Check Out What Really Happened



Documents obtained by The Intercept show the NYPD and IBM engaged in a long-running facial recognition tech partnership from .... While some of this deployment was discussed publicly, details about the extent of the program -- as well as it's more problematic elements -- haven't been.

As the article's title informs the reader, camera footage could be scanned for face matches using skin tone as a search constraint. Considering this was pushed by IBM as a tool to prevent the next 9/11, it's easy to see why the NYPD -- given its history of surveilling Muslim New Yorkers -- might be willing to utilize a tool like this to pare down lists of suspects to just the people it suspected all along (Muslims).

There are a number of surprises contained in the long, detailed article, but the first thing that jumps out is IBM's efforts and statements, rather than the NYPD's. We all know the government capitalizes on tragedies to expand its power, but here we see a private corporation appealing to this base nature to make a sale.

In New York, the terrorist threat “was an easy selling point,” recalled Jonathan Connell, an IBM researcher who worked on the initial NYPD video analytics installation. “You say, ‘Look what the terrorists did before, they could come back, so you give us some money and we’ll put a camera there.”

From this pitch sprung an 8-year program -- deployed in secrecy by the NYPD to gather as much footage as possible of New Yorkers for dual purposes: its own law enforcement needs and to serve as a testing ground for IBM's new facial recognition tech. Needless to say, New Yorkers were never made aware of their lab rat status in IBM's software development process.

Even though the software could search by skin tone (as well as by "head color," age, gender, and facial hair), the NYPD claims it never used that feature in a live environment, despite IBM's urging.

According to the NYPD, counterterrorism personnel accessed IBM’s bodily search feature capabilities only for evaluation purposes, and they were accessible only to a handful of counterterrorism personnel. “While tools that featured either racial or skin tone search capabilities were offered to the NYPD, they were explicitly declined by the NYPD,” Donald, the NYPD spokesperson, said. “Where such tools came with a test version of the product, the testers were instructed only to test other features (clothing, eyeglasses, etc.), but not to test or use the skin tone feature. That is not because there would have been anything illegal or even improper about testing or using these tools to search in the area of a crime for an image of a suspect that matched a description given by a victim or a witness. It was specifically to avoid even the suggestion or appearance of any kind of technological racial profiling.”

It's easy to disbelieve this statement by the NYPD, given its long history of racial profiling, but it may be those handling the secret program deployment actually understood no program remains secret forever and sought to head off complaints and lawsuits by discouraging use of a controversial search feature. It also may be the NYPD was super-sensitive to these concerns following the partial dismantling of its stop-and-frisk program and the outing of its full-fledged, unconstitutional surveillance of local Muslims.

The thing is IBM is still selling this tech it beta tested live from New York. The same features the NYPD rejected are used to sell other law enforcement agencies on the power of its biometric profiling software.

In 2017, IBM released Intelligent Video Analytics 2.0, a product with a body camera surveillance capability that allows users to detect people captured on camera by “ethnicity” tags, such as “Asian,” “Black,” and “White.”

And there's a counter-narrative that seems to dispute the NYPD's assertions about controversial image tagging features. The IBM researcher who helped develop the skin tone recognition feature is on record stating the company doesn't develop features unless there's a market for them. In his estimation, the NYPD approached IBM to ask for this feature while the 8-year pilot program was still underway. The NYPD may have opted out after the feature went live, but it may have only done so to steer clear of future controversy. An ulterior motive doesn't make it the wrong move, but it also shouldn't be assumed the NYPD has morphed into heroic defenders of civil liberties and personal privacy.

What's available to other law enforcement agencies not similarly concerned about future PR black eyes is "mass racial profiling" at their fingertips. IBM has built a product that appeals to law enforcement's innate desire to automate police work, replacing officers on the street with cameras and software. Sure, there will be some cameras on patrol officers as well, but those are just for show. The real work of policing is done at desks using third-party software that explicitly allows -- if not encourages -- officers to narrow down suspect lists based on race. In a country so overly concerned about terrorism, this is going to lead to a lot of people being approached by law enforcement simply because of their ethnicity.

An additional problem with IBM's software -- and with those produced by competitors -- is a lot of markers used to identify potential suspects can easily net a long list of probables who share nothing but similar body sizes or clothing preferences. Understandably, more work is done by investigators manning these systems before cops start rounding people up, but the potential for inadvertent misuse (never mind actual misuse) is still incredibly high.

The secrecy of these programs is also an issue. Restrictive NDAs go hand-in-hand with private sector partnerships and these are often translated by police officials to mean information must be withheld from judges, criminal defendants, and department oversight. When that happens, due process violations gather atop the privacy violation wreckage until the whole thing collapses under its own audacity. Nothing stays secret forever, but entities like the NYPD and IBM could do themselves a bunch of favors by engaging in a little proactive transparency.


Views: 27


You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Burbia on September 10, 2018 at 8:12pm

Then we have Bozos the Amazonian...

Amazon facial recognition kit ‘racist and unreliable’

Comment by Sweettina2 on September 10, 2018 at 12:50pm


Comment by Sweettina2 on September 10, 2018 at 12:50pm

I believe it's used way more than we know. I've always heard that by the time they admit to something, its old news and they are much more advanced than what they're showing.

Comment by DTOM on September 10, 2018 at 12:41pm

Considering this was pushed by IBM as a tool to prevent the next 9/11...

Then the NYPD might want to make some (((adjustments)) to their profiling...



Latest Activity

Boris Badenov commented on Boris Badenov's page The #Fauxcahontas Folly just keeps getting better and better.
"#Fauxcahontas: This is hilarious. They used DNA from South America going back 12,000 years. By that type of science I'm .003% Russian"
16 minutes ago
Profile Icon via Twitter
The #Fauxcahontas Folly just keeps getting better and better.▼ Warren DNA test does NOT pr…
Twitter17 minutes ago · Reply · Retweet
Chris of the family Masters posted a blog post

A universal flu vaccine: the mad science solution

The National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) has launched efforts to create a vaccine that would protect people from most flu strains, all at once, with a single shot.Over the years, I’ve written many articles refuting claims…See More
18 minutes ago
Profile Icon via Twitter
Twitter40 minutes ago · Reply · Retweet
Chris of the family Masters replied to Fat Freddys Cat's discussion Applause & bashing on Twitter after transgender woman wins female cycling world championship
"It's never man to woman in sport, strange eh...."
41 minutes ago
Doc Vega commented on Doc Vega's blog post More Classified E-Mails and revelations on Benghazi!
"Fuckin hilarious Central Scrutinizer I'd pay for a seat at that matinee!"
1 hour ago
Boris Badenov commented on Boris Badenov's page "Math Correction" Confirms Warren Could Be 0.001% Native American
"- Obama 65 percent white"
1 hour ago
Thomas Less posted a blog post

Daily Verse

But now, this is what the Lord says— he who created you, Jacob, he who formed you, Israel: “Do not fear, for I have redeemed you; I have summoned you by name; you are mine. When you pass through the waters, I will be with you; and when you pass…See More
1 hour ago
Boris Badenov posted a photo

Among the Ruins of Mexico Beach Stands One House, Built ‘for the Big One’

“We wanted to build it for the big one,” he said. “We just never knew we’d find the big one so fast.”…
1 hour ago
Boris Badenov commented on Boris Badenov's page The source for these Jamal Khashoggi stories? Khaled Saffuri
1 hour ago
Boris Badenov commented on Boris Badenov's page LEAKED: Hillary Clinton's 2020 Campaign Commercial
1 hour ago
Profile Icon via Twitter
RT @titanmaximum2: @12160mhz CNN changed it's name to CNPC
Twitter3 hours ago · Reply · Retweet
raymond moody posted photos
3 hours ago
Fat Freddys Cat posted discussions
5 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on Fat Freddys Cat's blog post The Quiet Epidemic With Allona Lahn
"'I do not consent to my child being injected with toxic chemicals'"
6 hours ago
cheeki kea favorited Doc Vega's blog post Never Forget Benghazi and Why Democrats Should Never Be in Charge!
7 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on Fat Freddys Cat's blog post The Quiet Epidemic With Allona Lahn
"wow..I want to make a comment, but I don't what to say. These links lead to the saddest posts I've ever seen. We should warn all parents we know and ask if they would be willing to view some information, like this. "
7 hours ago
cheeki kea favorited Fat Freddys Cat's video
7 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on cheeki kea's photo

Queers Crossing

"These queer cops and town planners and Govt endorsers get special dispensation from kosher-ness. (if for the 'greater good' "by any means possible'. "To meet the agenda".) The only good thing about the Capital city is,…"
7 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on cheeki kea's photo

Queers Crossing

"They'll have to make up their minds. Queer freemasons doesn't look kosher...."
8 hours ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2018   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted