Congress may sneak through internet 'kill switch' in defense bill

Congress may sneak through Internet ‘kill switch’ in defense bill
Published on 08-29-2010 Email To Friend Print Version


Source: RawStory

A federal cybersecurity bill that critics say creates a presidential "kill switch" for the Internet could be added on to a defense spending bill and passed without much debate, technology news sources report.

Sen. Thomas Carper (D-DE), one of the sponsors of the Protecting Cyberspace as a National Asset Act, told GovInfoSecurity.com that the Senate is considering attaching the bill as a rider to a defense authorization bill likely to pass through Congress before the
mid-term elections.

"It's hard to get a measure like cybersecurity legislation passed on its own," Carper said.

Carper, along with Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-CT) and Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME), introduced the bill in June in an effort to combat cyber-crime and the threat of online warfare and terrorism. Critics say the bill would allow the president to
disconnect Internet networks and force private websites to comply with
broad cybersecurity measures. Future US presidents would have those
powers renewed indefinitely.

The bill (PDF) states that Internet service providers, search engines and other Internet-related businesses "shall immediately comply with any
emergency measure or action developed" by the Department of Homeland
Security.

But many observers point out that that doesn't necessarily amount to a "kill switch" -- and, in fact, the president already has the power to shut off the Internet. As Time magazine points out,
the Communications Act of 1934 grants the president the power to shut
down wire communications during a time of war, and the Internet is now
recognized as a wire communication medium.

Yet the proposed law authorizes the president to declare "cyber emergencies" -- potentially expanding the president's power to shut down the Internet to times when the US is not technically at war.

And even some backers of the proposed legislation argue the bill is too broad and vague, and the powers granted to the executive branch could be unpredictable as a result.

A summary (DOC) of the bill issued by Sen. Lieberman's office describes the powers granted to the president:

The Act will provide a responsible framework, developed in coordination with the private sector, for the President to authorize emergency measures, limited in both scope and duration, to protect the
nation’s most critical infrastructure if a cyber vulnerability is being
exploited or is about to be exploited. The President must notify
Congress in advance about the threat and the emergency measures that
will be taken to mitigate it. Any emergency measures imposed must be
the least disruptive necessary to respond to the threat. These
emergency measures will expire after 30 days unless the President
orders an extension. The bill does not authorize any new surveillance
authorities, or permit the government to “take over” private networks.

The bill "authorizes the president to declare 'cyber emergencies,' without spelling out what would happen next," states an editorial at the Scranton Times-Tribune. "It is certain that the Internet will be a prime means of communication during an emergency. Given the history of the government
over-stepping even constitutional constraints during such times, the
bill's sponsors should retool it to be more specific."

Security expert and Cryptography Research CEO Paul Kocher describes the bill as a "Rorschach blot -- on one level it's absurd, and on others it's impractical and frightening."

Kocher said, "When you build something that will shut down a massively critical piece of infrastructure that people have tried to make reliable, that's a more frightening prospect than anything that
could have inspired such a defense ... It's a very blunt weapon."

GovInfoSecurity notes that the House of Representatives passed a version of the defense authorization bill last spring that included cyber-security measures. If the Senate follows suit, a final version of
the cyber-security legislation would be worked out in conference
committee.

.

Views: 31

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Sweettina2 on August 30, 2010 at 5:20pm
Heheheee, me too PH! They can kill the internet, they can kill anything they want...but they cant kill the spirit and soul of the patriots!

"Destroying the New World Order"

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

Latest Activity

Guardian of Scotland commented on stormtruther's video
Thumbnail

Film your hospitals Dayton, Ohio COVID HOAX

"I think that the man that went to these hospitals in Dayton went about it in the wrong way. He was…"
59 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer favorited James Roberts's blog post "Coronavirus" - My Theory (Rapid-Onset Autoimmune Disease)
1 hour ago
cheeki kea commented on James Roberts's blog post "Coronavirus" - My Theory (Rapid-Onset Autoimmune Disease)
"The blood is in a sterile Environment, but it could become septic. Blood only contains antibodies…"
4 hours ago
James Roberts favorited Burbia's photo
4 hours ago
James Roberts replied to Keisha Ruan's discussion No Covid-19 Overwhelming Here Yet.
"I think it was Alibaba I was looking on, plenty of sellers of hydroxychloroquine there."
4 hours ago
James Roberts favorited MAC's discussion The People Must Be Shown First, They Must Understand, Then The Arrests
4 hours ago
James Roberts commented on Mr. Sizzle's blog post Something to ponder and enjoy rather than the fear porn of Covid 19
"Right. I don't doubt it. The screaming girl fans were paid, that's a fact. The Monkees…"
4 hours ago
James Roberts commented on Keisha Ruan's blog post Work Force Giving us Notices on Martial Law
"Fixed it for you. Thanks for posting."
4 hours ago
James Roberts favorited Chris of the family Masters's blog post Go Ahead and Line Up to Take the Death Shot!!! - 'PUBLIC NOTICE' (comments by Mr.Ed & Video)
5 hours ago
James Roberts favorited cheeki kea's photo
5 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on James T. Kirk's video
5 hours ago
JoeG favorited stormtruther's video
6 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on stormtruther's video
Thumbnail

Film your hospitals Dayton, Ohio COVID HOAX

"The sick and the dead won't turn up until they get the covid vaccination First. Then, as a…"
6 hours ago
cheeki kea favorited stormtruther's video
6 hours ago
James Roberts commented on stormtruther's video
Thumbnail

Film your hospitals Dayton, Ohio COVID HOAX

"And Trump and the Democrats are in on it."
6 hours ago
James Roberts commented on stormtruther's video
Thumbnail

Film your hospitals Dayton, Ohio COVID HOAX

"Thanks, stormy. That's 30 miles north of me. This is just a big power and money grab by Jewish…"
6 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on cheeki kea's photo
Thumbnail

NOT J. Ardern, and no relation !

"Mel, you poor, poor, lady. My heart goes out to you. And thank god you've got normal teeth or…"
7 hours ago
cheeki kea posted a photo
7 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post Go Ahead and Line Up to Take the Death Shot!!! - 'PUBLIC NOTICE' (comments by Mr.Ed & Video)
"Yes cheeki, you have got it right. These days all Functional Medicine practitioners are very active…"
7 hours ago
MAC posted a discussion
7 hours ago

© 2020   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted