Who Will Govern? Rome’s Food Summit may determine who decides who will eat

Download PDF:
4.9MB

The declaration coming out of the World Food Summit for Food Security in Rome is even worse than the “shameful” document adopted by world leaders in 1996, so famously criticized by Cuba’s Fidel Castro. Governments won’t promise anything to anybody. The only issue really being debated in Rome is whether control of the UN’s “Department of Agriculture” will be wrested from the UN’s Rome-based agencies and surrendered to an amorphous, G8 conjured, public-private compact called the Global Partnership for Agriculture, Food Security and Nutrition. If the Partnership prevails, national sovereignty fails, and civil society's hopes for Food Sovereignty will suffer.

Issue: The World Summit on Food Security (Rome, Nov. 16-18) is agriculture’s bid for the attention of climate change negotiators en route to Copenhagen. To carbon traders, agriculture is a money-maker. To food negotiators, it is a billion people hungry with more on the way due to global warming. The food/climate summitry obscures a critical battle over the future governance of global food and agricultural institutions. The G8, the UN Secretary-General, and the Romebased food agencies – FAO, WFP (World Food Programme), IFAD (International Fund for Agricultural Development) and the (often overlooked) CGIAR (Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research) – are in a three-way fight for institutional leadership over world food security. The decision about who will decide who will eat is the Summit’s hot topic.

Fora: When governments awoke to the food crisis in the second quarter of 2008, two separate initiatives popped onto the scene. First, UN Secretary-General Ban-Ki Moon took advantage of the crisis to create a High-Level Taskforce of 22 UN and Bretton Woods institutions to respond to the challenge and (though unstated) to assert UN headquarters’ hegemony over the interminably squabbling Rome agencies. Then, France’s President Sarkozy (backed by the G-8 and, half-heartedly, by the G-20) proposed a Global Partnership for Agriculture, Food Security and Nutrition; a new vertical fund for agricultural development; and an expert advisory committee to guide agriculture’s future. After a critical meeting in Madrid this January, Rome’s feuding agencies called a temporary truce to stare down the Secretary-General forcing him to let a long-neglected leftover from the 1970s food crisis known as the Committee on World Food Security (CFS) take a crack at uniting the UN System and creating a global body that could meet Sarkozy’s demand for a Global Partnership. Between Madrid and the CFS, the G20 met in Pittsburgh and agreed that a new fund of around $20 billion (over 3 years) should be managed by the World Bank. When the CFS convened in Rome in mid-October, the global South was staring down the barrel of a huge new cash cow in Washington and still-persistent proposals for anamorphous Global Partnership hovering somewhere in the mid-Atlantic. Much to its own surprise and very much to the credit of its Chair, the CFS agreed to a new, more transparent intergovernmental and interagency structure in which it was acknowledged as the policy “hub” around food and agriculture. The euphoria may be short lived. In the draft declaration for the World Food Summit, states subordinate the CFS to the (as yet) undefined Global Partnership.

Policy: Nothing that takes place at the Food Summit, nor at the FAO Conference (following
immediately afterward), should derail or delay six steps. The Summit should affirm that: (1) all policies (including treaties, regulations, program and financial policies) must be negotiated and monitored under the UN one state/one vote basis; (2) the CFS is recognized as “the hub” of all intergovernmental action related to food and agriculture; (3) the CFS immediately conduct a meta-evaluation of the four main agricultural agencies (including CGIAR); (4) the CFS invite the four organizations to coordinate their regular meetings to jointly review the meta-evaluation; (5) FAO restructure its biennial regional conferences to be co-convened by the four agencies under the guidance of the CFS with its revised procedures allowing the active participation of civil society. The regional conferences should address the meta-evaluation, review the responses of the
various agencies, and make specific recommendations; and, (6) the CFS should take the
opportunity of the 2011 FAO leadership change to facilitate a new leadership model among the Rome agencies.

Views: 41

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Dee on November 21, 2009 at 10:39am
great info c!!! thanks.

Latest Activity

Sweettina2 posted videos
1 hour ago
Old Denmark posted videos
1 hour ago
cheeki kea commented on Diana's photo
Thumbnail

**

"Well said !"
3 hours ago
Old Denmark posted a status
"LIVE: Homes dangerously close to falling into swollen Oklahoma river http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uuWSn1ySaIc"
3 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post Consumer Reports Recommends Sunscreens That Seep Poison Into Your Bloodstream
4 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post Consumer Reports Recommends Sunscreens That Seep Poison Into Your Bloodstream
"Once the sunscreen has cooked you up medium rare it will then absorb right into the blood till your…"
4 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer favorited Mrs. Tif Morgan's discussion Is there Any Evidence That The UN Is Going After Israel And America?
4 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer replied to Central Scrutinizer's discussion Bought a Berkey!
4 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters posted videos
4 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on James T. Kirk's video
Thumbnail

Welcome to Our Discount Dystopia!

"Awesome. - and a great song from Lee and Nancy."
6 hours ago
Diana's 6 photos were featured
6 hours ago
Raz Putin favorited Diana's photo
6 hours ago
Diana's 2 discussions were featured
6 hours ago
MAC's discussion was featured
6 hours ago
Burbia commented on Maasanova's photo
7 hours ago
cheeki kea posted a photo
7 hours ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted