How many Muslims has the U.S. killed in the past 30 years?

Tom Friedman had an especially fatuous column in Sunday's New York Times, which said something given his well-established capacity for smug self-assurance. According to Friedman, the big challenge we face in the Arab and Islamic world is "the Narrative" -- his patronizing term for Muslim views about America's supposedly negative role in the region. If Muslims weren't so irrational, he thinks, they would recognize that "U.S. foreign policy has been largely dedicated to rescuing Muslims or trying to help free them from tyranny." He concedes that we made a few mistakes here and there (such as at Abu Ghraib), but the real problem is all those anti-American fairy tales that Muslims tell each other to avoid taking responsibility for their own actions.

On the other hand, a different take on this subject was brought forward at a conference on U.S. relations with the Islamic world. In addition to a diverse set of views from different Islamic countries, one of the other participants (a prominent English journalist) put it quite simply. "If the United States wants to improve its image in the Islamic world," he said, "it should stop killing Muslims."

Though the issue is not quite that simple,  the comment was thought provoking: How many Muslims has the United States killed in the past thirty years, and how many Americans have been killed by Muslims? Coming up with a precise answer to this question is probably impossible, but it is also not necessary, because the rough numbers are so clearly lopsided.

Here's a back-of-the-envelope analysis, based on estimates deliberately chosen to favor the United States. Specifically, this has taken the low estimates of Muslim fatalities, along with much more reliable figures for U.S. deaths. 

To repeat: the chart above was created by deliberately selecting "low-end" estimates for Muslim fatalities, so these figures present the "best case" for the United States. Even so, the United States has killed nearly 30 Muslims for every American lost. The real ratio is probably much higher, and a reasonable upper bound for Muslim fatalities (based mostly on higher estimates of "excess deaths" in Iraq due to the sanctions regime and the post-2003 occupation) is well over one millionequivalent to over 100 Muslim fatalities for every American lost.

Figures like these should be used with caution, of course, and several obvious caveats apply. To begin with, the United States is not solely responsible for some of those fatalities, most notably in the case of the "excess deaths" attributable to the U.N. sanctions regime against Iraq. Saddam Hussein clearly deserves much of the blame for these "excess deaths," insofar as he could have complied with Security Council resolutions and gotten the sanctions lifted or used the "oil for food" problem properly. Nonetheless, the fact remains that the United States (and the other SC members) knew that keeping the sanctions in place would cause tens of thousands of innocent people to die and we went ahead anyway. 

Similarly, the United States is not solely to blame for the sectarian violence that engulfed Iraq after the 2003 invasion. U.S. forces killed many Iraqis, to be sure, but plenty of Shiites, Kurds, Sunnis, and foreign infiltrators were pulling triggers and planting bombs too. Yet it is still the case that the United States invaded a country that had not attacked it, dismantled its regime, and took hardly any precautions to prevent the (predictable) outbreak of violence. Having uncapped the volcano, Americans are hardly blameless, and that goes for pundits like Friedman who enthusiastically endorsed the original invasion.

Third, the fact that people died as a result of certain U.S. actions does not by itself mean that those policy decisions were wrong. In other words, a full assessment of U.S. policy would have to weigh the regrettable costs against the alleged benefits to the United States itself or the international community as a whole. 

Yet if you really want to know "why they hate us," the numbers presented above cannot be ignored. Even if we view these figures with skepticism and discount the numbers a lot, the fact remains that the United States has killed a very large number of Arab or Muslim individuals over the past three decades. Even though some may say that the U.S. had just cause and the right intentions in some cases (as in the first Gulf War), its actions were indefensible (maybe even criminal) in others. 

It is also striking to observe that virtually all of the Muslim deaths were the direct or indirect consequence of official U.S. government policy. By contrast, most of the Americans killed by Muslims were the victims of non-state terrorist groups such as al Qaeda or the insurgents in Iraq and Afghanistan. Americans should also bear in mind that the figures reported above omit the Arabs and Muslims killed by Israel in Lebanon, Gaza, and the West Bank. Given our generous and unconditional support for Israel's policy towards the Arab world in general and the Palestinians in particular, Muslims rightly hold us partly responsible for those victims too.

Contrary to what Friedman thinks, America's real problem isn't a fictitious Muslim "narrative" about America's role in the region; it is mostly the actual things America has been doing in recent years. To say that in no way justifies anti-American terrorism or absolves other societies of responsibility for their own mistakes or misdeeds. But the self-righteousness on display in Friedman's op-ed isn't just simplistic; it is actively harmful. Why? Because whitewashing one's own misconduct makes it harder for Americans to figure out why their country is so unpopular and makes us less likely to consider different (and more effective) approaches.

Some degree of anti-Americanism may reflect ideology, distorted history, or a foreign government's attempt to shift blame onto others (a practice that all governments indulge in), but a lot of it is the inevitable result of policies that the American people have supported in the past. When you kill tens of thousands of people in other countries -- and sometimes for no good reason -- you shouldn't be surprised when people in those countries are enraged by this behavior and interested in revenge. After all, how did Americans react after September 11? 

Views: 1334

Reply to This

 

 

Latest Activity

Central Scrutinizer favorited Raz Putin's discussion "RFK Jr. wins case against U.S. government for vaccine safety violations"
2 minutes ago
Deep Space's blog post was featured

Norway bitches it’s ‘aware Russia jammed’ GPS at massive NATO drills

Norway bitches it’s ‘aware Russia jammed’ GPS at massive NATO drills11/13/18The Norwegian military have accused Russia of meddling with the Scandinavian nation’s GPS during NATO’s Trident Juncture military drills – a day after similar, evidence-free…See More
3 minutes ago
Burbia's video was featured
3 minutes ago
Deep Space favorited DTOM's blog post The Great Twitter-CNN-Jewish Meme War ...In Case You Haven't Seen It
6 minutes ago
Guardian of Scotland commented on Central Scrutinizer's blog post Watch–Caravan Migrants Arrive at Southern Border, Scale Fence
"They would not be coming over the fence if Marines were on the other side with guns pointed at them. "
7 minutes ago
William Stack commented on Boris Badenov's page No Wonder Trump Calls Them The Enemy of the People.
"For telling the truth? "
14 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer posted blog posts
21 minutes ago
James D commented on Boris Badenov's page video- Brenda Snipes, asked if her history has bearing on her ballot handling in FL
"Isn't there a felony hiding in plain sight with respect to this person's behavior?"
28 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer posted a discussion

The Heritage Guide to The Constitution

The Heritage Guide to the Constitution is a landmark, one-of-a-kind book that presents the U.S. Constitution as never before.It includes:Clause-by-clause analysis of the entire Constitution and each amendmentInput from more than 100 constitutional…See More
34 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer favorited Boris Badenov's video
42 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer posted a video

The Molten-Salt Reactor Experiment

This film was produced in 1969 by Oak Ridge National Laboratory for the United States Atomic Energy Commission to inform the public regarding the history, te...
51 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer commented on Boris Badenov's page video- Brenda Snipes, asked if her history has bearing on her ballot handling in FL
56 minutes ago
Profile IconCentral Scrutinizer and Alice Rabbit were featured
56 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer commented on Central Scrutinizer's blog post (Video)15 ARRESTS IN GEORGIA: DEMOCRAT STATE SENATOR ARRESTED AT CAPITOL IN VOTE-COUNT FIASCO
"Buh-Bye felicia.... "
1 hour ago
Diana favorited Chris of the family Masters's discussion RFID? Beat Them With Their Own Stick.
1 hour ago
DTOM's blog post was featured

The Great Twitter-CNN-Jewish Meme War ...In Case You Haven't Seen It

 The Great Twitter-CNN-Jewish Meme War ...In Case You Haven't Seen It7-5-17…See More
1 hour ago
Diana posted photos
1 hour ago
Diana favorited Fat Freddys Cat's blog post Compilation of Overwhelming Election Fraud Evidence in Broward County Florida
1 hour ago
Central Scrutinizer commented on Raz Putin's video
1 hour ago
Diana commented on Central Scrutinizer's blog post Watch–Caravan Migrants Arrive at Southern Border, Scale Fence
"LGBT members of migrant caravan reach US border, say they endured verbal abuse by other migrants   …"
1 hour ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2018   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted