“A Florida Judge Ruled that Police Officers Had No Duty to Protect Students in Parkland Massacre.”

A federal judge in Florida ruled that the Broward County schools and the county sheriff’s office had no legal duty to protect students during the shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School on Feb. 14.CreditCreditSaul Martinez for The New York Times
  • Dec. 18, 2018
    The school district and sheriff’s office in the Florida county that is home to Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School had no constitutional duty to protect the students there during the deadly February massacre, a federal judge has said in a ruling.
    The decision was made in a lawsuit filed by 15 students who said they suffered trauma during the Feb. 14 attack in Parkland, Fla. A total of 17 students and staff members lost their lives; 17 others were injured.
    Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty for Nikolas Cruz, 20, the former Stoneman Douglas student who is accused of opening fire at the school on Valentine’s Day. He has pleaded not guilty, but his lawyers have said he would plead guilty in exchange for a life sentence.
    The Dec. 12 ruling, by Judge Beth Bloom, came on the same day that a county judge, Patti Englander Henning, came to the opposite conclusion. Judge Henning found that Scot Peterson, the armed sheriff’s deputy who heard the gunfire but did not run in and try to stop the attack, did have an obligation to confront Mr. Cruz.
    The two decisions in rapid succession highlight an assumption often made: the belief that the public has a right to receive protection from police officers.
    But police officers, in fact, generally are not under any legal obligation to protect citizens who are not in their custody.
    “Neither the Constitution, nor state law, impose a general duty upon police officers or other governmental officials to protect individual persons from harm — even when they know the harm will occur,” said Darren L. Hutchinson, a professor and associate dean at the University of Florida School of Law. “Police can watch someone attack you, refuse to intervene and not violate the Constitution.”
    The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that the government has only a duty to protect persons who are “in custody,” he pointed out.
    “Courts have rejected the argument that students are in custody of school officials while they are on campus,” Mr. Hutchinson said. “Custody is narrowly confined to situations where a person loses his or her freedom to move freely and seek assistance on their own — such as prisons, jails, or mental institutions.”
    There are exceptions, Mr. Hutchinson said, as when a crossing guard who is specifically assigned to protect children traveling across a street allows a child to get run over while, say, the guard is being distracted by a smartphone. The crossing guard is in a “special relationship” with the children, in legal eyes.
    When an officer has a “special relationship” with people, or acts to “enhance the risk” of harm, the officer can be liable for any resulting injury under state negligence laws, Mr. Hutchinson said.
    This is likely how Judge Henning found that Mr. Peterson did have a duty to protect those inside the school and refused to dismiss the negligence lawsuit filed by Andrew Pollack, whose daughter Meadow was killed.
    The county lawsuit argued that Mr. Peterson had a “special relationship” with students and staff members at the school because he was specifically assigned to offer them protection.
    Video footage and other evidence shows Mr. Peterson, the only armed officer at the school, staying outside while shots could be heard exploding from inside the school. Mr. Peterson also launched a “code red” to put the entire school on lockdown.
    “They also argued that he enhanced the risk of death, or injury, by Mr. Cruz by negligently ordering a lockdown, which prevented escape from the building,” Mr. Hutchinson said. “Either of these assertions could support liability for Peterson. But I would not be surprised if the state case was reversed on appeal. It is very difficult to establish liability in this area of law.”
    The federal decision is expected to be appealed.
    A state commission that has been investigating the attack found last week that there was a multitude of failures on the part of the school and law enforcement officials in the response to the shooting.
    At least eight sheriff’s deputies who raced to the school and heard gunshots stayed outside the building, the commission wrote in a 400-page draft report, and officers lost even more time scrambling to retrieve bulletproof vests from their cars.
    Follow Adeel Hassan on Twitter @adeelnyt.

    Comment

    You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

    Join 12160 Social Network

    Comment by Boris on December 20, 2018 at 10:45am
    No Duty to Protect Students

    "Destroying the New World Order"

    TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

    THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

    mobile page

    12160.info/m

    12160 Administrators

     

    Latest Activity

    Sandy posted a video

    Dr. Mike Yeadon Speaks Out Against Digital ID, CBDCs, and Agenda 2030

    Dr. Mike Yeadon, ex-Pfizer VP, urges public rejection of digital ID, CBDCs, and Agenda 2030, warning of future restrictions on freedom and privacy.
    9 hours ago
    Doc Vega posted blog posts
    16 hours ago
    Burbia posted a video

    "EVERYONE'S BEEN SHOT UP HERE": Arsonists Set Wildfire In Idaho, Open Fire On Firefighters, Police

    - Shocking news just broke that multiple firefighters and officers were shot in an ambush at the Canfield Mountain Natural Area in Coeur d'Alene, Idaho.Acco...
    yesterday
    Doc Vega posted a blog post

    The Draconian Show

    Sometimes I talk to my invisible friend, IkeHe comes from another dimension when magnetic fields…See More
    Friday
    tjdavis posted a blog post
    Thursday
    Doc Vega posted a blog post
    Wednesday
    Doc Vega posted blog posts
    Jun 24
    Doc Vega posted blog posts
    Jun 23
    Doc Vega favorited tjdavis's photo
    Jun 22
    Doc Vega commented on tjdavis's photo
    Thumbnail

    Game Night

    "Ha! Good one!"
    Jun 22
    Doc Vega commented on FREEDOMROX's blog post MRNA VACCINES: Question
    "Listen man I know where you're at but back in October of 2023 thru December of 2023 for months…"
    Jun 22
    tjdavis posted a video

    Architecton | Official Trailer HD | A24

    SUBSCRIBE: http://bit.ly/A24subscribeWritten and directed by Victor Kossakovsky and starring Michele De Lucchi. ARCHITECTON – Coming Soon RELEASE DATE: Comin...
    Jun 22
    tjdavis posted photos
    Jun 22
    tjdavis posted a blog post
    Jun 21
    Burbia posted a video

    Europe Will Not Survive

    The hubris.All things Archaix at www.archaix.com
    Jun 21
    FREEDOMROX posted a video
    Jun 21
    Burbia commented on tjdavis's blog post Track AIPAC
    Jun 20
    rlionhearted_3 commented on Doc Vega's blog post Latest Details on Missile Exchanges Between Iran and Israel
    "May get really ugly over there?"
    Jun 20
    Doc Vega posted a blog post

    Latest Details on Missile Exchanges Between Iran and Israel

    Latest information about the air attacks between Israel and Iran as the US moves another carrier…See More
    Jun 19
    tjdavis favorited Less Prone's video
    Jun 19

    © 2025   Created by truth.   Powered by

    Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

    content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted