NH DMV wrong to deny "COPSLIE" license plate

Here's an interesting article on the 1st amendment. A man who wanted to display on his license plate "COPSLIE" was wrongfully denied by the Department of Motor Vehicles. Well, the state Supreme Court has ruled that the DMV acted unconstitutionally in denying the man his right in political free speech.
                                                    Courtesy of Union Leader


CONCORD - "COPSLIE" may soon be gracing a vehicle owned by David Montenegro, now known as "human," after the state Supreme Court ruled Wednesday that the DMV regulation cited for rejecting his vanity license plate request was unconstitutional and violated his right to free speech.


The state Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) disapproved Montenegro's request for the plate four years ago because, it said, the phrase was "insulting."

"human," 35, who lists his mailing address in Durham and who legally changed his name to "human," contended his vanity plate selection is an expression of political speech protected under the Constitution.

Gilles Bissonnette, staff attorney with the New Hampshire  Civil Liberties Union - which filed an amicus brief in the case, said the NHACLU believes human should receive a plate since the Supreme Court struck down the DMV regulation cited to deny it.

The court remanded the case back to Strafford County Superior Court, "presumably to address whether he will get the plate but we believe he should get it," Bissonnette said.

Attorney Anthony J. Galdieri with Nixon Peabody LLP argued the case on behalf of the NHCLU.

The Attorney General's Office, which filed a brief on behalf of the DMV, argued in its brief that a vanity license plate is government property and the state's rule "is reasonable in light of the government's intended purpose of identifying individual vehicles in a manner which does not imply that the government approves of combinations of letters that are offensive."

The court, however, sided with human, ruling the state regulation prohibiting vanity registration plates that are "offensive to good taste" on its face "authorizes or even encourages arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement," (see MacElman, 154 N.H. at 207) and is, therefore, unconstitutionally vague.

"Accordingly, we hold that, on its face, this restriction violates the right to free speech guaranteed by Part I, Article 22 of the State Constitution."

human, who argued the case before the high court, wanted the vanity plate to protest state government corruption. The DMV, however, bans plates that "a reasonable person would find offensive to good taste." The New Hampshire Civil Liberties Union, which joined in the appeal, argued that the regulation is unconstitutionally vague.

Senior Assistant Attorney General Richard Head, who argued the case before the Supreme Court, maintained state employees denied the plate because it disparages an entire class of people - police officers.

The case began on May 4, 2010, when human, as Montenegro, applied for the "COPSLIE" vanity plate. He stated on the application that the intended meaning was "cops lie." That same day, the DMV rejected the application because several DMV employees believed the text to be "insulting."

Montenegro appealed to the director of the DMV in writing on May 5, 2010. Two days later, the director denied the appeal concluding that "a reasonable person would find COPSLIE offensive to good taste." State administrative rule, Saf-C 514.61(c)(3) says a vanity plate shall not be "ethnically, racially or which a reasonable person would find offensive to good taste."

On Aug 30, Montenegro again applied for the COPSLIE vanity plate - his first choice - but also requested alternate plates, in order of preference: GR8GOVT; LUVGOVT; GOVTSUX; SEALPAC, and GOVTLAZ. The DMV again denied his first choice as "insulting" but issued him a vanity registration plate for the alternative choice of "GR8GOVT." That same day human obtained a regular issued plate.

Bissonnette said the DMV rejecting COPSLIE, but approving GR8GOVT is the definition of a "government official using a vague regulation to discriminate against the message of the speaker and engage in viewpoint discrimination.

He sought an injunction directing the DMV to issue him the COPSLIE vanity plate, as well as a permanent injunction enjoining the DMV from recalling it. He also argued the state regulation violated his right to free speech. On July 3, 2012, then Strafford County Superior Court Judge John Lewis ruled in favor of the DMV, finding no federal or state violation of human's freedom of speech rights.

The court agreed with human that the state regulation is unconstitutionally vague because it is "so loosely constrained" that it "authorizes or even encourages arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement."

The court also turned to the dictionary to define what the words "offensive" "good" and "taste" means. Taken together, the court said the definitions lead to various potential interpretations of what that phrase means.

"For example, one such interpretation could be that no vanity registration plates are allowed that are 'insulting to the standard of morality or virtue of individual preference,'" the court said. "This reading alone demonstrates the arbitrariness of determining whether a vanity registration plate is ' offensive to good taste.' "
Derek Wood at 10:01 AM

Views: 159

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by noblsht on May 15, 2014 at 8:59pm

That will not work that is suggestive/Sexual innuendo, use your head, it will be denied on that basis alone, cops lie etc. is all good. Will not Be misconstrued as vulgar

Comment by John Carman on May 14, 2014 at 7:47pm

That's interesting!! I am ex-law enforcement and a Whistle-blower so I have a different perspective on today's law enforcement as it is usually corrupt. I have been exposing corruption since 1995.

Law enforcement humor is much different than most and similar to military cause we/they have been in harms way on a daily basis or Death, etc...and we have see the worst in Humans. 

I bet someone could have fun with this one??? (7 letters & numbers for a plate)

Let's see: COPSUCK, CopsSuck, CopsBlow, (I know I know, some have 8 but what the hell)

FedsSuck, Fedsuk, Fedsblow, Fedsblo, FBIsht!, FBIShit, FBICunt,CIADick, FBIBtch, FedBich, JudgCnt,

JudgDck, JudgFek,FekJudg, Judgcok, USABich(for U.S. Attorney) U.S.A.Bch, AUSABch,(assistant U.S. Attorney Bitch) AUSAAnl, U.S.A.ANAL, etc.....

Have fun !!! Can you come up with something else and unique that expresses your Freedom of Speech?

Latest Activity

Central Scrutinizer favorited James T. Kirk's video
8 minutes ago
Kim is now a member of 12160 Social Network
13 minutes ago
James Roberts favorited James T. Kirk's video
20 minutes ago
James T. Kirk posted videos
27 minutes ago
Diana posted photos
35 minutes ago
Diana commented on Diana's photo
Thumbnail

Idiot Makes Cover

"It is the April Fools' Day Edition.  I like dd's cover better."
40 minutes ago
James Roberts posted photos
42 minutes ago
oldranger_68 favorited James Roberts's photo
1 hour ago
oldranger_68 favorited James Roberts's photo
1 hour ago
Diana's 2 photos were featured
1 hour ago
cheeki kea's photo was featured
1 hour ago
Raz Putin favorited cheeki kea's photo
1 hour ago
James Roberts's 2 photos were featured
1 hour ago
oldranger_68 favorited James Roberts's photo
1 hour ago
oldranger_68 favorited James Roberts's photo
1 hour ago
oldranger_68 favorited James Roberts's photo
1 hour ago

Please remember this website is supported by your donations...

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2015 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted