Should person who sends driver a text be blamed for a crash?

Mobile devices

We adore our mobile devices. But a New Jersey court case underscores the dangers of texting and driving. (Bloomberg News / May 24, 2012)

We all know we're not supposed to text and drive. But what about texting with someone else when that person is texting and driving?

A tragic case being heard in a New Jersey courtroom on Friday is testing the limits of such responsibility in a potentially precedent-setting case. It's also serving as a cautionary tale about the sometimes irresistible lure of our mobile devices.

Here's what happened, according to local coverage of the high-profile case in the New Jersey Star-Ledger and the Daily Record:

David and Linda Kubert were out on theirHarley-Davidsonon Sept. 21, 2009, enjoying a winding Morris County road. That's when they saw, Kyle Best, 19, driving a pickup truck headed in their direction. In the final seconds before impact, the couple could see he had his elbows -- not his hands -- on the steering wheel, and his face was peering down.

Authorities would later determine that Best was using his cellphone to text with his girlfriend, Shannon Colonna. Best pleaded guilty earlier this year to three traffic citations and was ordered to pay $775 and speak at 14 schools about the dangers of texting and driving. His driver's license was not suspended.

That's a slap on the wrist, as far as the Kuberts are concerned.

The Kuberts, both 56, each lost their left legs in the crash. They have endured multiple surgeries and medical costs. They have also become crusaders working with state legislators to beef up punishment for drivers who text from behind the wheel.

But it's their legal action that is raising eyebrows: They are suing both Best and Colonna. The attorney for the Kuberts, Stephen Weinstein, says that Colonna -- who was also 19 at the time -- aided and abetted Best’s negligence by texting him when she knew or should have known he was driving.

No surprise, but Colonna’s lawyer, Joseph McGlone, disagrees. "It’s not fair. It’s not reasonable. Shannon Colonna has no way to control when Kyle Best is going to read that message," McGlone told the Daily Record.

McGlone has asked Morris County Superior Court Judge David Rand to dismiss Colonna from the case. Rand has indicated he will issue his decision on Friday in the case with implications far beyond his courtroom.

Join Rene Lynch on Google+, Facebook or Twitter. Email:

Views: 57


You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Nikki on May 24, 2012 at 7:45pm

I really feel sorry for the Kuberts but it's all Best's fault.  He did not have to answer her texts while he was driving.

"Destroying the New World Order"


mobile page

12160 Administrators



Latest Activity

Less Prone favorited Central Scrutinizer's photo
35 minutes ago
Mr. Sizzle posted a photo
59 minutes ago
Mr. Sizzle commented on Central Scrutinizer's photo

Its a Madhouse!!

"I improved on a few things,"
1 hour ago
Mr. Sizzle favorited Central Scrutinizer's photo
1 hour ago
MAC posted discussions
3 hours ago
Amaterasu Solar posted a discussion

Would You Be Happier? - Censored Off YouToilet (9 minutes)

A video I posted to YouToilet was removed for "medical misinformation."  Pretty funny, that!  It…See More
5 hours ago
Patrick C Conway commented on Twilight Zone's photo

Ya Think?

"Wow!  Comes the dawn?"
5 hours ago
Twilight Zone posted discussions
7 hours ago
Larry Flinchpaugh posted blog posts
7 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters posted blog posts
8 hours ago
Twilight Zone replied to Twilight Zone's discussion Border Security Director in Biden's White House Will Come from the UN
"This is Barry's reign 2.0.  All of Joey's cabinet are from Barry's group or UN…"
9 hours ago
MAC replied to Twilight Zone's discussion Border Security Director in Biden's White House Will Come from the UN
"During the Darkfag aka Obama administration if I'm not mistaking, the u.S. population went…"
9 hours ago
Guardian of Scotland commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post Joe Biden Issued 0 Executive Orders
"The Federal Register now indidates that there are Executive Orders sent by Biden.  This even…"
9 hours ago
Twilight Zone favorited MAC's discussion Hard-left Biden’s first days aimed at destroying America First
10 hours ago
rlionhearted_3 posted a status
"Glenn Kessler’s WaPoo factchecker Facebook account is allowing raw pictures and videos to be uploaded. Visit and share! Drive them nuts"
12 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer's photo was featured
12 hours ago
Bob Renner's photo was featured
13 hours ago
Twilight Zone posted photos
13 hours ago
Aaron posted videos
13 hours ago
Aaron posted blog posts
13 hours ago

© 2021   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted