Hurricanes and Socialism
Two articles in the New York Times last week exemplify perfectly why our nation is in such bad shape. Both articles concerned the devastation from Hurricane Sandy. The first was a Times editorial, entitled “A Big Storm Requires Big Government.” The other article was in the form of an op-ed entitled “Grover Cleveland’s Hurricane” by Matthew Algeo.
The thrust of both pieces was that Hurricane Sandy proved that the nation really needs big government in general and FEMA in particular. Without FEMA and big government, the argument goes, there is no way that people in a free society could cope with emergencies and crises.
Actually, however, in the process of praising FEMA, Algeo did Americans a great service. He criticized President Grover Cleveland for having denied federal disaster relief to hurricane victims in the latter part of the 19th century. He also pointed out that Cleveland vetoed a welfare bill for Texas farmers who were suffering a severe drought.
Why is that a service to Americans? Because it bursts the myth that is inculcated into every American schoolchild — that America’s system has always been the same. Americans are made to believe that myth because the last thing statists want them to do is to start wondering why our American ancestors chose a different system than the one that modern-day Americans chose. In fact, in their haste to publish an article criticizing Grover Cleveland and his selfishness, I can’t help but wonder if the Times failed to realize that the article it was publishing, at the same time, was bursting one of the government’s most prized myths.
As Algeo implicitly points out, Americans have lived under two different economic systems and social orders. Our American ancestors chose a way of life in which everyone kept everything he earned. There was no income tax. That wasn’t an accident. Our ancestors believed that a free society necessarily entailed the right of people to keep the fruits of their earnings.
There was also no requirement that people do the “right” thing with their money. They were free to do whatever they wanted with it. They could save, donate, invest, or spend it. The choice was theirs. Our ancestors believed that that’s part of what living in a free society is all about.
Cleveland’s position simply reflected what America was once all about — what a free society was once all about. As Algeo points out, Cleveland stated, “Federal aid in such cases encourages the expectation of paternal care on the part of the government and weakens the sturdiness of our national character.” That’s not only what Cleveland believed. It was the philosophy that undergirded American society through the 1800s.
Not so today. Having born and raised under a welfare state, many Americans believe they are entitled to be taken care of by the government, When things go wrong, the first response is, “I have a right to federal money,” which is really nothing more than saying, “I have a right to your money, thanks to the taxing power of the IRS and the welfare function of the federal bureaucracies.”
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Christopher on
-
RE: "The welfare state has severely damaged the principles of self-reliance, can-do, and independence within the American people."
Agreed, but only to some extent.
Have human beings evolved, to such a degree, that they may actually be willing to part (give away) with some of the fruits of their earnings, and give to those in need – will the haves really want to give to the have nots?
I can only hope that they would.
I experienced a category four (Marilyn) hurricane, and the people selling the supplies, which others would need, to prepare for such an event, were gouging (prices) consumers.
“Cleveland was right: Federal aid has encouraged the expectation of paternal care on the part of the government - and has certainly weakened the sturdiness of our national character.”
And again, I agree with that – but the situation is what it is, right now, and we can’t switch back, any time soon, to the point prior, to having become a welfare state.
This is why my beef with the FEDERAL GOVERNMENT is simple – If you can get you’re A$$ in gear, with such self prided, record efficiency - moving tens of thousands of soldiers - and all the various weapons of mass destruction - transporting it all, thousands of miles away from home base, so ‘they’ can put “the boots on the ground”; like they did in “Desert Storm” (IRAQ), or somewhere else for that matter, in the Middle East – Then why does it appear so obvious, compared to the latter, that they have done nothing?
PS:
Great article you found - and thanks for posting it.
I know of some other material which I read sometime ago, on the "Welfare-State" - but I will have to look for it now (again).
-
Permalink Reply by Chip on
-
Last paragraph states: (Except for libertarians, the welfare state has severely damaged the principles of self-reliance, can-do, and independence within the American people). I know lots of people that aren't libertarians that are not damaged by the welfare state. Hmmmm, my first thought when reading this headline was from the douche nozzle Chris Matthews last night. The socialist stated that he thanks god for the Hurricane that got o'dumbler re-elected. Funny, hurricane and socialist in the same sentence and Matthews proved it.
-
Permalink Reply by Marklar on
-
Hmmm, but maybe if they had stockpiled food and water instead of ammo?
Might as well distribute those hundreds of rounds of ammo to the populace since that is all they seem to have to offer.
Or maybe they could have put money into flood control instead of letting out infrastructure rot causing the whole problem in the first place,... naaaaaaaaah
"Destroying the New World Order"
THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!
Latest Activity
- Top News
- Everything
Charlie Kirk: Grief And Outrage From Turning Point USA in Phoenix
We went to Charlie Kirk's Turning Point USA headquarters in Phoenix to talk with people who were there to pay their respects.►Join my community to get exclus...
"cheeki kea, Yes that was released on to book sites 19 hours before the tragic event and also there…"
Charlie Kirk Was Terrified Of Israel
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.
"The internet is fractioned that's for sure but it never sleeps and the big question of the day…"
"It seems America has many meanings to many people. The internet has fractioned everybody. I had…"
"Cheeki kea I'm glad that the giant Moa downsized to this turkey looking land walker.!"
"I don't know what difference if any that he was also a member of Council for National Policy.…"
"I remember when they found out that the united Council of Churches worldwide had been funding…"
A Few More Rats in Your Skull Concerning Charlie and the Rampaging Left
Political violence and death has been perpetrated for a long time now in America. The Democrats…See More
Charlie Kirk Assaination
September 10th 2025 in Utah Turning Point USA CEO has been assassinated. Coincidentally, answering…See More
Bow to Your New Masters
Dr. Jerome Corsi reports that the discovery of a new wireless system that can corrupt any…See More
"Wow I never knew penguins got down sized also over time. I knew of the Moa which is really now a…"
Civalyze meme
meme ad for a fake drug that would do away with black fatiguecivilyze you're not racist your just exhausted
Is the Timing of Alex Jones and Charlie Sheen Connected?
Alex Jones is sperging out.Charlie Sheen is coming out of the closet.Is this why Alex Jones is…See More
Buying the Last haunted House on the Left (A partial autobiography)
Note to the reader, there are events here that are true and some that are fictional.Chapter IIt was…See More
© 2025 Created by truth.
Powered by
