A Museum of Tolerance we don't need; The Simon Wiesenthal Center should abandon its plan to build a facility on the site of a Muslim cemetery in Jerusalem


A Muslim cemetery near the construction site of the Museum of Tolerance in downtown Jerusalem. (Dan Balilty / Associated Press / February 10, 2010)

A Muslim cemetery near the construction site of the Museum of Tolerance in downtown Jerusalem. (Dan Balilty / Associated Press / February 10, 2010)

The Simon Wiesenthal Center's plan to construct an outpost of Los Angeles' Museum of Tolerance atop the most important Muslim cemetery in Jerusalem is temporarily in disarray. This presents an opportunity to call on the center to abandon this outrageous project once and for all.

The site in question is Ma'man Allah, or the Mamilla Cemetery, which had been in continuous use for centuries until 1948, when hundreds of thousands of Palestinians were expelled or driven into flight and their private property, including Ma'man Allah, was handed over to Jewish users.

Like Muslim and Christian sites throughout Israel -- which, as a 2009 State Department report pointed out, implements protections only for Jewish holy sites -- the cemetery has long been threatened. Parts of it have been used as a roadway, parking lots, building sites and Israel's Independence Park. Among the trees in the park, Palestinian tombstones can still be seen, eerily and all too appropriately.

In 2002, the Wiesenthal Center -- which had been given part of the cemetery by the city of Jerusalem -- announced that architect Frank Gehry would design a complex to be called the Center for Human Dignity-Museum of Tolerance Jerusalem. Ground was broken in 2004. Palestinian and Muslim concerns were ignored until a lawsuit led to the suspension of excavation in 2006. In 2008, the Israeli Supreme Court -- dismissing the appeals not only of Palestinians with relatives buried there but also the protests of Jews appalled by desecration of any cemetery -- cleared the way for the project.

The center claims to see nothing wrong with erecting what its leader, Rabbi Marvin Hier, calls "a great landmark promoting the principles of mutual respect and social responsibility" on top of what remains of another people's cemetery. It has resorted to endless dodges to support its claim.

To those protesting construction on ancient cemetery land, the center says it's merely using a part of the site that has been a parking lot for years. To Jews outraged at desecration, it says, in effect, that different standards apply to Muslim cemeteries than to Jewish ones. To Muslim clergy and legal scholars who insist on the inviolability of cemeteries in Islam, the center disagrees, in essence claiming that it knows more about Islamic jurisprudence than they do. To those who protest today, the center asks where they were in 1960, when an Islamic judge approved Israel's construction of the parking lot (it does not, however, mention that he was a state employee, nor that he was subsequently removed from office for corruption).

To archaeologists who say the site should be spared construction, the center says that only a couple hundred bodies needed to be moved. And with reference to Palestinians who have filed legal actions and persisted in expressing anxiety over their families' remains, Hier had this message just last month: "The case is over; get used to it."

That was his paraphrase of the high court's dismissal of a final appeal made by Palestinian families based on the testimony of Gideon Suleimani, the chief archaeologist at the museum site. Suleimani said that the Israel Antiquities Authority withheld from the court his opinion that construction should not be approved, and that the site still contains four layers of Muslim graves dating from the 12th century. "We're talking about tens of thousands of skeletons under the ground there," noted Suleimani.

Last month, Gehry announced that he had decided to pull out of the project, citing other commitments. At the same time, the center said it was scaling back the museum; it is short of its original $200-million fundraising target. Now the center lacks an architect and a plan. Hence the opportunity to stop this project.

This week, moreover, Palestinians with relatives buried in the cemetery made a last-ditch effort to end its continued desecration. They appealed directly to the United Nations, pointing out that the desecration violates international conventions forbidding discrimination and protecting cultural heritage, the manifestation of religious beliefs and the right to culture and family.

Protecting the cemetery should never have become a legal issue. This project is something that any decent human being should recognize as wrong. And it can still be reversed -- if the Wiesenthal Center can be persuaded to turn "tolerance" and "human dignity" into principles for action, not just empty slogans.

For all its sanctimoniousness, the center now presides over a big hole from which scores of bones have been unearthed. Those remains were disinterred without respect. As Suleimani put it: "The Muslim dead have no one to defend them." It is not, however, too late to safeguard the rest of those as yet undisturbed.

In wanting to lay the dead to rest, however, we should think also of the living. Displacing living people -- something Israel does every single day -- is hardly any better than displacing dead ones. And this disgraceful episode is only part of a much longer history of displacement and dispossession dating to 1948.

The real lesson of Ma'man Allah and the museum project is this: Peace will come to Palestine/Israel only when the blind insistence on displacement ends and both peoples are allowed to belong to the same land.

Saree Makdisi is a professor of English and comparative literature at UCLA. He is the author of, among other books, "Palestine Inside Out: An Everyday Occupation."


http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/la-oe-makdisi12-2010feb12,0,105...

Views: 26

Comment

You need to be a member of 12160 Social Network to add comments!

Join 12160 Social Network

Comment by Marklar on February 12, 2010 at 5:47pm
Note: It was a representative of the racist Simon Weisenthal Center that who famously showed a Powerpoint presentation which mixed images of Jihadist Muslim websites with images from the website for Architects and Engineers for 911 Truth during the hearings on the Violent Radicalization and Homegrown Terrorism Prevention Act of 2007 (S.1959 / H.R.1955), sponsored by Jane Harman and co-sponsord by David Reichert.

"Destroying the New World Order"

THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING THE SITE!

mobile page

12160.info/m

12160 Administrators

 

TOP CONTENT THIS WEEK

Latest Activity

oldranger_68 favorited Chris of the family Masters's blog post God Demands America Remove 'In God We Trust' From Currency
23 minutes ago
oldranger_68 favorited James Roberts's photo
25 minutes ago
oldranger_68 favorited Maas's photo
25 minutes ago
oldranger_68 favorited James Roberts's photo
26 minutes ago
oldranger_68 favorited James Roberts's photo
26 minutes ago
Boris commented on Boris's status
"Sometimes the light's all shinin' on me, Other times I can barely see. Lately it occurs…"
37 minutes ago
Boris commented on Boris's status
40 minutes ago
James Roberts's video was featured

Dumbest Jeffery Epstein Coverage On Corporate News

17 American intelligence agencies agree!
44 minutes ago
Diana favorited Old Denmark's video
44 minutes ago
Boris favorited Old Denmark's video
44 minutes ago
Mrs. Tif Morgan replied to Mrs. Tif Morgan's discussion Control Through Concepts: Will World Governments Confiscate Gold?
"Lets see if I can make the comment stay this time...:)   Click on a state to see it's…"
50 minutes ago
Diana commented on Boris's video
1 hour ago
Boris favorited Old Denmark's video
1 hour ago
Old Denmark posted videos
1 hour ago
Diana commented on Boris's video
Thumbnail

Antifa Left Wing "Protesters" Pepper Spray and Throw Rocks at Homeless People in Olympia, WA

"MSM won't air this footage - Nope, the problem is the "Far right extremist groups"."
1 hour ago
Diana favorited Boris's video
1 hour ago

© 2019   Created by truth.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

content and site copyright 12160.info 2007-2019 - all rights reserved. unless otherwise noted