Harvard Researchers Want Fat Kids Taken from Their Homes

Harvard Researchers Want Fat Kids Taken from Their Homes

Source

John Hudson 12:10 AM ET 5,065 Views Comments (24)

As the Western world gets fatter and fatter, the solutions to slimming it down get ever more draconian. In Britain yesterday, the government issued guidelines saying "children under the age of 5, including babies who can’t walk yet, should exercise every day." Today, in the States, a pair of Harvard scholars writing in the Journal of the American Medical Association advocate stripping away the custody rights of parents of super obese children. They're for real!

"Despite the discomfort posed by state intervention, it may sometimes be necessary to protect a child," said Lindsey Murtagh, a lawyer and researcher at Harvard's School of Public Health. The study's co-author, David Ludwig, says taking away peoples' children "ideally will support not just the child but the whole family, with the goal of reuniting child and family as soon as possible." Ludwig, an obesity specialist at Harvard-affiliated Children's Hospital, said his eureka moment was when a 90-pound, 3-year-old girl entered his obesity clinic a number of years ago," reports Lindsey Tanner at the Associated Press.

Her parents had physical disabilities, little money and difficulty controlling her weight. Last year, at age 12, she weighed 400 pounds and had developed diabetes, cholesterol problems, high blood pressure and sleep apnea.

"Out of medical concern, the state placed this girl in foster care, where she simply received three balanced meals a day and a snack or two and moderate physical activity," he said. After a year, she lost 130 pounds. Though she is still obese, her diabetes and apnea disappeared; she remains in foster care, he said.

But not so fast! The academic world isn't in agreement. In response to the JAMA article, University of Pennsylvania bioethicist Art Caplan is pushing back in a column for MSNBC. Here are his sticking points:

Legality "Our laws give enormous authority to parents and rightly so," he writes. "The only basis for compelling medical treatment against a parent’s wishes are if a child is at imminent risk of death — meaning days or hours — and a proven cure exists for what threatens to kill them. Obesity does not pass these requirements. The risk of death from obesity is real, but it is way down the road for kids."

Practical issues "The number of kids involved — an estimated 2 million children with body-mass index above the 99th percentile — would quickly swamp already overwhelmed social service departments," he writes. "And, no matter what you do with overweight children, sooner or later they are going back home where their often overweight parents will still be."

It's the wrong focus "Before we start grabbing porky youths out of their homes and sending them off to government fat camps, might we try to change our food culture? This means doing what we have done for smoking. Demonize the companies that sell and market food that is not nutritious. That means you, candy, soda, fried food and snack food outfits. Tax them too."

Want to add to this story? Comments (24) below or send the author of this post, John Hudson, an email. Have a hot tip or story idea? Let us know on the Open Wire.

Views: 38

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Nikki on July 13, 2011 at 5:48pm
What's even scarier is the comments on the source site from many who actually agree with this.

"Destroying the New World Order"

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

Latest Activity

Chris of the family Masters favorited Aaron's video
4 hours ago
Less Prone favorited Hyper Loose's profile
4 hours ago
Hyper Loose's blog post was featured

‘Shove Your New World Order Up Your *ss!’ — London Erupts in Protest Against Lockdown

America take note! It's long past due for ALL to take to the streets and demand our lock-downs be…See More
4 hours ago
Less Prone commented on Hyper Loose's blog post ‘Shove Your New World Order Up Your *ss!’ — London Erupts in Protest Against Lockdown
"Let Londonistan boil over. They probably are already beyond repair in their multicultural illusion…"
4 hours ago
Aaron's video was featured
4 hours ago
Less Prone favorited Aaron's video
4 hours ago
Less Prone commented on Phyllis Maka's blog post MISSING CHILDREN NOT ONLY MADE INTO SHOES BUT NOW HANDBAG?
"All these people claim to be noble in their ideology is the opposite. 1984!"
5 hours ago
Phyllis Maka commented on Phyllis Maka's blog post MISSING CHILDREN NOT ONLY MADE INTO SHOES BUT NOW HANDBAG?
"A lot of these women are being RAPED. Most of these RAPES are committed by those who create those…"
5 hours ago
Phyllis Maka posted blog posts
6 hours ago
steve posted photos
8 hours ago
Patrick Conway commented on Mr. Sizzle's video
Thumbnail

Military Can Openers P-38 & P-51

"P-38s came with every c-rat pack in the day.  We always kept one with us, usually on dog chain…"
8 hours ago
steve replied to steve's discussion These crazy folks want us DEAD
8 hours ago
steve commented on Phyllis Maka's blog post MISSING CHILDREN NOT ONLY MADE INTO SHOES BUT NOW HANDBAG?
"Planned parenthood and TAXPAYERS have MURDERED(aborted is the tidy term)paid for the deaths of…"
9 hours ago
steve posted a discussion

These crazy folks want us DEAD

Here's some raghead teachers instructing  to KILL all non muds(sounds british but could be anywhere…See More
9 hours ago
Phyllis Maka commented on Phyllis Maka's blog post MISSING CHILDREN NOT ONLY MADE INTO SHOES BUT NOW HANDBAG?
"We KNOW They are killing them They're just being who they are and shoving it in our faces.…"
10 hours ago
Larry Flinchpaugh posted a blog post
11 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on Phyllis Maka's blog post MISSING CHILDREN NOT ONLY MADE INTO SHOES BUT NOW HANDBAG?
"Ethically sources would mean robbing the graves..."
11 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters favorited Hyper Loose's blog post ‘Shove Your New World Order Up Your *ss!’ — London Erupts in Protest Against Lockdown
14 hours ago
Aaron posted photos
14 hours ago
Hyper Loose posted a blog post

‘Shove Your New World Order Up Your *ss!’ — London Erupts in Protest Against Lockdown

America take note! It's long past due for ALL to take to the streets and demand our lock-downs be…See More
14 hours ago

© 2020   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted