Environment & Science

Scores of Reactors in Worldwide Quake Zones

Japan, Taiwan Account for Most Sites in High-Activity Areas; 'Large Margins of Safety' Factored In at U.S. Plants


March 19, 2011

 

Nearly 100 nuclear reactors operate in earthquake-prone regions around the world, including at least 34 in high-hazard areas, a Wall Street Journal analysis shows.

Most of those plants are in just two places: Japan and Taiwan, both islands with limited natural resources that have chosen the risks of nuclear calamity over complete dependence on foreign sources of energy.

Threat by Land and Sea

Dozens of nuclear reactors operate in earthquake-prone regions around the world. Among them, least 14 are in high-hazard areas. See a map and database of all of them.

Both are now being forced to re-evaluate that calculation amid Japan's unfolding nuclear crisis. A poll in Taiwan taken March 14—three days after a 9.0 magnitude earthquake off the coast of Japan triggered massive devastation and deadly tsunamis—showed that 55% of respondents lacked confidence in the island's nuclear facilities.

The Wall Street Journal looked at the location of more than 400 nuclear reactors across the world—as well as another 100 that are either planned or being built—using data provided by the World Nuclear Association, a London-based industry group. The Journal then used data from the Global Seismic Hazard Program, a 1999 study by the U.S. Geological Survey and the Swiss Seismological Service, to determine the earthquake risk at each plant.

According to the analysis, 90 of the world's operating nuclear reactors, or 20%, are in areas known to have at least moderate earthquake activity. These include the Fukushima Daiichi reactors at the center of Japan's nuclear crisis. Thirty-four, or 8%, are in areas of high activity. Of those, 17 are located within a mile of a coastline, making them at risk for both earthquakes and tsunamis.

Japan and Taiwan together account for 30 of the 34 high-activity reactors. But the U.S. has two reactors in such areas and Slovenia and Armenia have one each. Armenia has another planned.

The nuclear industry says reactors world-wide are built to withstand the most powerful quakes thought possible at each location, plus usually an added safety factor in case those projections are wrong. The Fukushima Daiichi plant in Japan apparently survived last week's powerful earthquake intact, only to fall victim to the aftermath.

"There are large margins of safety factored into our plants," said Tom Kauffman, a spokesman for the Nuclear Energy Institute, a U.S. trade group.

Late Friday, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission issued an information notice that represents its first official attempt to explain the event at Fukushima Daiichi to operators of the 104 commercial reactors licensed in the U.S.

The notice also included a recitation of steps American regulators have taken, over the years, to make sure that reactors are prepared for natural disasters or other extraordinary events—a section intended to reassure the public that U.S. regulators and industry are prepared. Preparation includes the development, the NRC said, for restoring cooling water to reactor vessels and spent fuel pools, both of which have suffered failures in Japan.

Of the more than 100 nuclear reactors in the U.S., only the two at Diablo Canyon Power Plant on the central California coast, are in a high-activity area. The Humboldt Bay plant on California's northern coast, was shut down in 1976 because of earthquake fears but still holds some spent nuclear fuel on the site.

Kory Raftery, a spokesman for Diablo Canyon operator Pacific Gas & Electric Co. PCG +1.15% PG&E Corp. U.S.: NYSE $40.53 +0.46 +1.15% Jan. 10, 2014 4:01 pm Volume (Delayed 15m) : 2.53M AFTER HOURS $40.53 0.00 0.00% Jan. 10, 2014 4:35 pm Volume (Delayed 15m): 11,552 P/E Ratio 25.02 Market Cap $18.21 Billion Dividend Yield 4.49% Rev. per Employee $750,401 12/13/13 Allysia Finley: Fifty Shades o... 12/10/13 Natural Gas Leak From PG&E Pip... 12/09/13 PG&E to Spend $300 Million on ... More quote details and news » , said the plant is designed to withstand a 7.5-magnitude quake from the nearby San Andreas fault. Several other less well-known faults run even closer to the plant, including one less than a mile away that was discovered in 2008, but the reactors have been tested to withstand projected quakes from those as well.

But scientists sometimes have underestimated how powerful quakes can be. The temblor that struck Japan was more than 10 times bigger than the Daiichi plant had been tested to withstand. In 2007, the world's biggest nuclear plant, Japan's Kashiwazaki-Kariwa, was damaged after it was hit by a quake far stronger than its designers anticipated.

Antinuclear activists in Japan have long warned that the country's reactors are more vulnerable to earthquakes than operators and government regulators acknowledge.

"A nuclear disaster which the promoters of nuclear power in Japan said wouldn't happen is in progress," said the Citizens' Nuclear Information Center, an antinuclear group based in Tokyo, in a statement last week.

Nuclear power has also been controversial in Taiwan, where all six of the island's existing reactors are built near major fault lines. Two more reactors are under construction near the densely populated cities of Taipei and New Taipei.

The Atomic Energy Council, Taiwan's nuclear regulator, said all its plants are built to withstand earthquakes of magnitude 7 or above and tsunamis of 12 to 15 meters. Both the regulator and government-owned nuclear operator Taiwan Power Company have pledged to take quick steps to increase safety margins if necessary.

Energy experts say it may be hard for Japan and Taiwan to move away from nuclear power. "Developing nuclear is a way to both diversify and reduce dependence on imported oil gas and coal," said Jone-Lin Wang, managing director of global power for the energy consulting firm IHS CERA and a native of Taiwan.

To be sure, most countries have tried to locate nuclear plants outside of quake zones.

"There are not that many places where reactors are built on these major fault zones," said Ben van der Pluijm, a geologist at the University of Michigan. "Japan is probably the poster child."

—Rebecca Smith
and Dionne Searcey
contributed to this article.

Write to Maurice Tamman at maurice.tamman@wsj.com and Ben Casselman at ben.casselman@wsj.com

Corrections & Amplifications
An earlier version of this article understated the number of nuclear reactors that are in earthquake zones. Thirty-four reactors, or 8% of the world's total, are in high-hazard earthquake areas. Of those, 24 are in Japan and six are in Taiwan, and 17 are within a mile of a coastline. Areas that have at least moderate earthquake activity are home to 90 reactors, or about 20% of the world's total.

The earlier version incorrectly said that 14 reactors, or 3% of the world's total, are in high-hazard areas; that 10 of those reactors are in Japan and Taiwan; and that 10 are within a mile of a coastline. The article also incorrectly said that 48 reactors, or 11% of the world's total, are found in areas that have at least moderate earthquake activity.

An earlier version of an interactive graphic that accompanied the article incorrectly categorized some reactors. The corrected version is in the article.

http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052748703512404576208...

Views: 97

Reply to This

"Destroying the New World Order"

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

Latest Activity

Sandy posted a video

Ghislaine Maxwell & The Secret "Shadow" 9/11 Commission? | John Kiriakou

In this gripping excerpt from the Julien Dorey podcast, former CIA officer and whistleblower John Kiriakou reacts to a leaked email from 2003. The document r...
22 hours ago
cheeki kea left a comment for Holyroller
"Greetings to you Holyroller very awesome you've joined up with us all. I know you'll find…"
yesterday
cheeki kea commented on Doc Vega's blog post Are the End Times Drawing Near?
"Yes it's a sad and sorry situation we see evolving here. On one front and it's a large…"
yesterday
Doc Vega commented on tjdavis's video
Thumbnail

When the Communists Take Over America!...Famous 1957 Anti-Communist Movie

"I remember this when I was a little seeing it on TV years after it was filmed and it scared me even…"
yesterday
tjdavis posted a video

When the Communists Take Over America!...Famous 1957 Anti-Communist Movie

Starring Jack Webb and Robert Conrad, this 1957 movie by the United States Armed Forces Information Agency is perhaps the best known anti-communist movie eve...
yesterday
Doc Vega posted a blog post

Are the End Times Drawing Near?

Are we seeing the gradual fulfillment of the Battle of Armageddon? Think of it. The US and Israel…See More
yesterday
Holyroller is now a member of 12160 Social Network
Monday
tjdavis posted a blog post
Monday
Sandy posted photos
Sunday
Burbia posted a video

Catherine Fitts: Epstein, CIA Black Budget, the Control Grid, and the Banks’ Role in War

Programmable digital currency is the final piece of the global control grid that’s finally snapping into place. Catherine Austin Fitts on how to defeat it. C...
Saturday
Евеліна posted a status
"цікаво, воно цитатами виділяє, як моє особливе "я""
Friday
Евеліна posted a status
"на роботі, сонце світить, потрібно перепочити."
Friday
Евеліна posted a blog post

Ключові слова в тексті: як органічно їх вписати в статтю

Що таке ключові слова і чому вони важливіКлючові слова — це слова або фрази, які користувачі…See More
Friday
Евеліна is now a member of 12160 Social Network
Friday
Burbia left a comment for pohonemas33 team
"Quit promoting gambling on another site"
Friday
tjdavis posted a photo
Friday
pohonemas33 team commented on DTOM's photo
Thumbnail

Orwell - Football, Beer & Gambling

"kalau kamu cari tentang trik dan tips main slot online biar gampang menang, coba cek di situs…"
Feb 25
pohonemas33 team commented on tjdavis's photo
Thumbnail

DejaVu

"coba iin main game slot online di situs POHONEMAS33"
Feb 25
tjdavis posted a video

I, Pet Goat VI by - Seymour Studios | I, Pet Goat 6

I, Pet Goat VI by - Seymour Studios | I, Pet Goat 6It's time for great JihadI presented the events in the Middle East as an animated short film based on the ...
Feb 23
tjdavis posted a photo
Feb 22

© 2026   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted