Judge Declares BP Not Liable For Damages From Gulf Oil Spill

Un-flipping-believable.

 

http://www.courthousenews.com/2011/06/17/37457.htm

 

NEW ORLEANS (CN) - Ruling in favor of Transocean and BP, a federal judge on Thursday dismissed third-party environmental claims in a giant pleading bundle in the Deepwater Horizon oil spill litigation, saying the fact that the oil flow has stopped makes those lawsuits irrelevant. 
     "The injunction at this stage would be useless, as not only is there no ongoing release from the well, but there is also no viable offshore facility from which any release could possibly occur," U.S. District Judge Carl Barbier wrote. "The Macondo well is dead, and what remains of the Deepwater Horizon vessel is on the ocean floor, where it capsized and sank in 5,000 feet of water.
     "Moreover, BP and the agencies comprising the Unified Area Command have been and are cleaning up the Gulf of Mexico. An injury is not redressable by a citizen suit when the injury is already being addressed."
     Judge Barbier is overseeing the massive, consolidated oil spill litigation, which has been divided into "bundles," based upon the nature of the claims.
     In instances where claims in the D1 bundle pertain to how the oil is being cleaned up, Barbier ruled that even if he allowed those claims to go forward, the claimants are not directly involved in the cleanup, so a ruling in their favor would not affect how the cleanup is progressing. 
     "The D1 defendants do not unilaterally direct the cleanup activities in the Gulf; such activities have been under the control of the National Incident Commander, Federal on-Scene Coordinator, Unified Area Command, and the Coast Guard in cooperation with other federal agencies. Thus, plaintiffs cannot show that an order from this court would actually resolve any potential deficiency in the ongoing cleanup," Barbier wrote.
     "In order to prevail on their claims for injunctive relief, plaintiffs must demonstrate an ongoing violation of various statutes on which plaintiffs' claims for relief is based. Because the Macondo well is dead and is no longer discharging oil, plaintiffs' only claims are confined to seeking environmental citizen suit injunctive relief of a prospective nature to stop noncompliance in the form of a continued release of oil. Thus, the citizen suit claims brought by the plaintiffs are moot, because no future-orientated injunction can provide any meaningful relief for plaintiffs in terms of stopping discharges that already concluded in mid-July 2010."

 

More....

Views: 32

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Unemployed Storm trooper TK420 on June 22, 2011 at 7:07pm
I wonder how much money BP gave to those corrupted Judges to get them to declare that massive  Oil disaster irrelevant to any lawsuits !
Comment by Justin A Horne on June 22, 2011 at 4:41pm
Its sad that the media camouflages the oil spills that have occurred in the Niger Delta. There has been 50 years of environmental devastation inflicted in Nigeria. Oil spills equal to the Exxon Valdez spill have occurred every year for the past five decades, making the Niger delta one of the five most polluted spots on the planet. Such criminals these oil companies are. I'm not surprised that the supreme court said they are not liable. Exxon and Shell has got away with purposely flooding a whole country with Texas tea. Damn criminals get diplomatic immunity every time!

 

 

Latest Activity

Chris of the family Masters commented on Boris Badenov's video
Thumbnail

5,200 Pentagon Employees Bought Child Pornography, Investigation halted after 8 Months

"All people are equal, but some are more equal then others."
31 minutes ago
Deep Space commented on Deep Space's blog post Pompeo on China Trade War: 'We Are Going to Win' < NO WE'RE NOT! EVERYTHING IS GOING TO COST MORE IN AN ALREADY SEVERELY DEPRESSED WAR ECONOMY WHERE 100+ MILLION AMERICANS ARE UNEMPLOYED
"@T - It doesn't get anymore obvious than this. I am completely flabbergasted that even a simpleton like Drumph doesn't have the capacity to see this clearly..."
43 minutes ago
Sweettina2 commented on Boris Badenov's video
Thumbnail

5,200 Pentagon Employees Bought Child Pornography, Investigation halted after 8 Months

"Holy shite! Thanks, buddy, sharing this. I just hate we had to hear it from Cooper, can't stand that guy..."
45 minutes ago
Sweettina2 commented on Sweettina2's blog post Brutal CHRISTIAN persecution at highest level in China, Pope Francis betrays them
"Absolutely right, Chris. I believe he is the False Prophet, he's shown that in so many ways. This betrayal will be par for the course."
48 minutes ago
Chris of the family Masters's video was featured

The STRAW MAN is not Yours, do not use it, ABANDON THAT NAME

Go to 'losethename.com' and learn the absolute and ugly truth about the Governments, the use of the NAME, and your whole life living a lie from the day they ...
49 minutes ago
Fat Freddys Cat's 2 blog posts were featured
49 minutes ago
Sweettina2 commented on Deep Space's blog post Pompeo on China Trade War: 'We Are Going to Win' < NO WE'RE NOT! EVERYTHING IS GOING TO COST MORE IN AN ALREADY SEVERELY DEPRESSED WAR ECONOMY WHERE 100+ MILLION AMERICANS ARE UNEMPLOYED
"Right on, DS, I agree!"
50 minutes ago
Boris Badenov's video was featured
50 minutes ago
Deep Space commented on Deep Space's blog post Off The Deep End - 'Deep Space' Free-Flow Thoughts (An Ongoing Eruption)
"And what is the government gonna do with the $300 difference I gotta pay for that refrigerator? Kick it back to you in the form of shit like health care or something positive? BIG FAT NOPE! They're just gonna use it to keep funding ISIS &…"
51 minutes ago
Sweettina2 commented on Chris of the family Masters's video
Thumbnail

The STRAW MAN is not Yours, do not use it, ABANDON THAT NAME

"Not sure bout this, Chris, maybe it's difference of country, but mine allows me, the bearer of the document, to be used. We have to pick our battles, over analyzing can make us crazy and cause lots more problems more important. "
51 minutes ago
Deep Space commented on Deep Space's blog post Off The Deep End - 'Deep Space' Free-Flow Thoughts (An Ongoing Eruption)
"I gotta buy a fucking refrigerator. The one I want is $900. If I wait for Drumph's retarded tariffs to take effect, it's gonna be $1200..."
55 minutes ago
Deep Space commented on Deep Space's blog post Off The Deep End - 'Deep Space' Free-Flow Thoughts (An Ongoing Eruption)
"Had an awesome convo with a Chinese guy who owns a local Chinese restaurant I frequent. I started off by saying North & South Korea wanna re-unify & kick out the evil war-mongering Americans. I'll paraphrase him: he said; “Most…"
1 hour ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on Sweettina2's blog post Brutal CHRISTIAN persecution at highest level in China, Pope Francis betrays them
"'Pope' Francis is a satanic jesuit. Nothing to do with Christianity."
1 hour ago
Boris Badenov favorited truth's photo
1 hour ago
Sweettina2 posted a blog post

Brutal CHRISTIAN persecution at highest level in China, Pope Francis betrays them

                               Chinese Catholics attend an Ash Wednesday…See More
1 hour ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on Chris of the family Masters's video
Thumbnail

The STRAW MAN is not Yours, do not use it, ABANDON THAT NAME

"When we 'id' ourselves on demand, we commit the crime of impersonation, for the name we admit to is copyright. It could be our only crime."
1 hour ago
richard J Lacy commented on Central Scrutinizer's blog post WOMAN FACES CHARGES FOR SAVING DOZENS OF PETS WITHOUT A PERMIT DURING HURRICANE FLORENCE
"She should counter sue - the gubment were asleep at the wheel so I took up the slack. Also no gubment worker should be paid unless they can prove they were actually working - which would mean helping this woman who was doing their job - she should…"
1 hour ago
james ha commented on Deep Space's blog post US-led aircraft evacuate *ISIS* (Daesh) commanders from eastern Syria: Report - FU Trump!!
"so the ISIS terrorist commanders get rescued but the rank and file terrorist little homies get left behind to face the music. "hey little homie #7, you are not high enough in rank to be saved....maybe next time!""
1 hour ago
Less Prone's blog post was featured

Marine Le Pen outraged after court orders her to undergo psychological examination

Marine Le Pen, a French presidential candidate running against Emmanuel Macron in 2017, is ordered to undergo a psychological examination. Her views are with the most common sense especially in the immigration policies. She's a patriot opposing the…See More
2 hours ago
Old Denmark's discussion was featured

Military intervention in Venezuela ‘on the table,’ says OAS secretary general

Military intervention in Venezuela ‘on the table,’ says OAS secretary generalPublished time: 15 Sep, 2018 06:15The head of the Organization of American States (OAS), accused by Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro of being a “CIA agent,” says…See More
2 hours ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2018   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted