San Francisco Subway Shuts Cell Service to Foil Protest; Legal Debate Ignites


BART workers remove a man atop a train during a protest at the Civic Center station in San Francisco last month. Authorities closed the station where demonstrators condemned the fatal shooting of a man by transit police the week before.

For apparently the first time in the United States, a government agency shuttered mobile-internet and phone service in a bid to quash a demonstration — the same type of speech suppression exercised by Middle Eastern tyrannies to quell dissent.

Thursday’s move by Bay Area Rapid Transit authorities was greeted by an uproar of comparisons to Egypt and Libya. The hacking collective Anonymous responded in typical form over the weekend by defacing the agency’s website, and stealing and releasing the private account information of some 2,000 San Francisco–area transit riders.

The controversy began when officials removed the power to underground service towers Thursday at four San Francisco stations in anticipation of a planned protest — which did not materialize — over the shooting death of a knife-wielding man by BART police last month.

Some constitutional scholars are likening BART’s actions to an unlawful suppression of First Amendment speech — a digital form of prior restraint. Others, however, say BART’s move would probably survive a court challenge, and will likely be copied by other government agencies as the use of mobile technology and social networking by protesters grows.

“You have the right to speak,” Damon Dunn, a First Amendment lawyer in Chicago, said in a telephone interview. “I don’t think you have the right to leverage your speech through technology that you don’t necessarily control yourself.”

An earlier BART protest in July resulted in a major disruption of rush-hour service, as some protesters even climbed atop cars at the Civic Center station.

“The interruption of cell phone service was done Thursday to prevent what could have been a dangerous situation. It’s one of the tactics we have at our disposal. We may use it; we may not. And I’m not sure we would necessarily let anyone know in advance either way,” BART spokesman Jim Allison said.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation said BART’s actions constituted an unconstitutional breach of protesters’ First Amendment rights. A blog post on the San Francisco civil rights group’s website likened the subway’s move to Egypt’s decision to cut internet access to quell protests: “Bart Pulls a Mubarak in San Francisco.”

“What they did, effectively, is suppressed an enormous amount of speech that otherwise would have occurred by disabling people’s devices,” Lee Tien, an EFF staff attorney, said in a telephone interview. “They just put a cone of silence for cell phone service over the BART stations in the belief that something needed to be prevented. In my mind, that’s the electronic version for shutting down somebody.”

He added that, “I’m not aware of us having thought about actually suing yet. I’m not aware of anyone doing that.”

The American Civil Liberties Union said it was mulling legal action, but conceded that there could be instances when it would be legal for a government agency to shutter mobile-phone service.

“I don’t want to say, absolutely, that this will never be permissible,” Michael Risher, an ACLU staff attorney, said in a telephone interview. “It should not happen unless under extraordinary circumstances, real and concrete, where it is necessary to prevent some disaster.”

He does not believe that BART has met that burden. But he noted that it might be hard to put the genie back in the bottle.

“It’s very difficult to stop this from happening once,” he said. “It never happened before. There are no rules.”

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Curtis on August 15, 2011 at 6:57pm

"Destroying the New World Order"

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

Latest Activity

Doc Vega posted a blog post
5 hours ago
tjdavis posted a blog post
22 hours ago
Less Prone favorited tjdavis's video
23 hours ago
Doc Vega's 4 blog posts were featured
23 hours ago
tjdavis's 3 blog posts were featured
23 hours ago
Larry Harmen's blog post was featured
23 hours ago
tjdavis posted a photo
23 hours ago
MAC posted a discussion
yesterday
cheeki kea commented on cheeki kea's photo
Thumbnail

New jobs off shore

"It's not surprising many former workers are heading away for better opportunities after being…"
yesterday
cheeki kea posted photos
Saturday
tjdavis posted a photo
Saturday
tjdavis posted videos
Saturday
MAC posted a video

This is INSANE! The Biden administration is doing it in ALL 50 states! | Redacted w Clayton Morris

American Financing:N M L S 1 8 2 3 3 4, N M L S consumer access dot org. APR for rates in the 5s start at 6.799% for well qualified borrowers. Visit https://...
Friday
tjdavis posted a video

Pete Seeger on being Black Listed in America, 1965: CBC Archives | CBC

In this clip from 1965, folk singer and activist Pete Seeger talks about being black listed for "un-American activities" and his refusal to answer questions ...
Friday
tjdavis posted a photo
Friday
tjdavis posted a blog post
Friday
Doc Vega commented on Doc Vega's blog post Letitia James You know the one who Announced She was going after Donald Trump Now targets Ivermectin!
"The Communists from within will not let you co-exist they will continue to try to steal your…"
Thursday
Doc Vega posted a blog post

Letitia James You know the one who Announced She was going after Donald Trump Now targets Ivermectin!

https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/wp-content/uploads/0-1468-600x313.jpg 600w,…See More
Thursday
Mr. Sizzle posted photos
Thursday
Mr. Sizzle favorited Doc Vega's blog post A Message to Illegal Aliens
Thursday

© 2024   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted