Torture Has Lasting Effects, Who Would Have Thought?

http://www.latimes.com/features/health/la-na-psychology20-2009apr20,0,139316.story

Mental damage from CIA tactics is disputed

Justice memos say no permanent harm was inflicted from interrogation techniques, but some doctors and psychologists disagree.

By Sarah Gantz and Ben Meyerson
April 20, 2009

Reporting from Washington -- The conclusion in recently released Justice Department memos that CIA interrogation techniques would not cause prolonged mental harm is disputed by some doctors and psychologists, who say that the mental damage incurred from these practices is significant and undeniable.

An August 2002 memo outlined 10 interrogation techniques used on top Al Qaeda suspects, including waterboarding, stress positions and -- for one prisoner with a known fear of insects -- cramped confinement with a bug. Other memos also described such techniques.

"I disagree wholeheartedly with their contention that there are no long-term psychological effects of these treatments," said Nina K. Thomas, an adjunct clinical associate professor of NYU's postdoctoral program in psychotherapy and psychoanalysis, who has worked with torture victims from Burma and Africa.

Interrogation techniques undoubtedly have lasting effects, she said, such as paranoia, anxiety, hypervigilance and "the destruction of people's personalities."

Brad Olson, a research professor of psychology at Northwestern University, also said Justice's approved methods could be extremely damaging.

"Even given individual differences in a person's resilience, over time -- using any of those techniques in combination -- there's absolutely no question they are going to lead to permanent mental harm," Olson said.

When interrogators were tipped off to one prisoner's fear of insects, they planned to put him and a bug in a box, although the CIA said it never did so.

"Some of these [techniques] clearly have a very real physical component," said Dr. Allen Keller, director of the Bellevue/NYU Program for Survivors of Torture. He cited waterboarding, in which water is poured over the face to simulate drowning, as an example.

A prisoner deprived of sleep may be overwhelmed with memories of torture when they become tired years later, Keller said. The same is true, he said, for the stomach growls of those tortured by starvation.

But David Rivkin, who served in the Justice Department under Presidents Reagan and George H. W. Bush, defended the practices. The military has been subjecting its own to these techniques for years during training, he said.

"If this is torture, we've been torturing our own soldiers for years," Rivkin said. "Why is it that we are all of a sudden revolted and aghast?"

In Rivkin's estimation, these techniques are better than other methods of coercion. "They're not easy, but they're enormously restrained -- they're not relying on brute force, they're not relying on infliction of pain," he said.

Regardless of its lasting damage, torture is not an effective way of extracting information, said Fathali Moghaddam, professor of psychology at Georgetown University.

"Depending on the individual being tortured, all of these can have the effect of leading the individual being tortured to give completely incorrect information -- as a way of stopping the pain," Moghaddam said.

sgantz@tribune.com

Views: 18

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Latest Activity

Chris of the family Masters commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post Anatomy of a Birth Certificate - What It Means
"Material for the instant bloodless revolution! Imagine 20% of people declaring themselves alive!"
38 minutes ago
Old Denmark favorited Chris of the family Masters's video
42 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters posted blog posts
50 minutes ago
Old Denmark posted videos
51 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on Chris of the family Masters's status
"It's no need to go on the street marching. We the people can engage in social disobedience known in UK as lawful rebellion. We open our mail which bears Vatican copy write name, not ours. Any presentment should be sent back unopened with a…"
1 hour ago
Diana posted photos
1 hour ago
canadianjoe favorited Diana's photo
1 hour ago
Diana posted discussions
2 hours ago
Diana commented on Raz Putin's video
Thumbnail

Eric Swalwell Has Tantrum After Mueller Report

"lol  He needs to hear from Mueller before he believes the report...Mueller wrote the report.  "
3 hours ago
Diana favorited Raz Putin's video
3 hours ago
Diana favorited Doc Vega's blog post Australia PM adviser says climate change is 'UN-led ruse to establish new world order'
3 hours ago
Diana commented on Doc Vega's blog post Australia PM adviser says climate change is 'UN-led ruse to establish new world order'
"Stalin had a climate control plan back in 1948.  They probably said we only had ten years back then.  lol  "
3 hours ago
Diana favorited Doc Vega's blog post Bob Mueller’s Recipe for a Nothing Burger Report
3 hours ago
Diana commented on Doc Vega's blog post Bob Mueller’s Recipe for a Nothing Burger Report
3 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters favorited Sweettina2's video
3 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on Doc Vega's blog post Australia PM adviser says climate change is 'UN-led ruse to establish new world order'
"Prime pirate Abbott has been deposed some years ago. Globalist think-tank Club of Rome invented global warming in 1977. There is no argument, really. Need to know the facts."
4 hours ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted