Warrant needed to snoop on your emails, court finally rules

By Daniel Tencer
Tuesday, December 14th, 2010 -- 7:46 pm

After many years of legal uncertainty, a federal appeals court has finally declared that emails have the same Fourth Amendment protections as regular mail and telephone calls.

"Given the fundamental similarities between email and traditional forms of communication, it would defy common sense to afford emails lesser Fourth Amendment protection," the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled (PDF).

If the ruling is not overturned by the Supreme Court, it will put an end to the practice of law enforcement agents using court orders, rather than warrants, to gain access to emails. Court orders require a much lower standard than warrants.

Kevin Bankston of the digital rights group EFF told Wired.com he expects Internet service providers will comply with the ruling, meaning they will start requesting warrants when law enforcement requests access to emails.

Privacy advocates say law enforcement has been using a loophole in the 1986 Stored Communications Act to get emails without a warrant. Under that law, information stored on servers is subject only to a court order.

As Wired notes, the law was written at a time when emails -- then still a novelty -- weren't stored on remote servers. But today's email services, such as Hotmail and Gmail, use servers to store all emails, giving law enforcement warrantless access.

A group of businesses, including Microsoft, Google and AOL, have been lobbying the US to update its laws so that all emails require a warrant.

At issue in the Sixth Circuit's ruling was the criminal case of Steven Warshak, founder of the company that sells Enzyte "male enhancement" pills. Warshak was given a 25-year sentence in 2008 after being convicted of 93 counts of fraud, conspiracy and money laundering.

Warshak appealed the ruling, saying his Fourth Amendment rights were violated when investigators failed to obtain a warrant for his emails. In its ruling Tuesday, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals agreed with Warshak and effectively declared parts of the Stored Communications Act to be unconstitutional.

However, the court also said that law enforcement agents "acted in good faith" in using the Stored Communications Act to obtain the emails, so it will not vacate Warshak's conviction. ZDNet reports that he may see a lesser sentence as a result.

"Today's decision is the only federal appellate decision currently on the books that squarely rules on this critically important privacy issue, an issue made all the more important by the fact that current federal law ... allows the government to secretly obtain emails without a warrant in many situations," the EFF said in a statement.

"We hope that this ruling will spur Congress to update that law ... so that when the government secretly demands someone's email without probable cause, the email provider can confidently say: 'Come back with a warrant.'"


Get Raw Story updates!

Views: 85

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

That is good news if it is local law enforcement that has an interest in reading them but the fact of the matter is that a rubber stamped FISA warrant still works for anything the feds want to do.

Fourth amendment protection is really irrelevant when we still have an existing court that will grant a warrant based on you farting in a government building while complaining about the long line.....After all, you might have been trying to kill people with a gas attack......And that, by God, is terrorism!!!!



"Destroying the New World Order"



mobile page


12160 Administrators

Doc Vega, Chris of the family Masters, cheeki kea and 3 more were featured


Latest Activity

tjdavis posted photos
1 hour ago
Parrhesia posted photos
3 hours ago
Doc Vega posted blog posts
5 hours ago
Parrhesia posted videos
5 hours ago
tjdavis posted videos
5 hours ago
Parrhesia posted a discussion

Former Pentagon Advisor Says US Likely Attacked Nord Stream Pipelines to Isolate Germany

“You have to look at who are the state actors that have the capability to do this.”A former…See More
6 hours ago
Parrhesia commented on Sandy's video

Iraq Veteran Confronts Ex-President George W. Bush On War Deaths #Shorts

"Not to mention those wounded and displaced plus the excuse for the invasion of Europe from all the…"
8 hours ago
Parrhesia favorited Sandy's video
8 hours ago
Sandy posted a video

Iraq Veteran Confronts Ex-President George W. Bush On War Deaths #Shorts

A U.S. Army veteran confronted ex-President George W. Bush at a speech on Sunday, demanding the former president apologize for civilian deaths during the Ira...
9 hours ago
Ragnarok commented on Less Prone's video
9 hours ago
Ragnarok favorited Less Prone's video
9 hours ago
Parrhesia favorited MAC's video
9 hours ago
Parrhesia favorited Burbia's video
11 hours ago
Parrhesia favorited tjdavis's photo
11 hours ago
Ragnarok posted videos
16 hours ago
Burbia commented on Burbia's video

University of Washington unknowingly helped a jailed ‘body broker’ find donors

"There was a comment made when Ann Heche was "died" in a car wreck. It was by hospital…"
18 hours ago
Burbia posted a video

University of Washington unknowingly helped a jailed ‘body broker’ find donors

A KING 5 investigation found that the largest medical school in the Northwest unwittingly helped supply donated human bodies to a former Seattle man who is n...
18 hours ago
tjdavis favorited Doc Vega's blog post A Secret Letter Containing Biden's Plans for Trump Supporters Using the Military?
20 hours ago
MAC posted a video

Roundtable #25: George Galloway, Syrian Girl, Alex Thomson

Subscribe to my Rumble, where I will be when I get deplatformed from YouTube:https://rumble.com/c/c-1913107George Galloway’s Twitter: https://twitter.com/geo...
Kath is now a member of 12160 Social Network

© 2022   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted