Alfred Hitchcock's unseen Holocaust documentary to be screened

Alfred Hitchcock's unseen Holocaust documentary to be screened

It's a little known fact that the great director made a film about the Nazi death camps – but, horrified by the footage he saw, the documentary was never shown. Now it is to be released. Geoffrey Macnab reports

The British Army Film Unit cameramen who shot the liberation of Bergen-Belsen concentration camp in 1945 used to joke about the reaction of Alfred Hithcock to the horrific footage they filmed. When Hitchcock first saw the footage, the legendary British director was reportedly so traumatised that he stayed away from Pinewood Studios for a week. Hitchcock may have been the king of horror movies but he was utterly appalled by "the real thing".

In 1945, Hithcock had been enlisted by his friend and patron Sidney Bernstein to help with a documentary on German wartime atrocities, based on the footage of the camps shot by British and Soviet film units. In the event, that documentary was never seen.

"It was suppressed because of the changing political situation, particularly for the British," suggests Dr Toby Haggith, Senior Curator at the Department of Research, Imperial War Museum. "Once they discovered the camps, the Americans and British were keen to release a film very quickly that would show the camps and get the German people to accept their responsibility for the atrocities that were there."

The film took far longer to make than had originally been envisaged. By late 1945, the need for it began to wane. The Allied military government decided that rubbing the Germans' noses in their own guilt wouldn't help with postwar reconstruction.

Five of the film's six reels were eventually deposited in the Imperial War Museum and the project was quietly forgotten.

In the 1980s, the footage was discovered in a rusty can in the museum by an American researcher. It was eventually shown in an incomplete version at the Berlin Film Festival in 1984 and then broadcast on American PBS in 1985 under the title Memory of the Camps but in poor quality and without the missing sixth reel. The original narration, thought to have been written by future Labour Cabinet Minister Richard Crossman in collaboration with Australian journalist Colin Wills, was read by actor Trevor Howard.

Now, finally, the film is set to be seen in a version that Hitchcock, Bernstein and the other collaborators intended. The Imperial War Museum has painstakingly restored it using digital technology and has pieced together the extra material from the missing sixth reel. A new documentary, Night Will Fall, is also being made with André Singer, executive producer of The Actof Killing, as director and Stephen Frears as directorial advisor. Both the original film about the camps and the new documentary will be shown on British TV in early 2015 to mark the 70th anniversary of the "liberation" of Europe. Before that, next year, they are due to be shown together at festivals and in cinemas.

The decision to revive the film is bound to provoke anguished debate. It includes truly shocking footage of the camps (Belsen-Bergen in particular.) The film's own commentary, which has been re-recorded with a new actor, has a phrase about "sightseers" at a "chamber of horrors".

Billy Wilder, who directed Death Mills (1945), an American film about the German atrocities, was forthright about why he did not want atrocity footage to be seen in later years. Wilder questioned whether it had worked in "re-educating" the German civilian population about what their leaders had been doing in their name.

Belsen concentration camp in 1945, while under British control after liberation (Getty) Belsen concentration camp in 1945, while under British control after liberation (Getty)
"They [the Germans] couldn't cope with it. He [Wilder] told me people just left the screening or closed their eyes. They didn't want to see," Wilder's friend Volker Schlöndorff recalled in a 2011 interview. "They found out it was almost unbearable to see these documents and almost indecent for the victims or the people related to the victims."

In Memory of the Camps, there is imagery of heaps of naked bodies being piled up in mass graves. The footage seems as surreal as anything you might see in a Hieronymus Bosch painting but then you remember that these corpses haven't been conjured up by some artist's twisted imagination. These are real victims whose relatives are alive today.

In the documentary, we see the Germans themselves confronted with the enormity of the crimes committed in their name and forced to help bury the dead themselves.

As Toby Haggith acknowledges, the film is "much more candid" than any of the other documentaries about the camps. Haggith also describes it as "brilliant" and "sophisticated". The editors Stewart McAllister (famous for his work with Humphrey Jennings) and Peter Tanner, working under advice from Hitchcock, fashioned an immensely powerful and moving film from the hours and hours of grim material at their disposal. The documentary isn't all about death. We also see imagery of reconstruction and reconciliation. There is footage of camp inmates having their first showers and cleaning their clothes. The film-makers show the painstaking way that typhus was eradicated from the camps.

Haggith speak of the "brilliance" of the original cameramen at the camps, who were working without direction but still had an uncanny knack for homing in on the most poignant and telling images.

"It's both an alienating film in terms of its subject matter but also one that has a deep humanity and empathy about it," Haggith suggests. "Rather than coming away feeling totally depressed and beaten, there are elements of hope."

The Trevor Howard voiceover narration in Memory of the Camps is strangely reminiscent of the one that director Carol Reed himself read over the opening of The Third Man (in which Howard co-starred.) It has the same sardonic understatement as it describes the devastation wreaked by the war. In the new version, the words will remain (but have now been recorded by a contemporary actor.)

Memory of the Camps was a title given to the documentary years after it was made. It will now be renamed. Haggith won't reveal the new title.

For Hitchcock fans, the Holocaust film is a cause for both excitement and wariness. On the one hand, it seems obvious that his work on the documentary must have had a profound influence on him. He may have been a "treatment advisor" on the project rather than its actual director but his exposure to imagery as extreme as this must have coloured his approach to depicting horror and violence on screen.

The wariness comes from the sense that it is both distasteful and absurdly reductive to see a Nazi atrocity documentary as a "Hitchcock movie". We will never know exactly how much he contributed to the film, even if it seems certain that his ideas about how it should be structured were taken on board.

"Our experience with it has been similar to the experience of the cameramen really, in that the technical work has to some degree protected us from the meaning of the film," Haggith suggests of the experience of spending many months poring over such gruesome and disturbing imagery. He adds that "the fact that we have been habituated to these images over the last 70 years" has meant that the restorers have been able to treat the film as "historical source material".

The restoration is now almost complete. How will contemporary audiences react to a film which, when it was first being put together, traumatised Hitchcock himself and so deeply upset its original editors, who weren't aware of what had actually gone on in the camps?

"Judging by the two test screenings we have had for colleagues, experts and film historians, what struck me was that they found it extremely disturbing," Haggith says. "When you're sitting in a darkened cinema and you're focusing on a screen, your attention is very focused, unlike watching it on television... the digital restoration has made this material seem very fresh. One of the common remarks was that it [the film] was both terrible and brilliant at the same time."

That, Haggith, believes is testament to the craftsmanship of the film-makers, who took some of "the most atrocious and disturbing footage that had yet been recorded in cinema at that stage" and turned into a film that was lucid, moving and instructive as well as appalling. The job now for those showing the film is to provide context and explanation. As Haggith puts it: "We can't stop the film being incredibly upsetting and disturbing but we can help people understand why it is being presented in that way."

The restored version of the concentration camp film, retrospectively titled 'Memory of the Camps', will be released later this year

Views: 524

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Wikipedia
The camp was liberated on April 15, 1945 by the British 11th Armoured Division.[5] The soldiers discovered around 53,000 prisoners inside, most of them half-starved and seriously ill,

The horrors of the camp, documented on film and in pictures, made the name "Belsen" emblematic of Nazi crimes in general for public opinion in Western countries in the immediate post-1945 period.

with up to 35,000 of them dying of typhus in the first few months of 1945, shortly before and after the liberation.[4]

Allied bombing stopped food supplies causes everyone to be easy target for diseases - crimes with impunity

Allied forces bombed nazi factories with 1000's of dissidents, jews, and POW's inside well-knowing they were there. Horrific.  

The creation of a Holocaust - It was written into the Versaille Treaty

Logic: Those who lose a war have to pay the cost of both sides

Really? That is an interesting priciple they did not care much about later.

Rothschild's terms for War loans were: If you are the victor you have to pay the debt of the conquered nation as well

The same evil people accused of these atrocities couldn't sit through a documentary depicting them. The allies had no problem viewing them, they caused them by bombing the rail lines. They weren't "death camps" until the supply lines were cut off. like General Patton said about the jew before he was assassinated,  
"where, although room existed, the Jews were crowded together to an appalling extent, and in practically every room there was a pile of garbage in one corner which was also used as a latrine. The Jews were only forced to desist from their nastiness and clean up the mess by the threat of the butt ends of rifles. Of course, I know the expression 'lost tribes of Israel' applied to the tribes which disappeared -- not to the tribe of Judah from which the current sons of bitches are descended. However, it is my personal opinion that this too is a lost tribe -- lost to all decency."  I think we have all heard far too much about the supposed holo-hoax and the eternal suffering of gawds chozen....

RSS

"Destroying the New World Order"

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

Latest Activity

Central Scrutinizer favorited Chris of the family Masters's video
25 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer commented on Chris of the family Masters's video
Thumbnail

Dr Rashid A Buttar WHAT FACE MASKS ACTUALLY DO TO YOUR HEALTH

"wAIT....wha???.... how refreshing... and here I thought all human logic circuits, rational thinking…"
25 minutes ago
Maas favorited Aaron's photo
4 hours ago
MAC commented on James Roberts's photo
Thumbnail

Our Rights Despite An Emergency

"I got Slapped Upside the Head for sharing your post!"
5 hours ago
MAC favorited James Roberts's photo
6 hours ago
Aaron posted blog posts
6 hours ago
Aaron posted videos
6 hours ago
Guardian of Scotland commented on Aaron's blog post Unmasking The Mask Hoax – Bow Down Anyhow… Submit To All Unlawful Authority Or Else!
"I do not trust anything the CDC has to say about anything. I would like to see exactly where on the…"
7 hours ago
Phyllis Maka commented on Phyllis Maka's blog post If Trump wins and the Democrats steal the Senate in 2020? the House will impeach and the Senate will convict
"We are here now being awakened to do the job of clearing out this 'muckety muck of all…"
8 hours ago
Phyllis Maka posted blog posts
9 hours ago
Mr. Sizzle favorited Chris of the family Masters's video
9 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters posted a discussion

Covid "Safety" Mirrors Initiation Into a Satanic Cult

July 11, 2020 "The entire manufactured coronavirus crisis is one giant, occult ritual from start to…See More
10 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters favorited Phyllis Maka's blog post If Trump wins and the Democrats steal the Senate in 2020? the House will impeach and the Senate will convict
11 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on Phyllis Maka's blog post If Trump wins and the Democrats steal the Senate in 2020? the House will impeach and the Senate will convict
"All this will come to light sooner or later, and that's when we will see the parents blamed, -…"
12 hours ago
Doc Vega commented on Chris of the family Masters's video
Thumbnail

Dr Rashid A Buttar WHAT FACE MASKS ACTUALLY DO TO YOUR HEALTH

"A voice of integrity! I love this guy! "
12 hours ago
Doc Vega favorited Chris of the family Masters's video
12 hours ago
cheeki kea favorited Phyllis Maka's blog post If Trump wins and the Democrats steal the Senate in 2020? the House will impeach and the Senate will convict
15 hours ago
cheeki kea favorited Aaron's video
17 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on Aaron's blog post Liberal writers, activists sign open letter calling to end 'cancel culture'
18 hours ago
Old Denmark posted a video

Alan Watt (July 12, 2020) A Virus Which is All Things to All Men

https://www.CuttingThroughTheMatrix.com with Alan Watt - TOPICS - Weather - Relying on Experts - The Weather Channel - Climate Change - The Elite Use Groups;...
20 hours ago

© 2020   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted