It's Your Data, It's Your Bot: It's Not A Crime



Deeplink
by Jennifer
Granick


Can public websites decide who is and is not a criminal through their terms of service? A brief EFF filed yesterday argues no.

The amicus brief is a follow-up to one we filed last month in Facebook v. Power Ventures. Facebook claims that Power breaks California
criminal law by offering users a tool that aggregates their own
information across several social networking sites. For some, it may be a
useful way to access various social network information through one
interface. The tool also makes it easier for users to export their data
out of Facebook. In its suit against Power Ventures, Facebook claims
that the tool violates criminal law because Facebook's terms of service
ban users from accessing their information through "automated means."

This is not an esoteric business issue, because the legal theories Facebook is pushing forward would make it a crime not to comply with terms of service. People have already faced criminal charges for
violating a site's terms of use policy. For example, in United States v.
Lori Drew
, a woman was charged with violating the federal
computer crime law for creating a false profile that was used to
communicate inappropriately with a teenager who eventually committed
suicide. EFF filed an amicus
brief
in that case arguing that terms of service do not define
criminal behavior, and the charges were eventually dismissed. We also
defended Boston College computer science student Riccardo
Calixte
, whose computers, cellphone and iPod were seized by local
police who claimed that he violated criminal law by giving a fake name
on his Yahoo account profile. A justice of the Massachusetts Supreme
Judicial Court ordered
police to return the property after finding there was no probable cause
to search the room in the first place.

Using criminal law to enforce private website operators' terms of use puts immense coercive power behind measures that may be contrary to the interests of consumers and the public. EFF believes that users have the
right to choose how they access their own data, and that services like
Power's give users more options. So long as the add-on service does not
access off-limits information and is not harmful to server
functionality, authorized users who choose add-on technologies like
Power’s commit no crime. Frighteningly, under Facebook's theory,
millions of Californians who disregard or don't read terms of service on
the websites they visit would risk criminal liability.

Another wrinkle in the case is Facebook's attempt to interfere with uses of the Power service through IP address blocking. In response to the block, Power simply changed its IP address so it could continue to
provide its service. The IP address blocking used by Facebook was a
crude attempt to control the means by which authorized users could
access the website; it was not aimed at distinguishing between
authorized and unauthorized users. Yet, remarkably, Facebook claims that
Power's IP address change is also a violation of the law. Indeed,
Facebook's claimed prohibition against "automated means" of access is so
broad that it could be read to prevent any automatic process for
presenting your credentials -- even the "remember my password" functions
in web browsers.

As social networking increases in popularity, it's important that users are able to preserve their rights when using these services, including the right to choose competitive services and to take their
information and leave. That's why we've developed a Bill
of Rights for Social Nework
users. Users deserve to maintain
control of their information without facing criminal threats.


Related Issues: Coders' Rights Project, Innovation, Social Networks


Related Cases: US v. Drew


[Permalink]

Views: 44

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

"Destroying the New World Order"

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

Latest Activity

Doc Vega commented on Burbia's video
Thumbnail

InfoWars reporter Jamie White ‘brutally murdered’ near Austin residential area, outlet says

"We're supposed to be conditioned to accept this kind of shit! That the government will have…"
17 hours ago
Doc Vega posted blog posts
19 hours ago
Doc Vega commented on Doc Vega's blog post Disturbing Aspect of the Patterson Gimlin Film
"Thanks for your support Les Prone!"
20 hours ago
Doc Vega commented on Doc Vega's blog post What Would Have Happened to the US Had Harris Been Elected?
"Les Prone-no shit Dude absolutely frightening! "
20 hours ago
Burbia commented on Burbia's video
Thumbnail

InfoWars reporter Jamie White ‘brutally murdered’ near Austin residential area, outlet says

"Yeah, when his company was being auctioned off, why wasn't the starting bid 100 million?"
22 hours ago
tjdavis's blog post was featured
23 hours ago
Doc Vega's 5 blog posts were featured
23 hours ago
cheeki kea's blog post was featured
23 hours ago
Less Prone commented on Doc Vega's blog post What Would Have Happened to the US Had Harris Been Elected?
"It's too terrible to even contemplate. Kamala the president of the USA."
23 hours ago
GeneralCarlosQ17's blog post was featured

Reuters was paid millions of dollars by the US government for “large scale social deception”

Reuters was paid millions of dollars by the US government for “large scale social deception”. That…See More
23 hours ago
Burbia's blog post was featured
23 hours ago
Less Prone commented on tjdavis's blog post The Strobe Method
"Sound like another CIA project."
23 hours ago
Less Prone favorited rlionhearted_3's photo
yesterday
Less Prone commented on rlionhearted_3's photo
Thumbnail

On the beach in Ireland!!!

"It kind of makes sense, on the beach. Maximizing the sun tan surface area. But is it worth it?"
yesterday
Less Prone favorited Doc Vega's blog post Disturbing Aspect of the Patterson Gimlin Film
yesterday
cheeki kea commented on tjdavis's video
Thumbnail

Route 91: Uncovering the Cover Up

"Video not always showing on you tube according to comment section. I can't see it anyways but…"
yesterday
tjdavis posted a blog post
Sunday
Doc Vega favorited Burbia's video
Sunday
Doc Vega commented on Burbia's video
Thumbnail

InfoWars reporter Jamie White ‘brutally murdered’ near Austin residential area, outlet says

"Gosh do you think the Deep State was sending Alex a message? These bastards!"
Sunday
Doc Vega commented on tjdavis's video
Thumbnail

Route 91: Uncovering the Cover Up

"The lying bastards never covered one aspect of the shooter who was in bad health and couldn't…"
Sunday

© 2025   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted