Sarkozy Seizes Opportunity for Internet Censorship After Terror Attack

French President Sarkozy Sees Opportunity for Censorship, Seizes It

March 22, 2012 | By Jillian C. York

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2012/03/french-president-sarkozy-sees...

In the wake of a horrific rampage, in which Mohamed Merah (now dead after a 32-hour standoff with police) reportedly murdered three French soldiers, three young Jewish schoolchildren, and a rabbi, President Nicolas Sarkozy of France has begun calling for criminal penalties for citizens who visit web sites that advocate for terror or hate.  "From now on, any person who habitually consults Web sites that advocate terrorism or that call for hatred and violence will be criminally punished," Sarkozy was reported as saying.

Apart from the obvious flaws in Sarkozy's plan--users, can, of course, use anonymizing tools to view the material or simply access it from a variety of locations to avoid appearing as "habitual" viewers--there are numerous other reasons to be concerned about criminalizing access to information.

First, there's no guarantee that criminalizing access to hate speech or terrorist content will end the very real problems of hate crime and terrorism.  Extremist violence didn't start with the Internet and it won't end with it, either.

Second, who defines "hate speech"?  In France, that definition includes Holocaust denial, which in the past resulted in Yahoo! discontinuing auctions of Nazi memoribilia (the collectors of which are not, by any stretch, all sympathizers).  And negative comments about France's Muslim community have also resulted in criminal penalties, most notably in the case of actress Brigitte Bardot, who has been convicted five times for "inciting racial hatred."  While Holocaust denial and comments about Muslims such as those made by Bardot may be deplorable, they should not be criminal.

Finally, while Sarkozy is not--yet--calling for websites to be blocked, it wouldn't be a stretch; after all, France already offers mechanisms for blocking child pornography and "incitement to terrorism and racial hatred." If Sarkozy were to decide censorship is the answer, one major risk would be overblocking: there's nary a country in the world that censors the Internet without collateral damage (in Australia, for example, testing on a would-be censorship regime found the site of a dentist blocked, among others).

EFF has serious concerns about the implications of Sarkozy's comments.  When a democratic country such as France decides to censor or criminalize speech, it is not just the French that suffer, but the world, as authoritarian regimes are given easy justification for their own censorship.  We urge French authorities to judge crime on action, not expression.

Views: 136

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Unemployed Storm trooper TK420 on March 24, 2012 at 8:20am

This Just prove that Sarkozy is totally overrated as a Leader.  The guy is a total idiot !

"Destroying the New World Order"

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

Latest Activity

Profile Icont.me/TheIntelligenceLibrary and Twin City Security Fort Worth joined 12160 Social Network
2 hours ago
Less Prone commented on Doc Vega's blog post FBI Agent Admits Evidence of Sasquatch Existence
"Watch the Mike Cremo video. The story goes back a million…"
7 hours ago
Less Prone favorited Doc Vega's blog post FBI Agent Admits Evidence of Sasquatch Existence
7 hours ago
Less Prone posted a video

DOT-COM BUST 2.0; WHEN ALL ELSE FAILS THEY TAKE YOU TO WAR

The Trends Journal is a weekly magazine analyzing global current events forming future trends. Our mission is to present Facts and Truth over fear and propag...
7 hours ago
tjdavis posted photos
9 hours ago
tjdavis favorited Doc Vega's blog post The Great DC Ivory Tower of Deception
yesterday
tjdavis posted videos
yesterday
Doc Vega posted blog posts
yesterday
Less Prone commented on Less Prone's video
Thumbnail

Forbidden Archaeology | Michael Cremo | Talks at Google

"Forbidden Archeology and the Consciousness Paradox "Michael Cremo, also known as the…"
yesterday
Less Prone posted a video

Forbidden Archaeology | Michael Cremo | Talks at Google

Over the past two centuries, archaeologists have found bones, footprints, and artifacts showing that people like ourselves have existed on earth for many mil...
yesterday
tjdavis posted a video
Friday
cheeki kea posted a photo
Thursday
cheeki kea commented on Doc Vega's blog post World Government Reveals itself Over Zelensky Oval Office Meltdown
"Great essay Doc V. We are seeing the world clowns reveal themselves in record time, often by left…"
Thursday
Less Prone favorited Doc Vega's photo
Thursday
Doc Vega posted photos
Wednesday
Doc Vega posted blog posts
Wednesday
Doc Vega posted a blog post

World Government Reveals itself Over Zelensky Oval Office Meltdown

 Was it simply President Trump’s scorched earth retaliatory reply to the disrespect of Ukraine’s…See More
Tuesday
cheeki kea favorited tjdavis's blog post GenAI fueling employee impersonation with biometric spoofs and counterfeit ID fraud
Tuesday
Doc Vega's blog post was featured

Blue Eyed and Blonde

I fell in love with her the very first timeShe was never subtle and hardly sublimeEven her mother…See More
Mar 3
cheeki kea commented on cheeki kea's video
Mar 2

© 2025   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted