Stats - It’s worse than we thought

Data fudging, infilling, use the actual count, some historical 2013 data, splice in some numbers from admin sources, impute a few more data sets and we will have an answer for you shortly. It may be right, it may be wrong. We really have no idea.Quote.

Government Statistician Liz MacPherson is facing contempt of Parliament after being ordered by MPs to produce census information

n an unusual move, a select committee invoked a standing order compelling Statistics NZ chief executive to produce the number of partial responses were [sic] received in Census 2018.

MacPherson was first asked by [sic] to provide the answer by the governance and administration select committee during its annual review in February, and again on Wednesday. Both times she declined.

The chief statistician now says she will provide the information – which could further reveal the extent of Census 2018 issues – not on the given April 10 deadline but as part of an announcement promised later in the month

Stats NZ has remained tight-lipped about its efforts to patch up the long overdue Census 2018 results, which failed to count one in ten New Zealanders.

National state services spokesman Dr Nick Smith said the committee unanimously decided such an extraordinary measure was required after MacPherson again refused to answer on the basis it would require “extensive contextual information”.

“It is the first time ever that I have seen a select committee having to use its powers to require a public servant to provide an answer to a basic question

I can only draw the conclusion that Stats NZ has something to hide.”

Smith said the partial response rate was pivotal for understanding how the [sic] reliable the census data would be, and the refusal to respond meant MacPherson had side-stepped accountability during the department’s annual review.

If the information was not provided by April 10, he would make a complaint to refer MacPherson to the privileges committee for contempt of Parliament. A person can be in contempt of Parliament for obstructing and impeding its work, or for refusing to answer a question.

“If the chief statistician does not comply with a unanimous select committee to provide a simple answer by next Wednesday she’s effectively giving the fingers to Parliament.”

MacPherson was unavailable for an interview on Friday but in a statement, remained firm that it was not the appropriate time to release the number of partial responses to Census 2018.

“It is my hope that the committee will appreciate that I have made this determination after careful thought and application of statistical best practice.”

“Without the appropriate context, these individual numbers would be open to misinterpretation,” MacPherson said.

She said the number of full and partial responses would now be provided in an announcement later this month, when Stats NZ would also detail when the first census results would be released.

“This is simply a question of timing … When we produce information for the public we outline the methodology and limitations of any data produced,” MacPherson said.

University of Otago professor Andrew Geddis said it was “very unusual” for such an order to be placed on state sector chief executive

“I can’t remember a time a public servant has refused after being told they must answer.”

If a complaint was taken to the speaker or the House, Macpherson could be forced to apologise or be censured by the privileges committee.

“That would be a very major escalation. I would expect that the House treat it as contempt.”[…] End quote.


Views: 89


You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Chris of the family Masters on April 13, 2019 at 3:25pm

I'm not participating. I withdrew my consent.

Comment by cheeki kea on April 13, 2019 at 3:16pm

 Worst than stocktake, It's a it's a comprehensive human inventory analysis of facts "consented" to by the assets, with the added benefit of an Actual Head Count. A most vital tool for our GDP rating. Measurable, and functional assessment data Is needed for The Human Capital Component of our wealth. - which is now based on happiness, and things aren't going as planned. They're pretending we're all happy hobbits, but it's not known how many of us there are to be. No known value and treasury handing out "happy pills" - for mental wellbeing. True, because the Assets need to be viable ones. Glad I scarped off from that paperwork. 

Comment by Chris of the family Masters on April 12, 2019 at 2:09pm
Secretive stock take?

"Destroying the New World Order"


mobile page

12160 Administrators



Latest Activity

Less Prone favorited Central Scrutinizer's photo
2 hours ago
Mr. Sizzle posted a photo
2 hours ago
Mr. Sizzle commented on Central Scrutinizer's photo

Its a Madhouse!!

"I improved on a few things,"
2 hours ago
Mr. Sizzle favorited Central Scrutinizer's photo
2 hours ago
MAC posted discussions
5 hours ago
Amaterasu Solar posted a discussion

Would You Be Happier? - Censored Off YouToilet (9 minutes)

A video I posted to YouToilet was removed for "medical misinformation."  Pretty funny, that!  It…See More
6 hours ago
Patrick C Conway commented on Twilight Zone's photo

Ya Think?

"Wow!  Comes the dawn?"
7 hours ago
Twilight Zone posted discussions
8 hours ago
Larry Flinchpaugh posted blog posts
8 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters posted blog posts
10 hours ago
Twilight Zone replied to Twilight Zone's discussion Border Security Director in Biden's White House Will Come from the UN
"This is Barry's reign 2.0.  All of Joey's cabinet are from Barry's group or UN…"
11 hours ago
MAC replied to Twilight Zone's discussion Border Security Director in Biden's White House Will Come from the UN
"During the Darkfag aka Obama administration if I'm not mistaking, the u.S. population went…"
11 hours ago
Guardian of Scotland commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post Joe Biden Issued 0 Executive Orders
"The Federal Register now indidates that there are Executive Orders sent by Biden.  This even…"
11 hours ago
Twilight Zone favorited MAC's discussion Hard-left Biden’s first days aimed at destroying America First
12 hours ago
rlionhearted_3 posted a status
"Glenn Kessler’s WaPoo factchecker Facebook account is allowing raw pictures and videos to be uploaded. Visit and share! Drive them nuts"
14 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer's photo was featured
14 hours ago
Bob Renner's photo was featured
14 hours ago
Twilight Zone posted photos
14 hours ago
Aaron posted videos
14 hours ago
Aaron posted blog posts
14 hours ago

© 2021   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted