Congress Looks at Laws That Criminalize Non-Criminal Behavior

By Lesley Clark | McClatchy Newspapers
WASHINGTON — Abner Schoenwetter, a Miami seafood importer, spent six years in prison, paid tens of thousands of dollars in fines and legal fees and is at risk of losing his home.

His crime? Agreeing to purchase lobster tails that federal prosecutors said violated harvest regulations — in Honduras.

Now Schoenwetter, 64, is a convicted felon with an ailing wife, no job or right to vote and three years of supervised release ahead of him. But he's also a star witness for congressional efforts aimed at stemming what a growing number of legal experts and lawmakers consider "overcriminalization" — the federal government's penchant for writing new laws to criminalize conduct that could be addressed with fines or other remedies.

"We must put an end to the notion that we need to prosecute every individual for every perceived offense," said Rep. Bobby Scott, a Virginia Democrat who chairs a House Judiciary subcommittee that last week held its second hearing on overcriminalization. "We continue to lock up people for offenses that should not even require incarceration."

Legal experts say there are more than 4,450 federal crimes on the books and as many as 300,000 federal regulations that can be enforced criminally. From 2000 to 2007, Congress created 452 entirely new crimes, said Brian Walsh, a senior legal research fellow at the Heritage Foundation who focuses on overcriminalization.

"It used to be a grave statement to say someone was making a 'federal case' out of something," Walsh told lawmakers. "Today, although the penalties are severe and frequently harsh, the underlying conduct punished is often laughable."

Support for cutting back the tangle of laws and regulations is strong among what Scott calls "seemingly odd political bedfellows" — the Heritage Foundation, a conservative Washington think tank; the American Civil Liberties Union; Edwin Meese, attorney general under President Ronald Reagan; liberal Democrats and traditional law-and-order Republicans who chafe at a plethora of federal regulations, many of which carry prison time.

"We're talking about people's freedom and the way it affects people's faith in their government or lack thereof. We've got to get this cleaned up," Rep. Louie Gohmert, R-Texas, a former judge and prosecutor, said after Schoenwetter told the panel about the agents who burst into his home early one morning, "herding my wife, my mother-in-law and my daughter into the living room in their nightclothes."

"I'm not here to get sympathy," Schoenwetter told lawmakers. "I'm here to make sure other Americans don't have to go through the same destructive ordeal that we've been through."

A major problem, legal experts and lawmakers say, is that many federal laws are written so vaguely that prosecutors are not required to prove criminal intent to put someone behind bars.

Joining Schoenwetter at the witness table: former racecar driver Bobby Unser, who — after getting lost in a blizzard — was prosecuted for entering a national wilderness area on a snowmobile. The charge carried a six-month prison term and a $5,000 fine. Because it was considered "strict liablity," the government didn't have to prove Unser intended to break the law, or that he even knew he broke the law.

"That doesn't seem like American justice to me," Unser told lawmakers. "Why should I, who nearly died in the blizzard, have to show there was no true need for me to enter the wilderness? I didn't even know I was there."

Lawmakers said they worry that the pursuit of such charges wastes valuable law enforcement time and that too many nonviolent offenders are taking up valuable prison space.

Schoenwetter's nightmare began in 1999 when he and several co-defendants were charged with smuggling and conspiracy after agreeing to purchase lobster tails from the same supplier they'd been using for more than a decade. But this time, federal officials said the catch violated Honduran fishing regulations — and therefore, the federal Lacey Act, which makes it a crime to import fish that violates foreign laws.

The Heritage Foundation's Walsh said advocates are developing recommendations to address the problem, including requiring bills that add criminal penalties to be reviewed by the House and Senate judiciary committees. He said a study found that bills that cleared the committees were "statistically more likely to have criminal intent requirements" than those that didn't face such scrutiny.

Other changes would be to direct federal courts to give the benefit of the doubt to the defendant — rather than the prosecution — when faced with ambiguous criminal laws.


Follow the latest politics news at McClatchy's Planet Washington

Read more:

Views: 30


You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

"Destroying the New World Order"


mobile page

12160 Administrators



Latest Activity

Bob Renner posted photos
44 minutes ago
Twilight Zone posted a video
1 hour ago
Twilight Zone favorited Chris of the family Masters's blog post Brandon Smith - We're Headed For 1929 Repeat
1 hour ago
Twilight Zone favorited Central Scrutinizer's blog post MONSANTO FOUND GUILTY OF CHEMICAL POISONING IN LANDMARK CASE
1 hour ago
Twilight Zone favorited Hyper Loose's blog post Medical Doctor Tells How Death Will Occur due to Taking the CV 19 Vaccine
1 hour ago
Twilight Zone commented on cheeki kea's photo
2 hours ago
Twilight Zone posted photos
2 hours ago
Twilight Zone commented on cheeki kea's photo


"Fortunately those born male can celebrate by identifying as "women" thereby nullifying…"
2 hours ago
Hyper Loose posted a blog post

Medical Doctor Tells How Death Will Occur due to Taking the CV 19 Vaccine

Medical Doctor Exposes Mass Eugenics Extermination Called 'Covid-19 Vaccine'…See More
3 hours ago
Patrick C Conway favorited Phyllis Maka's blog post Two huge con jobs: Homeless tents in San Francisco, and the latest "covid relief bill" - Jim Stone
3 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post America's Frontline Doctors
"I hope the petition works. I was reading info on a site today concerning the grave concerns that…"
4 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters posted blog posts
6 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on cheeki kea's video

Career-Limiting Move (The Most Career-Limiting Thing You Can Do)

"This ad is utter bull shit And Racist towards asian women in this case. You international…"
7 hours ago
cheeki kea posted a video

Career-Limiting Move (The Most Career-Limiting Thing You Can Do)

What’s the most career-limiting thing you can do? It turns out that if you’re a woman, it’s having a baby.There’s a clear and obvious cost to women and their...
8 hours ago
cheeki kea posted a photo


Man have I seen some crap today sisters.
8 hours ago
Phyllis Maka posted blog posts
9 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer posted a blog post
13 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer posted a video
14 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer favorited Chris of the family Masters's blog post Brandon Smith - We're Headed For 1929 Repeat
14 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post Brandon Smith - We're Headed For 1929 Repeat
"Buckle up kids & the Fasten Seat belts light is now on folks... won't be a repeat.....…"
14 hours ago

© 2021   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted