Is it acceptable for Israel to use Gazan civilians as human shields?

 

Charles Kypke

snardfarker.ning.com

April 25, 2011

 

 


Now most would agree that the practice of using human shields is morally wrong, unless of coarse you are immoral, but the logical question here is -- is it legal?

The Israeli High Court ruled against the use of human shields in 2005. The court ruling stated specifically that, "The use of human shields was in violation of international law." The ruling was unfortunately a delayed decision based on Israeli military forces using Palestinian civilians as human shields which was widely practiced during the five year Palestinian uprising that led up to the court ruling.

The "neighboring procedure" as it was called, is well documented. The tactical use of innocent civilians was almost limitless. Israeli soldiers would make civilians brandish weapons to deter fire from Israeli troops to cover troop movements and various urban assaults on Palestinian forces. Other procedures included forcing civilians into potentially booby trapped houses to prevent military casualties as well as forcing Palestinian ambulance drivers to drive in front of Israeli soldiers to provide a mechanized civilian shield.


Judge Aharon Barak, president of the High Court, stated specifically in the ruling: "You cannot exploit the civilian population for the army's military needs, and you cannot force them to collaborate with the army."

In 2002 a coalition of human rights groups, including Israeli and Palestinian organizations, petitioned in opposition to the Israeli Military's use of the neighboring procedure. The petition was filed in response to widespread reports from civilians and Israeli military forces themselves.

As result, The High Court initially ruled an injunction against the policy despite the tireless efforts of human rights groups whom continued to document numerous cases of the use of human shields. The injunction was eventually modified in 2003 to allow the use of "prior warning" situations which were deemed acceptable if Palestinian civilians "volunteered" to help Israeli Defense Forces.

"It is hard to judge when a Palestinians consent was given freely and when it was the fruit of overt or covert pressure," Judge Aharon Barak stated in his written decision. Indeed.

International Law?

A key provision of the Fourth Geneva Convention stipulates legal protections for civilians living under military occupation.

So what is the verdict here Israeli soldier? Guilty. It is Illegal under Israeli and international law to use civilians for human shields or for any military action that would otherwise put them in harms way and violate their human rights.

Sources:

The Jerusalem Post
Gaza: Use of human shields continues
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?c…

Amnesty International Says Israel Uses Palestinians as Human Shields
http://www.aljazeerah.info/News/2009/Jan…

Israel's human shields draw fire
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2003/jan…


Israeli Army Uses Palestinian Children as Human Shield part1
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTh8M80LA…

 

Original posting (Uncle CEO a.k.a yours truly)

http://answers.yahoo.com/activity?show=O7ploA27aa

 

New York Times -- Gaza Strip

http://topics.nytimes.com/top/news/international/countriesandterrit...

Views: 53

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Cryptocurrency on April 26, 2011 at 2:41pm
good answer Doc.

Latest Activity

Chris of the family Masters posted a discussion
3 minutes ago
James T. Kirk posted videos
5 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters favorited Less Prone's blog post Jeannette Bougrab - Letter to veiled women
7 minutes ago
Less Prone favorited Central Scrutinizer's discussion A Hot Time in the Ol Town Tonight
13 minutes ago
Less Prone posted blog posts
19 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters replied to Central Scrutinizer's discussion A Hot Time in the Ol Town Tonight
"So lucky you woke up. Many in your situation fail. Glad your mate is ok, too."
23 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer replied to Central Scrutinizer's discussion A Hot Time in the Ol Town Tonight
"LMAO.... now that's funny right there ;)"
24 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters favorited Central Scrutinizer's discussion A Hot Time in the Ol Town Tonight
26 minutes ago
Less Prone commented on Less Prone's blog post US forces at Al-Tanf are impeding fight against terrorism: Syrian official
"It's a twisted world, a mental asylum run by psychopaths."
29 minutes ago
Diana replied to Central Scrutinizer's discussion A Hot Time in the Ol Town Tonight
"Glad your dog's alright.  Oh yeah, you too!  (Just kidding - glad everyone's okay.)  I had a house fire once (pellet stove) and my dog woke me up.  She didn't carry me out though."
29 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on Less Prone's blog post US forces at Al-Tanf are impeding fight against terrorism: Syrian official
"This what 'war on terror' is all about."
32 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters favorited Less Prone's blog post US forces at Al-Tanf are impeding fight against terrorism: Syrian official
34 minutes ago
Diana favorited Central Scrutinizer's discussion A Hot Time in the Ol Town Tonight
35 minutes ago
Swtnlovabl's blog post was featured

: Everything you ever wanted to know about GMOs, genetically modified organisms, but didn't have the time to ask

The Basics: What's a GMO? A GMO (genetically modified organism) is the result of a laboratory process of taking genes from one species and inserting them into another in an attempt to obtain a desired trait or characteristic, hence they are also…See More
36 minutes ago
Deep Space commented on Deep Space's blog post Off The Deep End - 'Deep Space' Free-Flow Thoughts (An Ongoing Eruption)
"So I tried to hire somebody to beat me up cause I wanted to start a race war & gain attention for myself, but nobody would bite.   All the prospective niggers I interviewed turned me down. They said I was too white &…"
53 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer posted a discussion

A Hot Time in the Ol Town Tonight

I.. AM... FUCKING... DONE... WITH... FIREWOOD!Woke up last night from a dead sleep because I couldn't breath, I could take…See More
55 minutes ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted