An Estonian news site was responsible for abusive comments posted by its readers, the European Court of Human Rights has ruled.

An Estonian news site was responsible for abusive comments posted by its readers, the European Court of Human Rights has ruled. Though the ruling appears to contradict provisions within European law giving such sites safe harbor, a legal expert said its impact likely will be limited.

The unanimous ruling from seven judges suggested that if a commercial site allowed anonymous comments, it is both practical and reasonable for the site owner to be held responsible for them.

The case centers on an article Delfi SA, one of Estonia’s most popular news sites, ran in January 2006, regarding a ferry company’s decision to change its routes. The change delayed the opening of cheaper ice roads to outlying islands.

Users added some 185 comments, about 20 of which contained personal threats and offensive language toward the ferry company’s majority shareholder. The ferry company sued and in April 2006 was awarded 5,000 Estonian kroon (about $430).

After exhausting appeals within Estonia, Delfi appealed, unsuccessfully, to the ECHR.

Yesterday’s ECHR ruling said: “The applicant company [Delfi], by publishing the article in question, could have realized that it might cause negative reactions against the shipping company and its managers and that, considering the general reputation of comments on the Delfi news portal, there was a higher-than-average risk that the negative comments could go beyond the boundaries of acceptable criticism and reach the level of gratuitous insult or hate speech.”

The court also said that Delfi had a commercial interest in having an active comment section. “The number of comments had an effect on the number of visits to the portal and on the applicant company’s revenue from advertisements published on the portal. Thus, the applicant company had an economic interest in the comments.”

The court found that the Estonian courts hadn’t infringed Delfi’s rights.

While the ruling appears troublesome to site operators, in fact, it is not as problematic as it might seem.

A spokeswoman for the ECHR made it clear that the ruling was only in relation to the particulars of Estonian law and was not applicable to other cases, except by way of case law. “All this tells us is about Estonian law,” she said. “It is not applicable to other countries.”

According to Jonathan Ball, a lawyer at London-based Norton Rose Fulbright LLP, by going to the ECHR, which is not a body of the European Union, rather than the European Court of Justice, which is, the ruling concerns only the human rights involved, not the provisions of the European directive that can extend to site owners safe harbor for users’ comments.

“The court was not looking at the law of defamation in Estonia, nor at the safe-harbor directive,” Mr. Ball said. “Does this set some sort of precedent in international law [on comments]? No, I don’t think it does. Had it gone the other way, it wouldn’t have had that effect, either. If you commit defamation, that is a matter for national courts. Good luck in bringing that to the court of Human Rights.”

Delfi did not respond to requests for comment.

The judgment isn’t final. During the three-month period following its delivery, any party may request that the case be referred to the Grand Chamber of the Court. If such a request is made, a panel of five judges considers whether the case deserves further examination. If it believes so, the Grand Chamber will hear the case and deliver a final judgment. If not, the original judgment becomes final on that day.

http://blogs.wsj.com/tech-europe/2013/10/11/news-site-held-responsi...

Views: 157

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

oh chit

RSS

"Destroying the New World Order"

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

Latest Activity

Doc Vega posted a blog post

What Has Tulsi Gabbard Been Up to? Oh, Just catching Obama's ass ordering Intelligence Agencies to Commit Treason!

As we can always expect, the mainstream media will do anything they can to undermine the Trump…See More
14 hours ago
Burbia commented on tjdavis's blog post The Jewish Couple That Taught Bob Dylan Hebrew and Introduced Him to Zionism
"Haaretz put this story behind a pay wall. Sali Ariel and Terry Noble were the names of the couple…"
17 hours ago
William Heckman is now a member of 12160 Social Network
19 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on tjdavis's photo
22 hours ago
cheeki kea commented on cheeki kea's video
Thumbnail

This Woman DESTROYED Harley-Davidson's Future Forever

"It's a sad day on the highway. But I guess the show must go on. Watch out for the ruination of…"
23 hours ago
cheeki kea posted a video

This Woman DESTROYED Harley-Davidson's Future Forever

This Woman DESTROYED Harley-Davidson's Future ForeverWelcome to Ride Radar – Your Frontline Source for Motorcycle Deals, Trends & Market Mayhem.Looking for t...
yesterday
tjdavis posted a photo
yesterday
Burbia posted a status
"Who knew releasing the MLK files and literally deflecting, it ends up implicating himself with the Epstein Files."
Tuesday
Burbia posted a video

Dan Bilzerian DEMOLISHES MAGA Nutjob Patrick Bet-David on His Own Show

Watch as two powerhouse personalities collide in this no-holds-barred debate on one of the world’s most contentious issues. Patrick Bet-David, known for his ...
Monday
Doc Vega's 7 blog posts were featured
Sunday
tjdavis's 2 blog posts were featured
Sunday
Less Prone favorited tjdavis's blog post Track AIPAC
Sunday
FREEDOMROX's blog post was featured

MRNA VACCINES: Question

Hello my fellow sojourners,I know it has been five years since the Plandemic, but one question has…See More
Sunday
Less Prone favorited FREEDOMROX's blog post MRNA VACCINES: Question
Sunday
cheeki kea commented on cheeki kea's photo
Saturday
cheeki kea posted a photo
Saturday
Doc Vega posted blog posts
Friday
Doc Vega commented on Doc Vega's blog post Marjory Taylor Green Proposes Bill Abolishing Geoengineering or Weather Modification
"cheeki kea Marjory is in a daily battle with Democrats on the hill constantly coming up with more…"
Friday
Doc Vega posted blog posts
Jul 16
Mr. Sizzle favorited Less Prone's video
Jul 15

© 2025   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted