by Scott Tips, JD
May 27, 2010

Did you ever see that movie Night of the Living Dead? Well, I didn’t either. But I can imagine how it went, with mindless zombies roaming around turning others into the same. I don’t mean to be discourteous to my fellow Codex delegates, but I am reminded of the movie each time that I attend the meetings of the Codex Committee on Contaminants in Foods (CCCF).

This most-recent CCCF meeting, held this week of April 26-30, 2010, in Izmir, Turkey, has been no exception. No arguments, no disagreements, no hot collars, just plodding murmurs of assent to whatever is put in front of them. Here it is, eat it. Okay. Mmmm, tastes good . . . .

The hosts for the meeting were the Dutch government nominally and the Turkish government actually, with the Turkish host outdoing all other Committees in the quality of the surroundings, receptions, and events planned for the Codex delegates. This was far and away the best-arranged Codex meeting, thanks to Turkey and there could be no complaints there.

Melamine on your Table

Unfortunately, though, the Committee itself expressed a general desire to adopt “acceptable” levels for melamine in foods when melamine is not even a contaminant naturally found in soil, water, or air. It is completely man-made and man-introduced. So, its acceptable level should be set at zero.
Unfortunately, the Committee members had other ideas. (See Codex document “
Proposed Draft Maximum Levels for Melamine in Food and Feed (N13-2009)”. The CCCF party line, espoused most vocally by the European Union (EU), was to establish an acceptable contamination level for melamine at 1.0 part per million (ppm, equal to 1 milligram per kilogram of food) for infant formulas and 2.5 ppm for adults.

The problem is that melamine, even at low levels, can interact with other contaminants with lethal effect. For example, small amounts of melamine combined with pesticides/herbicides such as cyromazine used on mushrooms has a multiplicative effect, so that when regulators look at contaminants in isolation, they are not seeing the real-world picture. Yet, that isolated perspective is what they are basing their rules, regulations, and standards upon.

At the meeting, as the NHF’s delegate, I argued – unfortunately alone – that “Melamine is a synthetic chemical, deliberately added to foods. It is cumulative, deadly to humans and animals, and, as such, has no place in the food chain. Its acceptable limit for human consumption should be set at zero. Unlike naturally-occurring toxins, such as arsenic and lead, melamine is an intentional contaminant, whether directly or indirectly added to foods.” (See also the NHF’s written comments, submitted to the Committee as CRD 10.)

Brains Left at the Door

But hearing delegation after delegation after delegation support the EU position (even one, Ghana, which had promised earlier to support the NHF), the NHF was forced to argue its fallback position, which was that the 1.0 level for infants should then be set across the board for all foods and feeds. “Why,” I challenged the delegates, “if the issue is – as the EU and other delegations say – that we cannot keep melamine out of our foods as a practical matter, we are able to establish a level of 1.0 contamination for infants but find it impossible to set the same for adults? Why not 1.0 for all, at the very least?”

Not one single delegation answered that question, so NHF raised it yet again, challenging the delegates to answer it and braving the disdain of the CCCF chairman Mr. Martijn Weijtens, who insulted the NHF with dismissive comments. Still, no one could or would answer the question.

Instead, the EU delegate proceeded to push through exemptions to even these unacceptable levels of melamine contamination! So, in three cases (from the application of cyromazine as a pesticide/herbicide, from migration through food contact with melamine dinnerware and other foodware, and from certain food additives and ingredients) even the insane 2.5 ppm level will and can be exceeded, as the CCCF agreed with the EU suggestion! They could not have cared less.

I was stunned when I heard that the EU wanted exemptions so large that you could drive a truck through them. I was just waiting for someone to suggest that all of the Codex delegates place their heads in nooses too, for I was certain they all would have happily murmured their assent to that suggestion as well.

At Least Label Disclosure?

NHF therefore proposed that if and when melamine contamination levels exceeded 2.5 ppm, then that fact must be disclosed on the food or feed labels for consumers to read. The Chairman helpfully stated he would not take that idea up at his Committee, and that was the end of that idea at this meeting (but not forever).

The CCCF meeting ended on the last day of April, having mindlessly adopted standards of melamine contamination that will needlessly harm humans and animals all over the World all for the convenience of a few industries. It was absolutely inconceivable and disgusting that only the National Health Federation spoke out against melamine contamination.

It is truly bizarre that Codex delegates will trip all over themselves in their rush to establish low maximum acceptable levels for healthy vitamins and minerals, but when it comes to a true industrial contaminant, extremely harmful to health, they look the other way.

Views: 44


You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Billy1st III% on June 30, 2010 at 10:29pm
Another metting to dumb down all of us slaves the world over! It was just a meeting on the progress of how it has been going!

Latest Activity

Burbia replied to MAC's discussion Target Sells LGBTQ Clothing For Children, Funds Group Whose Founder Praised NAMBLA Defender
8 minutes ago
Burbia replied to Central Scrutinizer's discussion Bought a Berkey!
"They are great people at Berkey. Was star struck a bit when the lady on the phone was also on Infowars. I had a similar experience with them. I couldn't stop laughing with my Berkey, Infowars membership and that Tang powder food suplement. I…"
14 minutes ago
Sweettina2 posted videos
24 minutes ago
Central Scrutinizer favorited James T. Kirk's video
1 hour ago
MAC posted a discussion
2 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer favorited Dr. Frederick Meekins's blog post Producers Hint Batman May Never Return To Television
2 hours ago
Raz Putin replied to Central Scrutinizer's discussion Bought a Berkey!
2 hours ago
Raz Putin favorited Central Scrutinizer's discussion Bought a Berkey!
2 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer's discussion was featured

Bought a Berkey!

I had been saying it for 4 years, " I'm going to get a water purifier when I can afford one damn it"Well I finally ordered a…See More
2 hours ago
Raz Putin favorited Anti Everything's blog post Medical Industrial Corporations Will Kill You
2 hours ago
Raz Putin favorited Chris of the family Masters's blog post Template for Australians.
2 hours ago
Central Scrutinizer posted a discussion

Bought a Berkey!

I had been saying it for 4 years, " I'm going to get a water purifier when I can afford one damn it"Well I finally ordered a…See More
2 hours ago
Phyllis Maka's blog post was featured

Who Are 'They' really? These Scandalous Troublemakers! Want To Rule & Hog Every Leetle Thing In Sight, Every Where They Go!

Former US lawmaker Cynthia McKinney says every candidate for Congress has to sign a pledge to vote for supporting the military superiority of Israel.…See More
2 hours ago
Dr. Frederick Meekins's blog post was featured

Producers Hint Batman May Never Return To Television

In the Gotham series finale, viewers were provided a glimpse of the time when the characters had developed into their forms most remember either from the comics or other media.However, according to a story posted at SyFyWire, there is a likelihood…See More
2 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters's blog post was featured

Consumer Reports Recommends Sunscreens That Seep Poison Into Your Bloodstream

Story at-a-glanceAll of the recommended products in Consumer Reports Best Sunscreens for 2019 report contain oxybenzoneA pilot study by the U.S. FDA shows four common active ingredients in sunscreen — avobenzone, oxybenzone, octocrylene and ecamsule…See More
3 hours ago
Raz Putin's blog post was featured

Breaking:"Judiciary Committee ranking member Doug Collins released the transcripts of nine key figures from the House investigation into DOJ and FBI political activity."

Looks like there could be some worthwhile reading here folks let's hope. Breaking:"Judiciary Committee ranking member Doug…See More
3 hours ago
Raz Putin favorited Chris of the family Masters's photo
3 hours ago
Chris of the family Masters's 2 photos were featured
3 hours ago
Diana's 4 photos were featured
3 hours ago
Raz Putin favorited Chris of the family Masters's photo
3 hours ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted