Source

A federal judge is dismissing lawsuits accusing the government of teaming with the nation’s telcos to funnel Americans’ electronic
communications to the National Security Agency without warrants.

U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker’s decision was a major blow to the two suits testing warrantless eavesdropping and executive branch powers implemented following the 2001 terror attacks. The San Francisco judge said the courts are not available to the public to mount that challenge.

“A citizen may not gain standing by claiming a right to have the government follow the law,” (.pdf) Walker ruled late Thursday.

He noted that the plaintiffs include most every American connected to the internet or to have used a telephone — meaning the lawsuits boil down to a “general grievance” and are barred. The decision came days after a government audit showed the telecom companies and FBI collaborated for four years, between 2003 and 2007, to violate federal wiretapping laws.

Judge Walker said that the lawsuits, in essence, cannot be brought because they are “citizen suits seeking to employ judicial remedies to punish and bring to heel high-level government officials for the allegedly illegal and unconstitutional warrantless electronic
surveillance program or programs now widely, if incompletely, aired in
the public forum.”

Cindy Cohn, the legal director of the Electronic Frontier Foundation that brought one of the cases, said the decision means “when you’re trying to stop the government from doing something illegal, and if the government does it to enough people, the courts can’t fix it.”

The Electronic Frontier Foundation, which said it would appeal Walker’s order, and others originally brought suit against AT&T and other telecommunication companies in 2006. That was a month after President George W. Bush acknowledged a Terror Surveillance Program after it was disclosed in The New York Times.

The EFF, based on a former AT&T’s documentation, claims the program was, and continues to be a dragnet where carriers funnel customer communications to the National Security Agency without warrants. Bush, however, acknowledged the program as one in which his war powers granted him the authority to monitor American’s telecommunications without warrants if
the subject was communicating with somebody overseas and was suspected
of terrorism

Walker tossed the case against the telecommunication carriers (.pdf) in June, after Congress — with then-Sen. Barack Obama’s vote — immunized the carriers from being sued for their alleged conduct. The 2008 legislation also authorized the Terror Surveillance Program as
outlined by Bush.

That decision by Walker, which is on appeal, gave new focus to the two lawsuits targeting the government that Walker tossed Thursday.

The Obama administration argued that the case decided Thursday should be dismissed on grounds it threatened to expose government secrets, a legal privilege judges routinely rubber stamp. The government also asserted “sovereign immunity,” a principle in which the
government cannot be sued unless it has given consent.

Walker declined to rule on those arguments.

The ruling also elevates the importance of another lawsuit testing the president’s authority to spy on Americans without warrants.

That suit involves two American lawyers accidentally given a “top secret” document showing they were eavesdropped on by the government when working for a now-defunct Islamic charity in 2004. That case is pending before Walker.

Views: 17

Reply to This

"Destroying the New World Order"

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

Latest Activity

cheeki kea posted a photo
1 hour ago
cheeki kea commented on Sandy's photo
3 hours ago
tjdavis posted videos
4 hours ago
Doc Vega posted a photo
20 hours ago
Doc Vega posted a blog post

What is Reality? Ask Dr. Steven Greer Pt. 2

 What would happen if mankind’s direction were suddenly transformed toward what was ultimately for…See More
21 hours ago
Sandy posted photos
yesterday
Sandy posted a video

How Man-Made Clouds Can Help Save Coral Reefs

Scientists have come up with a unique strategy for protecting corals in Australia’s Great Barrier Reef. @nikolajcw meets an oceanographer to see how man-made...
yesterday
rlionhearted_3 posted photos
yesterday
Sandy posted photos
Friday
Sandy posted videos
Friday
tjdavis commented on tjdavis's video
Friday
tjdavis commented on tjdavis's video
Friday
tjdavis posted videos
Friday
cheeki kea commented on cheeki kea's photo
Thumbnail

Both True.

"You're on to it Doc V, China wants a slice of the ice although they have no historical…"
Thursday
cheeki kea commented on cheeki kea's photo
Thumbnail

Can it get any Sicker !

"Sick, sad, gut wrenching and true. It is understandable why so many families are fleeing Britain…"
Thursday
cheeki kea posted a photo
Thursday
Snakedaddy favorited Parrhesia's photo
Thursday
Doc Vega posted a blog post

What is Reality? Ask Doctor Steven Greer

So, what is the mystery drone sightings all about? We’re going to have to jump down a rabbit hole…See More
Wednesday
Doc Vega favorited Sandy's video
Wednesday
Doc Vega commented on Sandy's video
Thumbnail

THE FALL OF THE CABAL by Janet Ossebaard & Cynthia Koeter (THE SEQUEL) Part 9

"And there are the atheists who say there's no such thing as the Devil."
Wednesday

© 2025   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted