Mike's Minute: Govt's wellbeing budget a looming disaster

https://www.newstalkzb.co.nz/on-air/mike-hosking-breakfast/video/mi...

So as part of the Prime Minister's ongoing dream of living in a land of lollipops, landholding and general kumbaya, we have the mechanism used by the Treasury to put a monetary value on everything, despite the common-sense fact you can't put a monetary value on everything.

That's why they have sayings like "money can't buy experience", or that was "priceless". According to the Treasury, none of that's possible

This is, of course, for the so-called "wellbeing budget"

It is an idealist's fantasy, it's the workings of hand wringers who need to be consoled by the concept that as a result of any given action someone bursts into a smile, or song, or both

But to do that, given you are actually handing out money, and money is real, and the outcome might not be tangible,you need to make the intangible tangible

And that's what the spreadsheet does. It doesn't need to be a spreadsheet, it could have been a dartboard. What's a life worth? Double 20? What's making a friend worth? Triple 12? That's how stupid it is

They've valued a life at $4.7 million. Now the key to this is that you're dealing with about 4.7 million lives, that's roughly the population of the country. So you can immediately see if you get the number wrong to start with, it very quickly gets hopelessly and expensively out of control. Say a life was $4.6m, not $4.7m. That's $100,000 a person times 4.7m, and that's a lot of money.

And that's before, of course, you get to the simple reality that a life isn't worth $4.7m, it's worth whatever you want it to be

And even if we agreed this was a sensible way to measure anything, the $4.7m would merely be an average. I would value my life well beyond $4.7m, and averages aren't individual and because they're not individual, they don't directly affect you and I the way it should. It's like the mad debate around the gender pay gap, it's all done on averages. And averages don't reflect your individual set of circumstances, your reality, your wellbeing

If you value your life at $27m, then you're missing out. And that's before you get to the argument as to why the Government's estimate of your life is more valuable than yours, and who knows your life better than you?

Views: 18

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Latest Activity

Chris of the family Masters commented on Sweettina2's video
Thumbnail

Everything you need to know about the plan...

"Not sure about 'cosmic justice', all I know there is no law in US."
6 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters favorited Sweettina2's video
10 minutes ago
Diana posted photos
15 minutes ago
Diana commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post “JEW MOTHERFUCKER” AND “NIGGER” The Foulmouthed & Lying Clintons
"But I heard HRC has the calm, steady demeanor this country needs.  "
16 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters posted a blog post

“JEW MOTHERFUCKER” AND “NIGGER” The Foulmouthed & Lying Clintons

by Reinhold Aman, Ph.D.Millions of cretinous and amoral Americans still admire Bill and Hillary Clinton, the two foulest amoral slimebags that have ever besmirched the White House. These two foulmouthed and lying psychopaths have been, and still…See More
48 minutes ago
James Roberts posted a blog post
1 hour ago
Maasanova favorited Diana's photo
1 hour ago
Anti Everything commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post Anatomy of a Birth Certificate - What It Means
"I've been giving attention to this ladies website for about 10 yrs. I am missing one thing - How to break loose, completely, with absolute sovereignty giving me freedom of my own design. I call this 'anarchy'. However, the…"
1 hour ago
Diana commented on Maasanova's video
2 hours ago
James Roberts favorited Diana's photo
2 hours ago
James Roberts favorited Diana's photo
2 hours ago
James Roberts favorited Raz Putin's discussion Breaking: RT:"Mueller probe did not find that Trump campaign conspired with Russia"
2 hours ago
James Roberts commented on Raz Putin's blog post Les Gilets Jaune-Yellow Vest Protest Act 19-Live streaming feeds
"Now that Macron has brought in the military, the Yellow Vests need to progress to IEDs."
2 hours ago
James Roberts favorited Raz Putin's blog post Les Gilets Jaune-Yellow Vest Protest Act 19-Live streaming feeds
2 hours ago
James Roberts favorited Diana's photo
2 hours ago
James Roberts commented on James T. Kirk's photo
Thumbnail

Mouse Trap

"Hey! Meeces have been some of my best friends!"
2 hours ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted