Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court supports Northampton on parking ticket appeal process

MA city charges $320 fee to fight $15 parking ticket, supreme court rules in favor of the city when a person sues that the $320 fee inhibits his right to contest the ticket



The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Thursday handed down a ruling affirming the validity of Northampton’s appeal system for parking tickets despite a Greenfield man’s contention that the cost of the appeal effectively negated his constitutional rights.

 


Vincent Gillespie said the $319.90 cost of appealing his July 19, 2005, parking ticket in Hampshire Superior Court far exceeded the $15 fine. Gillespie, a former Easthampton resident, received two citations that day for parking in a prohibited zone in Northampton, the second as he was walking to the parking office to contest the first. He subsequently filed a written challenge that was denied, although the second citation was dismissed as duplicative of the first.


Because Northampton’s system did not include the option of appearing before a hearing officer, as it does now, Gillespie filed for summary judgment in Hampshire Superior Court, saying he was denied his rights. Judge Bertha D. Josephson found in his favor, but ruled in the city’s favor on Gillespie’s Constitutional argument that the fee system effectively denied him access to the courts.


Edward Hamel, who was issued a $100 citation for parking in a handicapped space in 2005, joined Gillespie as a plaintiff in the case, which was argued before the Supreme Judicial Court by American Civil Liberties lawyer William C. Newman of Northampton. The city did not have a lawyer at the hearing, with the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office representing its position instead.


NEWMAN_3135626.JPGWilliam Newman

Although the court did not address matters such as the high amount of the filing fees, it ruled in favor of Northampton, saying that the plaintiffs did not meet their burden of proving that the laws establishing the appeal process for traffic tickets were not in keeping with the state constitution. Furthermore, the court wrote, the fee system serves the purpose of discouraging “the filing of nonmeritorious appeals” by conserving scarce judicial resources.


Newman argued, however, that those same resources could be further conserved by hearing parking ticket appeals in small claims court or district court. He also noted, as did the court in its ruling, that the cost of appeal of tickets in Massachusetts far exceeds that in other states such as California ($25) and Connecticut ($35).


“The Massachusetts system is an aberration,” Newman said Thursday.


The court said it is up to the Legislature to set those costs.


“Our lens focuses only on the constitutional question,” the justices wrote.


Mayor Mary Clare Higgins said Thursday that the legal battle was more a matter of state concern, but concurred with the court’s opinion.


“I think the ruling was correct,” she said.

Views: 108

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Denis Sac on July 16, 2011 at 10:50am
ALLow smoking dope,Drinking Alcohol and BAN SMOKING...OH MY GOD
Comment by Denis Sac on July 16, 2011 at 10:49am
Who would go to that DUMP STATE,Its Just like the rest of the  GREEDY USA

"Destroying the New World Order"

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

Latest Activity

Michelle Reichert favorited Burbia's video
12 hours ago
cheeki kea posted a video

NEW DOCUMENTARY - Dissent Into Madness

TRANSCRIPT AND SOURCES: https://www.corbettreport.com/dissent-into-madness/What if the delusions of the dissidents are in fact real? What if their paranoid f...
18 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on Doc Vega's blog post Alligator Creek and a Japanese Massacre
"Japan served themselves up no favours by inching out into the South Pacific as they soon found out.…"
18 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on Doc Vega's blog post Was a Planned Civil War Averted?
"Their plans did not work out because we are the news now, and the old news is the enemy. "
19 hours ago
Doc Vega posted a blog post

Alligator Creek and a Japanese Massacre

The year is 1942 just a few months after the Pearl Harbor disaster. Despite losses suffered by the…See More
yesterday
Doc Vega commented on Burbia's video
Thumbnail

CHARLIE KIRK WAS CNP! JOSH REEVES 9-11-25

"With all due respect this guy comes off as a drunken asshole and he didn't even  know who…"
Monday
Doc Vega posted a blog post

Was a Planned Civil War Averted?

We are living in sadly historic times where good and evil are in battle all the time. Not that this…See More
Sunday
Sandy posted a photo
Sunday
Less Prone posted a video

President Trump addresses U.N. General Assembly - FULL SPEECH

President Donald Trump speaks at the United Nations General Assembly in New York City.Full video here: https://www.c-span.org/event/white-house-event/preside...
Sunday
Burbia posted a video

2 MIN AGO: Western Provinces MAJOR New WEXIT Announcement - Canada EXPLODES!

In a stunning turn of events, Western provinces just made a major new WEXIT announcement — and it’s shaking the foundations of Canadian unity. Is Western sep...
Saturday
Doc Vega posted a blog post

How You Provoke a Civil War

In the world of counter intelligence which is simply one aspect of many pertaining to asymmetrical…See More
Friday
Burbia commented on Burbia's video
Thumbnail

CHARLIE KIRK WAS CNP! JOSH REEVES 9-11-25

"I don't follow as much with Josh Reeves than I use to. He seems to be a documentary producing…"
Sep 25
Burbia posted a video

CHARLIE KIRK WAS CNP! JOSH REEVES 9-11-25

DONATE-paypal-dayglow76@yahoo.comCashapp-reevesradioVenmo-Josh-Reeves-61FILMS AND AUDIOBOOKS DOWNLOAD STORE-https://store.payloadz.com/results/242828-josh-re...
Sep 25
Doc Vega posted blog posts
Sep 25
tjdavis posted a video

CHARLIE KIRK VIDEO THAT KEEPS GETTING REMOVED OFF OF SEVERAL PLATFORMS

I had not planned to share this publicly, but I believe Advar, who spoke with Charlie Kirk while I was very ill, would have wanted me to. After my interview ...
Sep 25
pohonemas33 team commented on Chris of the family Masters's photo
Thumbnail

Gold-Coast-Message

"untuk bermain slot, kamu cukup kunjungi situs kacang99 pasti langsung gacor"
Sep 24
Doc Vega posted blog posts
Sep 24
Burbia posted a blog post

Former President Trump?

When was this article written? It is attributed to Victor Davis Hanson. He is a Fellow at Hoover…See More
Sep 22
Doc Vega posted a blog post

Don’t Go Hunting For Bigfoot

It is October 19, 2019 at 5:46 AM. This will be the last time any visual evidence of Mark is seen…See More
Sep 22
tjdavis posted a video

Most Corrupt Series: Elizabeth Warren | Forgotten History

Elizabeth Warren has built her reputation as a "reformer", but her political career has also drawn sharp criticism. Questions have been raised about her fina...
Sep 19

© 2025   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted