Who Started the Bombing of Civilians in WWII?

As part of a general post-World War II propaganda campaign to paint the Germans in as bad a light as possible, the controlled media has always claimed that the Germans started the bombing of civilians, using the two examples of the Luftwaffe attack on Warsaw, Poland, in September 1939 and the May 14, 1940 bombing of Rotterdam, the Netherlands.

The propaganda story goes along the lines that the Germans bombed these cities and thereby set the example of the mass bombing of civilians—and then followed this up with the “blitz” on London.

Only after all this, it is claimed, did the Germans “get back” what they had dished out.

This myth has been stated over and over so many times by the controlled media that it has become the “popular” understanding of the course of the war.

The reality, like so much else about World War II, is completely the opposite.

https://i0.wp.com/barnesreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Bombing-Vinidcated-cover.jpg?resize=100%2C150&ssl=1 100w, https://i0.wp.com/barnesreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Bombi... 283w" sizes="(max-width: 200px) 100vw, 200px" />In 1944, public discontent in Britain over the RAF’s civilian bombing policy had reached record heights, and to counteract this dissent, the former British Principal Secretary of the Air Ministry, J.M. Spaight, published a book titled Bombing Vindicated, which set out to justify the saturation bombing of German civilians.

The Bombing of Warsaw 

Spaight was honest in his book about the origins of the civilian bombing, and openly admitted that the Warsaw and Rotterdam bombings could not be compared to the RAF’s tactics, saying: “When Warsaw and Rotterdam were bombed, German armies were at their gates. The air bombardment was an operation of the tactical offensive.”

In other words, the bombing of Warsaw took place as part of a set tactical battle. The German army had laid siege to the city on September 16, 1939, and the Polish bravely—and fiercely—resisted until September 27, turning the city into an effective fortress which the Germans battled to subdue.

The Luftwaffe attack was therefore, part of the established rules of conflict and not a saturation bombing of civilians.

The Bombing of Rotterdam

The Rotterdam bombing was an identical scenario: German paratroopers had in fact been defeated in their May 10, 1940 attempt to seize the city of The Hague—a victory by a brave Dutch army which has also passed unnoticed, ignored by the Anglo-Saxon mass media—and it was up to German ground forces to press home the invasion.

Dutch resistance elsewhere was also far stronger than the Germans had anticipated, and an attempt by the German army to seize the 20 mile (32 kilometer)-long Afsluitdijk in the north of Holland was also defeated in a two-day long battle from May 12–14, 1940. The fierce Dutch resistance was beginning to hold up the entire German plan.

By May 13, the German army had reached Rotterdam, but once again Dutch military resistance halted the advance.

The Dutch defenders, under the able command of Colonel Pieter Scharroo, held the north bank of the Nieuwe Maas River, which runs through the city and completely blocked German forces from passing through.

On the Morning of May 14, Hitler issued his “Directive Number 11: Concerning the Dutch theater of operations” in which he ordered the following:

“The resistance capability of the Dutch army has proved to be stronger than expected. Political as well as military reasons demand that this resistance is broken as soon as possible. It is the task of the army to capture the Fortress Holland by committing enough forces from the south, combined with an attack on the east front. In addition to that the air force must, while weakening the forces that up till now have supported the 6th Army, facilitate the rapid fall of the Fortress Holland.”

In response to this order, the German forces in Rotterdam prepared a combined assault for May 14, using Panzer tanks, combat engineers, and paratroopers to make an amphibious crossing of the Nieuwe Maas river upstream and then try and take the city through Kralingen, about one mile from the city center. As part of these ground attacks, the Luftwaffe was called in to provide a precision strike on the Dutch forces.

At the same time, negotiations were opened between the besieging German forces and the Dutch defenders for the surrender of the city.

As part of the talks, the German commander called off the air attack, but a critical delay in passing messages ensured that only 40 of the 100 attacking aircraft received the abort message—and as a result, the city was bombed by 60 German Heinkel He 111 bombers.

https://i0.wp.com/barnesreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Rotterdam-bombed.jpg?resize=150%2C98&ssl=1 150w, https://i0.wp.com/barnesreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Rotte... 300w" sizes="(max-width: 600px) 100vw, 600px" data-recalc-dims="1" />

The city center of Rotterdam after the bombing. Exactly one square mile of the city center was destroyed in the bombing raid, an indication of the pin-point accuracy of the bombers, which were only deployed to support the German forces on the ground right next to the bombed area.

As tragic as the bombing of Rotterdam and Warsaw was—indeed, as tragic as the entire war was—the reality remains that both strikes were in direct support of attacking ground troops, and were not strikes against civilians for the purpose of spreading terror without any military objective.

https://i0.wp.com/barnesreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Dutch-soldiers-surrendering-Rotterdam-1940.jpg?resize=150%2C104&ssl=1 150w, https://i0.wp.com/barnesreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Dutch... 300w" sizes="(max-width: 600px) 100vw, 600px" data-recalc-dims="1" />

Dutch officers negotiating the surrender of Rotterdam, 1940.

It was in fact the British RAF, under the direct orders of Winston Churchill, which started the saturation bombing of civilians—on May 10, 1940, the day the new Prime Minister took office. From that day onward, British bombers bombed German civilian targets almost every night.

Even then, Hitler ordered the Luftwaffe not to respond in kind, and only to bomb military targets in Britain, such as airfields and ports, in preparation for a planned invasion of the United Kingdom.

On August 25, 1940, a German raid on an oil refinery on the banks of Thames River in east London took place as part of this tactical assault. Some of the bombs landed next to the refinery, in London’s East End, causing no casualities—but in response to this bombing, described by the post-war Official History of the Defence of the United Kingdom as “unintentional”—the first mass raid on Berlin by British bombers took place six days later.

After that, regular British raids on Berlin’s non-military targets took place—and escalated throughout the war.

Despite these attacks on Berlin, Hitler still refused to retaliate. But this situation could not last, and after nearly four months, the Luftwaffe was finally ordered to strike back.

In a speech in the Berlin Sportspalast on September 4, 1940, Hitler announced the German retaliation this way:

“Whereas German aviators and German planes fly over English soil daily, there is hardly a single Englishman who comes across the North Sea in daytime. They therefore come during the night, and as you know, release their bombs indiscriminately and without any plan on to residential areas, farmhouses and villages. Wherever they see a sign of light, a bomb is dropped on it.

For three months past, I have not ordered any answer to be given; thinking that they would stop this nonsensical behavior.

“Mr. Churchill has taken this to be a sign of our weakness.

“You will understand that we shall now give a reply, night for night, and with increasing force. We will put a stop to the game of these night-pirates, as God is our witness.”

As J.M. Spaight detailed in his book, it was the British who were to “realise the full potential” of saturation civilian bombing, and that the British bombers were designed to bomb cities, he said, while the “Teutonic mind” never even considered such a policy, and instead viewed an air force merely as a tool to “blast open” a path for attacking armies.

Spaight also wrote that Hitler’s hope that “Churchill would stop this nonsense” was “stupid” and furthermore the “blitz” on London which followed was actually minor by comparison to what had already been thrown at German cities by the RAF, and to what occurred in 1943 and 1944 (the bombing of Hamburg, Cologne, and Munich—where, Spaight boasted, the fires could be seen 150 miles away).

https://i0.wp.com/barnesreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Koln.jpg?resize=150%2C100&ssl=1 150w, https://i0.wp.com/barnesreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Koln.... 300w" sizes="(max-width: 600px) 100vw, 600px" data-recalc-dims="1" />

The German city of Cologne was bombed in 262 separate air raids by the Allies, starting on May 12, 1940.

Furthermore, Spaight said, the German air force was never used for anything else until ordered to retaliate against the British campaign. As Spaight put it:

“Whatever Hitler wanted or did not want, he most assuredly did not want the mutual bombing to go on. He had not wanted it ever to begin. He wanted it, having begun, to be called off. There was ample evidence that he did not want the latter kind of bombing to become the practice. He had done his best to have it banned by international agreement.”

It was therefore British policy which ultimately led to the destruction of Dresden in February 1945. The city had no military targets at all, and did not even possess a single anti-aircraft gun.

The city was filled with refugees—and even Allied prisoners of war (the most famous being the author Kurt Vonnegut, whose book Slaughterhouse-Five was based on his recollection of the bombing).

Some 700,000 incendiary bombs were dropped on Dresden, one bomb for every two inhabitants. Temperatures above ground reached up to 1,600 degrees Celsius, or 2912 degrees Fahrenheit. Unknown thousands of people—estimates vary up to 135,000 or more—were killed in the resulting firestorm, and the entire city was laid waste.

https://i0.wp.com/barnesreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Dresden-bombed.jpg?resize=150%2C108&ssl=1 150w, https://i0.wp.com/barnesreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Dresd... 300w" sizes="(max-width: 600px) 100vw, 600px" data-recalc-dims="1" />

The aftermath of the bombing of Dresden.

The establishment historians are equally reticent over the role of Churchill and the RAF in the bombing of Dresden, and are always seeking reasons to excuse this war crime.

The reality is that Churchill and the RAF bomber command under Sir Arthur Harris knew very well what was going to happen and also that there was no military justification for the attack.

The truth about Churchill’s role in the destruction of Dresden was revealed in a memo held by the RAF’s Air Historical Branch, which quotes the British Prime Minister as only being interesting in how many civilian refugees he could “fry” with the attack:

“I do not want to receive any suggestions how we can destroy militarily important targets in Dresden’s hinterland, I want to get suggestions how we can fry 600,000 refugees from Breslau in Dresden.”—Winston Churchill, as quoted in a Minute by A.P.S. of S.—Air Chief Marshal Sir Wilfrid Freeman—Jan. 26, 1945 in Air Historical Branch file CMS 608.

A funeral pyre in Dresden, February 1945

Who Started the Bombing of Civilians in WWII? - Barnes Review

A TEARFUL veteran who witnessed the Dresden bombing today recalled the moment he saw children melting in the fire-storm.

The four raids saw more than 3,900 tonnes of bombs and incendiary devices dropped on the ancient cathedral city between February 13 to 15.

Thousands of people were killed in the raids, which has become one of the most controversial Allied actions of World War Two.

Wiping away tears, he said he still struggled to accept the horrific sights, saying: "The way in which these people died - unless you were there you can't possibly, your brain won't accept it.

"There was never any sign of children because children melt. Their bones are too tender, they just melted.

"You didn't even see skeletons."

Tearful veteran who witnessed Dresden bombing recalls children MELT...

Don't forget the US was there bombing alongside of Britain.  One must ask what kind of psychopaths would do such a thing and who would consider Churchill some kind of a hero.

Views: 67


You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Parrhesia on November 18, 2022 at 11:33am

"Churchill was a WWI veteran who placed himself in the trenches with the foot soldiers as he did not want them to suffer anything he was unwilling to accept."

Churchill served a 125-day tenure as battalion commander in WW1.  He showed up at the RSF’s camp with two servants and a large wagon.  The wagon’s load included a bath and a water heater.  Churchill would equip himself with waterproof trousers, knee-high boots, a stylish waterproof coat and a torch when he ventured into the trenches.  Yep, he didn't want to ask his troops to suffer anything he wouldn't.

Perhaps you are confused and meant to say Hitler who was actually a WW1 frontline soldier from 1914-1918.

Comment by Parrhesia on November 17, 2022 at 6:39pm

Germany did not start the bombing of civilian areas just to terrorize.  The German bombings of Rotterdam (1940) and Warsaw (1939) were in direct support of attacking ground troops and were not strikes against civilians for the purpose of spreading terror without any military objective.

Chamberlain had always opposed the use of bombing against urban targets, but Churchill had no conscientious or legal objections.  Up until Churchill’s appointment as prime minister both Germany and Britain had stuck to a pledge not to attack targets in each other’s cities where civilians were at risk.  Between 1940 and 1945, sixty-one German cities with a total population of 25 million were destroyed or devastated in a bombing campaign initiated by the British government. Destruction on this scale had no other purpose than the indiscriminate mass murder of as many German people as possible quite regardless of their civilian status.  

All German towns and cities above 50,000 population were from 50% to 80% destroyed. Hamburg was totally destroyed and 70,000 civilians died in the most appalling circumstances whilst Cologne was likewise turned into a moon-scape. As Hamburg burned the winds feeding the three mile high flames reached twice hurricane speed to exceed 150 miles per hour. Trees three feet in diameter on the outskirts of the city were sucked from the ground by the supernatural forces of these winds and hurled miles into the city-inferno, as were vehicles, men, women and children.

These bombings were International War Crimes and London bombings were retaliation for Churchill's heartless choices.  (The first RAF raid on Berlin took place on the night of 25 August 1940.  In the following two weeks there were a further five raids of a similar size.  On September 7, 1940, 300 German bombers raid London, in the first of 57 consecutive nights of bombing.) “I do not want to receive any suggestions how we can destroy militarily important targets in Dresden’s hinterland, I want to get suggestions how we can fry 600,000 refugees from Breslau in Dresden.”—Winston Churchill, as quoted in a Minute by A.P.S. of S.—Air Chief Marshal Sir Wilfrid Freeman—Jan. 26, 1945 in Air Historical Branch file CMS 608.

Comment by Doc Vega on November 17, 2022 at 4:34pm

One might recall the desperation of Europe and the Britsh in the face of the the Blitzkrieg and the German lead in aerial technology as the V-1 and V-2 rockets were unleashed on cvilian targets . One might recall Winston Churchill making a daily inspection of the burned out town of London that was fortunately hanging on as the civilan population hunkered down in th subways below on a nightly basis. Ive seen film of dead children in London drug from beneath rubble and people coughing up smoke from their lungs after being buried under ash and burned down material. The Germans had worn down the RAF to less than 200 servicable planes with which to defend the UK after being bombed mercilessly by the Goering's Luftwaffe at Dunkirk in the rescue of the trapped troops on the beaches. 60 thousand French troops on the southern French coast never got picked up.  Luckily for the British, the Luftwaffe had just about doen the job but decided they could no longer sustain the attrition as the "Wolf pack" of U-boats effectively harassed British shipping. Within less than 2 years the greatest global navy on the high seas (Royal Navy) had been decimated in the Pacific and Atlantic by the Nazi and Imperial Japanese forces then in late 1942 the size and scope of Allied forces fell into the hands of the US Navy under Chester Nimitz and CINCPAC. The rest is the politically motivated moral arguments of those who weren't there and didn't realize the impact it had on the people and the fear after years of the Great Depression and we look back not living in their shoes and pass judgement. I talked to many a WWII veteran even one of my insurance agents wholived throught the war told me how it seemd like the end of the world to many people then. I don't Churchill was a war criminal. I think he was the man of the hour that th rest of the Royal Familiy was incapable of commandeering. Even the Duke of Windsor was a Nazi collaborator. Churchill was a WWI veteran who placed himself in the trenches with the foot soldiers as he did not want them to suffer anything he was unwilling to accept.

"Destroying the New World Order"



mobile page


12160 Administrators

Doc Vega, Chris of the family Masters, cheeki kea and 3 more were featured


Latest Activity

steve posted a discussion

A real woman finally speaks up against this mental illness of the TRANSFORMERS

I don't understand how NORMAL RIGHT MINDED folks can go along to get along with these obviously…See More
4 hours ago
steve commented on MAC's video

New BOMBSHELL Report on Electric Cars will change everything | Redacted with Clayton Morris

"SCAM after Scam after scam these thieving sons of demons keep coming up with yet either no one…"
4 hours ago
Doc Vega posted blog posts
6 hours ago
EDOGZ818 replied to EDOGZ818's discussion Militia Informants - Charles Dyer / July 4 Patriot Case
"UPDATE : Darren Wilburn pleas guilty to Child Porn, sentenced to 5…"
9 hours ago
MAC posted videos
10 hours ago
Parrhesia commented on tjdavis's blog post Gate$ Ca$he$ out
"On to the next scam."
17 hours ago
Parrhesia favorited tjdavis's blog post Gate$ Ca$he$ out
17 hours ago
Parrhesia commented on Ragnarok's video

Israel: Two people injured in possible shooting in occupied East Jerusalem [Jan. 28th, 2023]

"Netanyahu The Zionist is really hitting the Palestinians hard, but MSM won't tell you…"
17 hours ago
Parrhesia commented on MAC's video


"Many people with small flocks are saying that some of the chicken feed is keeping the hens from…"
17 hours ago
Sandy posted a video

Turning Plastic Into Protein?

Scientists are researching how to transform components of plastic into protein and other nutrients like fats and sugars. Steve Techtmann at Michigan Technolo...
21 hours ago
Burbia replied to steve's discussion pFIZER FAGGOT freaks out when exposed by Project Veritas
Doc Vega posted blog posts
tjdavis posted a blog post
Ragnarok posted videos
Less Prone favorited MAC's video
Less Prone posted a video

Episode 1995 EXCERPT - AntiVaxxers Win

The Anti-Vaxxers are clearly the winners.A compilation clip. For the full discussion with details and nuance, see Episode 1995.
MAC posted a video


It's more like murder. Chickens by the tens of millions are being culled and it's hurting meat and egg production every where. But Why?See the Genesis Gold G...
steve commented on Ragnarok's video

Tyre Nichols: 'State of Emergency' issued in Georgia ahead of possible protests

"Am I psychic or what hatefullest sheboon on the tube blames the race she is envious of for negroid…"
tjdavis favorited Sandy's video
tjdavis posted a photo

© 2023   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted