely opposed by opposition parties from left to right, and by most journalists, this amendment fits in all too well with the growing establishment campaign to censor dissident opinion by one means or another. The main pretext is the copycat Clintonite accusation of Russian “interference in Western elections.”

Applying initially only to election periods, to protect “our democracy”, this attempt to legislate the difference between true and false is a dangerous step in the door toward official censorship. Similar plans to ban “fake news” are brewing on the European level.

The law is superfluous to start with, since the existing 1881 French press law already sanctions insults, defamation and the artificial creation of panic, such as shouting fire in a crowded theater. But Macron’s government wants to go much farther, outlawing the spread of “false information”, obscurely defined as “alleging or lending credibility to a fact lacking verifiable elements of a nature to make it believable”. (…“une allégation ou imputation d’un fait dépourvue d’éléments vérifiables de nature à la rendre vraisemblable”.)

This definition is both unclear and potentially far-reaching.

To start with, a skeptic could ask what are the “verifiable elements” proving the existence of God, of life after death or of the effectiveness of prayer. There goes religion. How about the “verifiable elements” proving the effectiveness of astrology? There go some popular daily newspaper features. Numerous scientists have raised questions as to the “verifiable elements” justifying psychoanalysis without receiving satisfactory answers. Should psychobabble be banned in the name of combatting fake news?

And what should be done with post-modern French philosophy, whose most famous names take psychoanalysis very seriously and pride themselves on leaping to subjective conclusions? No one proliferates more fact-free assertions than Bernard-Henri Lévy, which so far has not interfered with his position on the board of major media from Le Monde to the cultural channel Arte. Humanitarian Imperiali... Jean Bricmont Best Price: $15.17 Buy New $15.95 (as of 09:55 EDT - Details)

But that’s only the beginning. What do we do with scientific theories that have been advanced without experimental confirmation? For example, string theory in physics and various hypotheses in cosmology.

In fact, many scientific discoveries begin with unproven hypotheses. Better not mention them!

And what about mainstream media? In one recent news report after another (Skripal poisoning, chemical weapons attacks in Syria, the falsified murder in Ukraine of an anti-Putin journalist, not to mention the responsibility for firing a missile that shot down a Malaysian airliner in July 2014), there is a big difference between the Western version of the facts and that which prevails in Russia, Malaysia, Syria and much of the non-Western world.

A Mental Border with Russia

Instead of Pascal’s “truth on this side of the Pyrenees, and error on the other side”, we would be establishing “truth on one side of the Mediterranean, error on the other”. Or rather, truth exists up to the Eastern border of NATO, with error on the other side. This is no way to advance toward universal understanding. The only way to resolve our differences with the rest of the world is free discussion. Inasmuch as the law against fake news seems to be designed mainly to counter what Western governments describe as Russian propaganda, there is a strong likelihood that it can only enforce the mental border between us and the Russians.

When the independent journalist André Bercoff simply raised a couple of questions concerning anomalies in reports of the amazing rescue by Mamoudou Gassama of a child hanging from a Paris balcony, his own colleagues instantly condemned him for “provoking doubts” and engaging in “conspiracy theories”. The official regulatory agency, the Conseil Supérieur de l’Audiovisuel, hastened to open an investigation… of Bercoff. President Macron had invited Gassama to the Elysee Palace, offering him French citizenship and making the event an exemplary national legend. Thus sacred.

Views: 31

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Latest Activity

dogitydog commented on Diana's photo
Thumbnail

Chrismas Tree

"I know where Santa is going first. No wonder he's so jolly!"
8 minutes ago
dogitydog replied to skip barker's discussion The human excrement known as the Bush family
"Ahhh..., so that's what I flushed down the toilet this morning! Then I followed up with a Weapon of Mass Destruction! Bye George. Is it warm down there?"
12 minutes ago
the mighty bull favorited Diana's photo
51 minutes ago
the mighty bull commented on the mighty bull's blog post No Title
"Situations looking up cuzzyz better things to come soon."
59 minutes ago
the mighty bull posted a blog post
1 hour ago
Central Scrutinizer favorited Diana's photo
1 hour ago
Central Scrutinizer commented on Diana's photo
1 hour ago
oldranger_68 favorited Diana's photo
2 hours ago
Raz Putin commented on Raz Putin's blog post Thank you Toronto, Canada for not feeding these animals."Bill and Hillary Clinton Speak to Hundreds of Empty Seats in Toronto on First Night of Tour"
"Soon..."
3 hours ago
Gralton commented on Boris Badenov's page Gavin McInnes, the founder of the group the Proud Boys, Has Been Unpersoned on Youtube ALL CHANNELS DOWN
"the purge continues"
3 hours ago
jim commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post Duterte Tells Philippines: ‘Kill Bishops,’ ‘90% of Priests Are Gay’
"well, what do you mean jimmy, The priest wants you to stay a little later, oh it will be alright he a priest, he is GODS messenger he won't harm you, you'll be safe in his arms. go ahead son it will be ok, you do whatever he says to do. I…"
3 hours ago
rlionhearted_3 posted photos
3 hours ago
jim favorited Chris of the family Masters's blog post Duterte Tells Philippines: ‘Kill Bishops,’ ‘90% of Priests Are Gay’
3 hours ago
Gralton commented on Boris Badenov's page USA Today Faces Backlash After Shaming Heisman Winner for Tweets Posted When He Was 15 - Called His Friend a "Queer" So 6 Years Later USAToday Has to Ruin the Greatest Day of His Life
"i guess queer is out then? what about gay, homo? rumprider? pillow biter?"
4 hours ago
Raz Putin commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post My Predictions
"" As these criminal corporate interests are rooted out and exposed to the light of day and the various schemes that they have used to defraud and oppress people under color of law are unraveled, a Great Awakening worldwide will…"
4 hours ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2018   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted