Guilty of Being Poor - the illegal return of the debtors prison.

by Eric Ruder / April 23rd, 2009


The jailers of the 19th century — even in the pre-Civil War South — largely abandoned the practice of imprisoning people for falling into debt as counterproductive and ultimately barbaric. In the 1970s and ’80s, the U.S. Supreme Court affirmed that incarcerating people who can’t pay fines because of poverty violates the U.S. Constitution.

Apparently, though, some states and county jails never got the memo. Welcome to the debtors’ prisons of the 21st century.

“Edwina Nowlin, a poor Michigan resident, was ordered to reimburse a juvenile detention center $104 a month for holding her 16-year-old son,” the New York Times wrote in an editorial.

“When she explained to the court that she could not afford to pay, Ms. Nowlin was sent to prison. The American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan, which helped get her out last week after she spent 28 days behind bars, says it is seeing more people being sent to jail because they cannot make various court-ordered payments. That is both barbaric and unconstitutional.”

The details of Nowlin’s case are even more alarming than the Times editorial suggests. Not only was Nowlin under orders to pay a fine stemming from someone else’s actions, but she had been laid off from work and lost her home at the time she was ordered to “reimburse” the county for her son’s detention.

Despite her inability to pay, she was held in contempt of court and ordered to serve a 30-day sentence. On March 6, three days after she was incarcerated, she was released for one day to work. She also picked up her paycheck, in the amount of $178.53. This, she thought, could be used to pay the $104, and she would be released from jail.

But when she got back to the jail, the sheriff told her to sign her check over to the county — to pay $120 for her own room and board, and $22 for a drug test and booking fee.

Even more absurd, Nowlin requested but was denied a court-appointed lawyer. So because she was too poor to afford a lawyer and denied her constitutional right to have the court provide one for her, she couldn’t fight the contempt charge that stemmed from her poverty. And her contempt conviction only added to her poverty, as the fines and fees she was obligated to pay now multiplied.

“Like many people in these desperate economic times, Ms. Nowlin was laid off from work, lost her home and is destitute,” said Michael Steinberg, legal director of the Michigan ACLU. “Jailing her because of her poverty is not only unconstitutional, it’s unconscionable and a shameful waste of resources. It is not a crime to be poor in this country, and the government must stop resurrecting debtor’s prisons from the dustbin of history.”

Michigan isn’t the only place where you can be imprisoned for the crime of involuntary poverty. The same Catch-22 ensnares poor defendants daily in courtrooms across the country.

In 2006, the Southern Center for Human Rights (SCHR) filed a suit on behalf of Ora Lee Hurley, who couldn’t get out of prison until she had enough money to pay a $705 fine. But she couldn’t pay the fine because she had to pay the Georgia Department of Corrections $600 a month for room and board, and spend $76 a month on public transportation, laundry and food.

She was released five days a week to work at the K&K Soul Food restaurant, where she earned $6.50 an hour, which netted her about $700 a month after taxes. Hurley was trapped in prison for eight months beyond her initial 120-day sentence until the Southern Center intervened. Over the course of her incarceration, she earned about $7,000, but she never had enough at one time to pay off her $705 fine.

“This is a situation where if this woman was able to write a check for the amount of the fine, she would be out of there,” Sarah Geraghty, a SCHR lawyer, told the Atlanta Journal Constitution while Hurley was still imprisoned. “And because she can’t, she’s still in custody. It’s as simple as that.”

Georgia also lets for-profit probation companies prey on people too poor to pay their traffic violations and court fees. According to a 2008 SCHR report entitled “Profiting from the poor”:

In courts around Georgia, people who are charged with misdemeanors and cannot pay their fines that day in court are placed on probation under the supervision of private, for-profit companies until they pay off their fines. On probation, they must pay these companies substantial monthly “supervision fees” that may double or triple the amount that a person of means would pay for the same offense.

For example, a person of means may pay $200 for a traffic ticket on the day of court and be done with it, while a person too poor to pay that day is placed on probation and ends up paying $500 or more for the same offense.

The privatization of misdemeanor probation has placed unprecedented law enforcement authority in the hands of for-profit companies that act essentially as collection agencies. These companies, focused on profit rather than public safety or rehabilitation, are not designed to supervise people or connect them to services and jobs. Rather, they charge exorbitant monthly fees and use the threat of imprisonment and a variety of bullying tactics to squeeze money out of the men and women under their supervision.

For too many poor people convicted of misdemeanors, our state is not living up to the constitutional promise of equal justice under law.

In Gulfport, Miss., the municipal court started a “fine collection task force” to crack down on people who owed fees for misdemeanors. According to the SCHR Web site:

The task force trolled through predominantly African American neighborhoods, rounding up people who had outstanding court fines. After arresting and jailing them, the City of Gulfport processed these people through a court proceeding at which no defense attorney was present or even offered.

Many people were jailed for months after hearings lasting just seconds. While the city collected money, it also packed the jail with hundreds of people who couldn’t pay, including people who were sick, physically disabled and/or limited by mental disabilities.

The disregard of the justice system for the rights of poor people to equal protection and due process is cause for outrage. But it shouldn’t come as a surprise in an era when the government spends billions bailing out banks while letting foreclosures and unemployment ruin the lives of working people.

We need to build a movement, like the working-class struggles of the 1930s, that can demand an end to the inhuman practice of incarcerating people for no other crime than finding themselves at the bottom of the social ladder.

Views: 400

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by WTRH-AM-AE on April 24, 2009 at 4:26pm
This world is always catering to the rich folks not the poor. It's easy for the poor to stay in jail and the rich get out of jail early.
Comment by Jeff on April 24, 2009 at 12:40am
Pretty sick society we live in, huh...
Comment by truth on April 23, 2009 at 9:46pm
Mark I just posted this related article. Just nuts! Now we will be judged by how we spend our money?

Like cable TV? You better pay your fines - New collections court in Florida

Judge can ask what the debtor spends money on — such as cable TV or cigarettes — and require him (or her) to end frivolous spending until the court fees and fines are paid, 12th Circuit Chief Judge Lee Haworth told HeraldTribune.

http://adap2k.blogspot.com/2009/04/new-collections-court-unpaid-fin...

"Destroying the New World Order"

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

Latest Activity

Chris of the family Masters posted a discussion

Criminal Charges Against OZ Pirates

 Judicial being issued with criminal charges for treason against the nation and to appear in court…See More
3 hours ago
the mighty bull replied to Mrs. Tif Morgan's discussion Newsweek: Taboo Against Eating Human Flesh is ‘Unreasonable’
"in the old days this diet was normal practice but that was a long long time ago maybe 200 years ago…"
4 hours ago
the mighty bull favorited Mrs. Tif Morgan's discussion Newsweek: Taboo Against Eating Human Flesh is ‘Unreasonable’
4 hours ago
Burbia commented on Phyllis Maka's blog post NEW DRONE VIDEO FROM PEDO ISLAND - Jim Stone
5 hours ago
Burbia posted videos
5 hours ago
the mighty bull commented on Chris of the family Masters's blog post The Text
6 hours ago
Phyllis Maka commented on Phyllis Maka's blog post UNBELIEVABLE HOW THEY CLONED THIS DEAD THING BACK TO LIFE/ How These Lying Pricks CHEAT US OUT OF OUR LIVING EARTH like hell they will NOT !!
"Like I said obliterate Washington DC (military) from this earth the rest will fall over, that being…"
10 hours ago
Rufus commented on guest_blog's page BBC: ‘We were wrong to hide commentator’s pro-Israeli credentials during Gaza assault’
"The BBC being less than honest?  What is the world coming to when we can't even trust our…"
10 hours ago
Mrs. Tif Morgan's 2 discussions were featured
10 hours ago
Profile IconRufus and Nigel joined truth's group
10 hours ago
Phyllis Maka's blog post was featured

NEW DRONE VIDEO FROM PEDO ISLAND - Jim Stone

"Rusty Shackleford" is at it again, and just nailed new evidence that strongly supports the…See More
10 hours ago
Mrs. Tif Morgan replied to Mrs. Tif Morgan's discussion Jeffrey Epstein Was Given Three 12 Yr Old Girls to Abuse As A Birthday Gift, Unsealed Court Documents Claim
" Now let me tell you what I know, this here, 卐, was found in Israel, it is over 12000 year…"
10 hours ago
Rufus favorited Central Scrutinizer's group Agnostic & Atheist Patriots
10 hours ago
Rufus posted a status
"Been away for 7 years! I wonder what has changed in here? In the real world, its just more of the same bs!"
10 hours ago
Rufus commented on Phyllis Maka's blog post UNBELIEVABLE HOW THEY CLONED THIS DEAD THING BACK TO LIFE/ How These Lying Pricks CHEAT US OUT OF OUR LIVING EARTH like hell they will NOT !!
"Washington DC, Vatican City, City of London - the whole lot need removing.  There is no point…"
10 hours ago
Phyllis Maka posted blog posts
12 hours ago

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted