Psychiatry's civil war - open conflict has broken out among the upper echelons of US psychiatry.
http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20427381.300-psychiatrys-civi...
When doctors disagree with each other, they usually couch their criticisms in careful, measured language. In the past few months, however, open conflict has broken out among the upper echelons of US psychiatry. The focus of discord is a volume called the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, or DSM, which psychiatrists turn to when diagnosing the distressed individuals who turn up at their offices seeking help. Regularly referred to as the profession's bible, the DSM is in the midst of a major rewrite, and feelings are running high.
Two eminent retired psychiatrists are warning that the revision process is fatally flawed. They say the new manual, to be known as DSM-V, will extend definitions of mental illnesses so broadly that tens of millions of people will be given unnecessary and risky drugs. Leaders of the American Psychiatric Association (APA), which publishes the manual, have shot back, accusing the pair of being motivated by their own financial interests - a charge they deny. The row is set to come to a head next month when the proposed changes will be published online. For a profession that exists to soothe human troubles, it's incendiary stuff.
First published in 1952, the DSM has its origins in a book used by the US military to determine if recruits were mentally fit for combat. The difficulty of separating mental disorders from normal variation in behaviour made it controversial from the start. Over the years, the book's influence has grown, and today it is used by doctors across the globe.
http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20427381.300-psychiatrys-civi...
When doctors disagree with each other, they usually couch their criticisms in careful, measured language. In the past few months, however, open conflict has broken out among the upper echelons of US psychiatry. The focus of discord is a volume called the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, or DSM, which psychiatrists turn to when diagnosing the distressed individuals who turn up at their offices seeking help. Regularly referred to as the profession's bible, the DSM is in the midst of a major rewrite, and feelings are running high.
Two eminent retired psychiatrists are warning that the revision process is fatally flawed. They say the new manual, to be known as DSM-V, will extend definitions of mental illnesses so broadly that tens of millions of people will be given unnecessary and risky drugs. Leaders of the American Psychiatric Association (APA), which publishes the manual, have shot back, accusing the pair of being motivated by their own financial interests - a charge they deny. The row is set to come to a head next month when the proposed changes will be published online. For a profession that exists to soothe human troubles, it's incendiary stuff.
First published in 1952, the DSM has its origins in a book used by the US military to determine if recruits were mentally fit for combat. The difficulty of separating mental disorders from normal variation in behaviour made it controversial from the start. Over the years, the book's influence has grown, and today it is used by doctors across the globe.
http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20427381.300-psychiatrys-civi...
Comment
-
Comment by Jeff on December 18, 2009 at 10:18pm
-
Comment by Marklar on December 16, 2009 at 5:53am
A vague but useful pseudoscience at it's best, an utter nightmare at it's worst.
That about says it. Succinct and to the point.
I'm very typically far more wordy. Psychiatry is based on opinion while medicine is based on science. There are no medical diagnostic tests for ANY psychiatric diseases and this includes Schizophrenia and other such so-called diseases. There are no blood tests, no brain imaging devices, no neurological tests to prove any of these diseases exist. None.
ALL of Psychiatry is based on opinion.
If I were a Psychiatrist and my opinion were that global warming was caused by man, would I be right?
-
Comment by Ron Cesek on December 18, 2009 at 3:21pm
-
" . . free and unnecessary drugs."
Like Fluoride Water for Baby Formula ?
-
Comment by Anti Oligarch on December 18, 2009 at 2:24am
-
Let's hope this escalates to a full out war between them.
-
Comment by Marklar on December 16, 2009 at 5:53am
-
A vague but useful pseudoscience at it's best, an utter nightmare at it's worst.
"Destroying the New World Order"
THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!
Latest Activity
- Top News
- Everything
"cheeki kea Marjory is in a daily battle with Democrats on the hill constantly coming up with more…"
The Saga of Joe Adams May Have Solved What's Behind the Numerous Disappearances Going on in our National Forests
The year is 2023 in September. A nature’s photographer and experienced survivalist, Joe Adams…See More
Aron Siri's opening statement, Senate Hearing on Covid Vaccines, May 25
Opening statement Aaron Siri, Managing Partner, Siri & Glimstad, L.L.P.Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, Permanent Subcommittee on Investiga...
"A smidgeon of facts have come to light. In English a misspelling suddenly occurred where an extra R…"
The Cancel Culture Vulture
Better to shut them down than hear their point of viewCancel culture coming after youHelping to…See More
The Fingerprint
The Fingerprint On a dance with the unpredictability of the signals you sendA solemn pact with my…See More
The Roots of Freemasonry (royales, ancient bloodlines, & end times chronology) w/Gary Wayne
👕 Merch from "The Deep End": https://www.livenotdie.com/thedeep-end🎧 Taylor's DAILY mindset podcast: https://open.spotify.com/show/1SW0ofWSXsmJZDnqKYTpRG?s...
"Bullets can be effective in reinforcing ownership."
Trump Receives Marching Orders
Netanyahu has made 3 visits to the White house since Trump's second term as President of the United…See More
Ben Shapiro Just LOST HIS MIND — There's No Coming Back From This
"Omg. The Ben Shapiro voice that Luke is imitating here couldn't be any more comedic to…"
© 2025 Created by truth.
Powered by
You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!
Join 12160 Social Network