Utah showdown with the feds as Dec. 31 deadline approaches for state to reclaim its land

Utah

Utah showdown with the feds as Dec. 31 deadline approaches for state to reclaim its land

(NaturalNews) An impending showdown between Utah and the federal government may set a precedent affecting future disputes regarding state vs. federal land ownership.

In 2012, Governor Gary Herbert formally challenged the feds over the right to control 31.2 million acres of Utah land when he signed the "Transfer of Public Lands Act." One of the provisions of the act demands that the federal government turn over the lands by December 31, 2014.

At this point, the feds haven't responded and it remains unclear exactly what will happen as the deadline approaches. The lands in question account for more than 64 percent of Utah's total acreage.

Federal government controls over half of western lands 

The federal government controls more than half of the land in the West and many states are beginning to challenge its continued right to do so.

Utah, however, has pushed the debate to a new level and the case may end up before the Supreme Court.

Utah State Representative Ken Ivory, sponsor of the legislation, said:

Under increasing federal control, access is being restricted. The health of the land is diminishing horribly. And the productivity is depressed. This is the only way to get better access, better health and better productivity.

Feds reneged on terms of 1894 Enabling Act 

When Utah was becoming a state, the federal government passed "The 1894 Enabling Act," which gave it control over the majority of the land, while promising to eventually return it to the state. In exchange, the feds would use the revenues from managing the land to fund Utah's public education system.

Essentially, the feds reneged on the original deal and engaged in what many see as a massive land-grab, one in which the land has been ineffectively managed, while educational infrastructure investment has remained paltry. Utah ranks among the lowest states in terms of school funding.

If there's no response by the end of the December, the state plans to move ahead with its program of "education, negotiation, legislation and litigation."

Showdown more likely in courtroom than Bryce Canyon

Although there won't likely be any armed showdowns between state and federal agents in Utah, it should be interesting to see how far the litigation goes. Utah has taken a bold step which may prove to be an example for other states considering similar legislation.

Advocates of the Utah challenge against the feds were encouraged by the recent release of a report entitled "An Analysis of a Transfer of Federal Lands to the State of Utah," the findings of which indicated that the plan would pay off economically for the state.

The analysis suggested that the state would be able to bring in enough income from managing the land itself to more than cover the costs of doing so. Mineral resources development could bring in more than $330 million - roughly $50 million more than the cost of management.

The report also found that federal control of large percentages of land results in an economic "drag" on local communities - most counties in Utah exceed what the authors consider the healthy limit of around 40 to 45 percent federally controlled land.

Governor Herbert's responsed to the report saying, "I expect that public discussion will be well served by this report. It shows the complexities and connections between Utah's robust economy and the great quality of life Utahans enjoy."

Other Western states, as well as various interest groups, will likely be paying very close attention to the results of the precedent being set in Utah.

One faction in opposition to the legislation is the environmentalist movement, which sees the relinquishment of federal control as a potential threat to Utah's natural resources.

Green activists worry that state control will lead to expanded gas and oil development in wild areas, while the legislation's defenders are promising that won't be the case.

If Utah is successful in gaining control over the disputed lands, it remains to be seen if it can manage the responsibility in a way that benefits the state's citizens while preserving its precious wilderness areas.

Sources for this article include:
http://www.washingtontimes.com
http://www.westernjournalism.com

Views: 80

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Latest Activity

Deep Space commented on Deep Space's blog post Off The Deep End - 'Deep Space' Free-Flow Thoughts (An Ongoing Eruption)
"Alex Jones is selling energy drinks & protein bars now. He told me l should buy his shit to fund his operation to fight the globalists, but I have reservations. Cause when I told him that the globalists were zionists he hung up on me."
31 minutes ago
Deep Space commented on KLC's group MUSICWARS
"Someone pointed out to me that, that's Guthrie Govan in that Hans Zimmer concert, & I was like "holy shit!" I didn't know! So cool. I didn't even recognize him. Guthrie is one of the most amazing guitar players ever."
1 hour ago
Profile Icon via Twitter
RT @robbystarbuck: For anyone hearing from media that they were just reporting facts when the Jussie Smollett hoax happened, they are lying…
Twitter2 hours ago · Reply · Retweet
Profile Icon via Twitter
RT @nickmon1112: WE GOT A MOTIVE for Jussie Smollett. “When the letter didn’t get enough attention, he concocted the staged attack,” https:…
Twitter2 hours ago · Reply · Retweet
canadianjoe favorited Diana's photo
3 hours ago
Thomas Less posted a blog post

Daily Verse

Give thanks to the LORD, for he is good; his love endures forever. — Psalm 107:1See More
3 hours ago
Deep Space posted a photo
3 hours ago
Deep Space commented on James T. Kirk's video
Thumbnail

Israel Prepares for Conflict with Russia

"Yes. That would be prudent. (and it would take the exact same amount of time)"
4 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on James T. Kirk's video
Thumbnail

Israel Prepares for Conflict with Russia

"Two nukes. Another at Dimona nuclear center."
4 hours ago
Profile Icon via Twitter
RT @JackPosobiec: @realDonaldTrump Jussie Smollett may be the first American in history to scam two Nigerians
Twitter4 hours ago · Reply · Retweet
Profile Icon via Twitter
RT @BreakingNLive: BREAKING: Chicago police are now looking closely into the possibility that Jussie Smollett sent racist and pro-Trump let…
Twitter4 hours ago · Reply · Retweet
Deep Space commented on James T. Kirk's video
Thumbnail

Israel Prepares for Conflict with Russia

"This is a rare example of a nuclear war that could happen between two nuclear-armed nations that is definitely winnable in record time. All Russia has to do is launch one tactical nuke from a sub in the Mediterranean Sea at Tel…"
4 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters favorited Sweettina2's video
4 hours ago
Sweettina2 posted a video

Darkness Has Blinded People To What's Happening

It's sad to say, but most Americans are blind to what's going on in this country and around the world. Most people have their own opinions and false paradigm...
5 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters commented on James T. Kirk's video
Thumbnail

Israel Prepares for Conflict with Russia

"That will be a last thing Kazarians will ever do, and the world will experience everlasting peace."
5 hours ago
Diana favorited dogitydog's discussion Over 30,000 Scientists Declare Climate Change A Hoax
6 hours ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted