Exclusive: John Cornyn Rips Chuck Schumer's Media 'Shield Law'

The number two Republican in the Senate is lambasting a media “shield law” proposed by New York Democrat Sen. Chuck Schumer, potentially imperiling its shot at passage.

“This is a bad idea and one whose time has not come,” Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX), the Senate minority whip, told Breitbart News in an exclusive interview. “Believe me, we will not be rolled over.”

Schumer’s “Free Flow of Information Act” passed the Senate Judiciary Committee in September, and he recently said he already has the 60 votes needed to pass the bill on the floor. “We’ll get a few more Republicans, not many more, but we have the 60 votes,” Schumer told reporters in New York last week.

He's bluffing, Cornyn retorts.

“If he had the votes to pass it, it already would have been passed,” Cornyn says, adding, “This isn’t about passing legislation, this is about distracting the public’s attention and changing the subject from the failed policies of this administration. I think you could put this in that same category.”

Schumer's proposal would exempt a “covered journalist” from subpoenas and other legal requirements to expose their confidential sources in leak investigations and other areas. Other lawmakers have proposed similar ideas in the past, but the effort gained new momentum after a series of revelations about controversial tactics the Justice Department was using to target journalists.

For instance, the Department of Justice secretly monitored Fox News reporter James Rosen in the course of a leak investigation, even claiming in a court filing he was a subject of investigation himself. In another instance, the government had secretly monitored numerous phone lines used by the Associated Press, including one in the U.S. Capitol.

Cornyn says Schumer's proposal is fatally flawed and may be an unworkable idea altogether.

“They want to pick and choose which journalists are covered,” the Texan Republican told Breitbart News. “In other words, if you’re a blogger they might not cover you, but if you work for the New York Times they might. Given the changes in the way we get information and the way we consume news, that really smacks to me in essence of government licensing who’s an official ‘journalist’ for the purposes of a shield law and who’s not. If there is one thing I can glean from the First Amendment, it is that government should not be in the business of licensing the news media.”

In practice, defining who is considered a “journalist” and protected under the law from having to disclose confidential sources is a thorny legal problem. On the one hand, the law's drafters don't want to provide blanket immunity to everyone. But anointing a government-approved class of scribes cuts against the nature of journalism, which almost by definition is frequently critical of the government.

“It’s totally inconsistent with the notion of a free press and the First Amendment,” Cornyn said.

His “fundamental problem” with the bill, though, is that it would exempt journalists from being subpoenaed to testify before a grand jury if they witness a crime.

“For example, if you’ve witnessed a crime taking place, you or I would both have to respond to a grand jury subpoena and come to testify to what we’ve seen. This idea of saying you could have information about a crime and you are immunized to having to partake in a basic act of American citizenship strikes me as pretty odd to say the least,” he says.

Cornyn, who just breezed past a primary challenge from Rep. Steve Stockman, notes it's more than a bit ironic that Senate Democrats are championing the bill while their party's president wreaks havoc on press freedoms.

Cornyn believes the bill's timing – and the administration’s backing of it – appears to be aimed at alleviating criticism of the Justice Department’s secret attainment of Associated Press phone conversations and the administration’s similar actions against Fox News’s James Rosen, among other media targeting.

“You remember when this was recently resurrected?” Cornyn asks. “It was essentially an attempt to deflect... from the Department of Justice and this administration... the criticism they were taking [from] James Rosen and other traditional journalists. So, I really question the timing of all of this.”

Finally, Cornyn raises concerns about the proposal's champion – Schumer.

The mere fact that Schumer is the one pushing this bill is something that should send alarm bells off throughout the Congress, Cornyn says.

“My antennae are always very sensitive whenever he is on the march,” he says, noting the New York Democrat openly declared war on the Tea Party in a Center for American Progress speech earlier this year.

Cornyn says that the bill would very likely exclude bloggers and would definitely exclude citizen journalists and other new media practitioners, those who may practice journalism but not in the employ of a major newspaper or television network, from being government-defined “journalists.” As such, it could end up hurting conservatives because many of the most widely-read new media figures are on the right.

“Well, you remember, a few years ago there was a discussion about the Fairness Doctrine, and whether they would go after talk radio,” Cornyn says.

“Talk radio, I think, the left feels as a threat. Now, you know, you start to put the dots together and the FCC’s recent discussion about placing monitors in newsrooms, you begin to see that this administration wants to control the information that people get and particularly any information that might be critical of them – which is, as you pointed out in the first instance... the function of a free press: to give people unbiased and factual information they can use to make their own decisions, not to collaborate with government in squashing speech that people find unfavorable,” he adds.

Cornyn says he will “absolutely” be whipping against the bill and doubts the Republican-controlled House would pass it anyway.

BREITBART

Views: 28

"Destroying the New World Order"

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

Doc Vega, Chris of the family Masters, cheeki kea and 3 more were featured

 

Latest Activity

tjdavis posted photos
3 minutes ago
cheeki kea commented on Parrhesia's photo
Thumbnail

Join The IRSS

"Yes I hear the IRS are advertising for new recruits according to American internet…"
31 minutes ago
cheeki kea commented on cheeki kea's photo
Thumbnail

Cancelled. ~ But not for long.

"Now look what you've done Stuff-up fuck-up. ~May your national demise be our wondrous Rise.…"
1 hour ago
cheeki kea commented on Less Prone's blog post The Malone Institute presents: World Economic Forum Project
"Yes they are all traitors, clowns or whores but collectively they know themselves as Puppets…"
2 hours ago
MAC replied to MAC's discussion Putin's Chilling Message to the West at the 10th Moscow Conference on International Security
"Putin the right man in the right place at the right time, stomping the nwo asshat country's…"
3 hours ago
cheeki kea posted a photo
3 hours ago
MAC posted a discussion
4 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on Less Prone's blog post The provocation is getting worse: Finland and Estonia are planning to set up a missile system to block Russia's Baltic fleet
"Finland shouldn't tie bows with Sweden and others if the provocative move brings disharmony to…"
4 hours ago
steve commented on tjdavis's photo
Thumbnail

every minute

"Ol trumpy bear is a damn good salesman/circus barker if nothing else. He could sell ice to eskimos…"
4 hours ago
steve commented on Less Prone's blog post The provocation is getting worse: Finland and Estonia are planning to set up a missile system to block Russia's Baltic fleet
"These cowardly prix think the distraction of war will save their scrawny necks come just desserts…"
4 hours ago
steve commented on Less Prone's blog post The Malone Institute presents: World Economic Forum Project
"Yes this list should be public knowledge, you call these traitors clowns I call em whores bought…"
4 hours ago
Less Prone posted a blog post
4 hours ago
Less Prone commented on Less Prone's blog post The Malone Institute presents: World Economic Forum Project
"Thanks for bringing this up, Steve. The world is a big circus with bought out political clowns…"
5 hours ago
Less Prone's blog post was featured
5 hours ago
tjdavis posted blog posts
5 hours ago
steve commented on tjdavis's photo
Thumbnail

gone to market

"Hey all Check this out then tell me it ain't all scripted. trumpy bear appointed this…"
7 hours ago
steve commented on Doc Vega's blog post This is What Happens When You Abandon Your Allies in Afghanistan
"When I was a schoolboy back in oh 67 0r 68 we had drills to dive under the desk in case them evil…"
8 hours ago
Parrhesia commented on Doc Vega's blog post This is What Happens When You Abandon Your Allies in Afghanistan
"Steve- I've already been outed as a KGB Agent.  That's why I find it offensive when…"
9 hours ago
steve commented on Doc Vega's blog post This is What Happens When You Abandon Your Allies in Afghanistan
"Hey Parr, or in the delusional mind of our weepy poet Hey Alter or invented ego or supporter or…"
9 hours ago
steve commented on Doc Vega's blog post This is What Happens When You Abandon Your Allies in Afghanistan
"dockedy how a "word can be incendiary" is as silly as dry water but let me splain to your…"
9 hours ago

© 2022   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted