Can a White Federal Agent Who Killed a Hawaii Local Get a Fair Trial?

Sara Lin/Civil Beat

Racial tension has played an important role in Hawaii's history ever since Capt. James Cook first stepped foot on the Sandwich Isles.

From the imprisonment of Queen Liliuokalani and the overthrow of the Hawaiian monarchy in the 1890s to "Kill Haole Day" and the stagnation of the Akaka bill in Congress, it's been an underlying part of the daily discourse here.

Now a Honolulu attorney representing U.S. special agent Christopher Deedy, who shot a local man in a Waikiki McDonald's, wants to make sure these long-simmering feelings won't keep his client — who is charged with murder — from getting a fair trial.

Deedy, a white male from Virginia, was in Honolulu last November as part of security detail to protect foreign dignitaries who were here for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation conference.

After a night of socializing with friends, Deedy went to a Waikiki McDonald’s where he shot and killed Kollin Elderts, a brown-skinned, multi-ethnic 23-year-old from Kailua.

Loading

Immediately after, protesters took to the streets decrying Elderts’ death and blaming APEC.

There was also speculation about the circumstances leading up to the shooting. Was Elderts bullying Deedy and his friends, using racial epithets to rile the visiting federal agent? Or was it Deedy who was the aggressor, asking Elderts if he wanted to get shot and escalating a verbal argument into one that ended in tragedy.

While part of this response was due to the highly charged atmosphere created by APEC, Deedy’s attorney, Brook Hart, argues in court documents that much of it can also be attributed to increased media scrutiny and underlying socioeconomic and cultural issues facing the people of Hawaii.

In a recent phone interview, he also noted that “some pretty strong anti-mainland, anti-haole sentiment” has arisen since the shooting.

“The case involves many aspects and they go well beyond the particular incident in McDonald's,” Hart said. “We have a strong and vibrant community of local folks who have very negative feelings about actions that the federal government have taken over the years and those might well be translated in animosity toward an agent of the federal government.”

Michael Green, the attorney representing Elderts' family in a civil suit against Deedy, disagrees with Hart's assertion, and says race hasn't become a legitimate factor in the case.

"He's trying to create any type of an issue that he thinks might help him at trial," Green said. "He's doing his job as a lawyer."

Hart didn’t want to delve into details, saying that he wants to save his comments for the courtroom. He added that he hasn’t made a decision yet on whether to ask for a change of venue. Trial has been set for September.

But in his May 14 court filing that asks for permission to more thoroughly question jurors about their potential bias, Hart describes some of the outside influences on the case and how those were latched onto by groups, such as Moana Nui, (De)Occupy Honolulu and the Hawaiian sovereignty movement.

“This case became a symbol of the federal government wrongfully exercising jurisdiction over the Hawaiian Kingdom; it became a sign of the 1% oppressing the 99%; it became an example of a mainland 'haole' allegedly expressing malice and prejudice towards a local Hawaiian,” Hart said in his motion.

READ MORE: http://www.civilbeat.com/articles/2012/06/19/16103-can-a-white-fede...

Views: 388

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

This is all I know.  Deedy wasn't here for not even 24 hrs. He was packing heat and drinking.  Waikiki had what is rare, A shooting death.  He was released from jail in about 12 hrs and left the State with no stipulations on $250K bail. The man is Secrete service!  APEC was hell!

  1. Opening statements conclude in Christopher Deedy murder trial ...

    Hawaii News Now‎ - 6 hours ago
    The murder trial for federal agent Christopher Deedy began just before 10 a.m. on Monday, with an attorney for the prosecution delivering an ...
  2. What to expect in the Christopher Deedy murder trial

    Hawaii News Now‎ - 7 hours ago
    Christopher Deedy is charged with second-degree murder for fatally shooting Kollin Elderts during a scuffle at a Waikiki McDonalds.
    Trial underway for federal agent accused of Waikiki murder KHON2
    Deedy Murder Trial Begins Honolulu Civil Beat (blog)
    Murder trial begins for federal agent charged with killing man at fast ... Minneapolis Star Tribune
  3. Fed agent's Waikiki murder trial set to open

    Hawaii News Now‎ - 3 days ago
    HONOLULU (AP) - Attorneys are preparing for trial to start in the ... State Department Special Agent Christopher Deedy's lawyers say it's likely ...
    Trial to begin for federal agent accused of Waikiki murder KHON2
    Trial for federal agent charged in Waikiki McDonald's shooting set to ... The Tribune
  4. Trial begins for federal agent accused of Waikiki murder

    KHON2‎ - 8 hours ago
    The murder trial for a federal agent accused of fatally shooting a Kailua man two years ago in Waikiki is underway. Christopher Deedy is ...
  5. Waikiki McDonald's shooting trial begins

    Thegardenisland.com‎ - 5 hours ago
    The trial against State Department Special Agent Christopher Deedy started Monday with opening statements. The 29-year-old is charged with ...

RSS

"Destroying the New World Order"

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

Latest Activity

Burbia commented on cheeki kea's blog post BREAKING: The Epstein Files Illuminate a 20-Year Architecture Behind Pandemics as a Business Model.
"What a bummer. Can't tell thie 'dead' guy to eat shit now."
20 hours ago
Burbia commented on rlionhearted_3's photo
Thumbnail

2DF36465-A826-443C-A3A8-6638BC1D4FFA

"Venezuela under Chavez had cut ties with the IMF and World Bank. He had suggested that the US had…"
20 hours ago
Burbia commented on Doc Vega's photo
Thumbnail

G_LrzqtXMAAhT7w

"Derelict of duty should be reason for removal of these judges. That would go against what is in…"
21 hours ago
Doc Vega posted blog posts
yesterday
tjdavis favorited Parrhesia's video
Thursday
tjdavis favorited UnitedWeStand's video
Thursday
tjdavis favorited Sandy's video
Thursday
tjdavis posted a photo
Thursday
Doc Vega commented on rlionhearted_3's photo
Thumbnail

2DF36465-A826-443C-A3A8-6638BC1D4FFA

"You can't subvert a nation that has already been subverted by Marxists and drug cartles who…"
Wednesday
Doc Vega commented on rlionhearted_3's photo
Thumbnail

2DF36465-A826-443C-A3A8-6638BC1D4FFA

"Venezuela was once a thriving nation until the left and Communism infiltrated the government, and…"
Wednesday
tjdavis posted a photo
Wednesday
tjdavis posted a video

Jacob Collier Improvises With Orchestra (Live in San Francisco)

A few months ago, I had the joy of performing with the world's first Audience Symphony Orchestra in San Francisco, a gathering of fans from all over North Am...
Wednesday
Doc Vega posted blog posts
Tuesday
Роман posted a blog post

Архітектура для мегаполісів: виклики та рішення урбаністики

Сучасні мегаполіси — це складні живі організми, де переплітаються економіка, культура, технології…See More
Feb 9
Tori Kovach posted a discussion

Pumpkin Face

Is he dead yet?See More
Feb 8
cheeki kea posted a blog post
Feb 8
cheeki kea commented on Sandy's photo
Thumbnail

FB_IMG_1770501160448

"Thumbs up find. So what ever do we have here then? Revolving doors of corruption and deceit that…"
Feb 8
cheeki kea left a comment for Роман
"Greetings and well wishes to you POMaH, great that you've joined us all here at the site. May…"
Feb 8
Sandy posted photos
Feb 8
Doc Vega posted a blog post

Something is Making Fishermen Disappear It’s not Alligators or Sharks

 The setting is a section of the Ohio River where many locals enjoy fishing, swimming, and boating.…See More
Feb 7

© 2026   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted